Ahh new love! If you're spending Valentine's Day with someone special this year, you're pretty lucky. But finding the perfect gift that appropriately honors the amount of time you've spent together can feel more like a burden than a blessing at times.
What gift lets your new significant other know how special they are, but that isn't cliché? One that feels important, but is not too expensive (or too cheap)? It can be tough to walk that line when you're in a new relationship.
Luckily, you've got the Shop TODAY team in your corner with great Valentine's Day gifts for him and for her. From options for gamers, travelers, foodies and every type of partner in between, we've curated picks that are perfect for any new relationship — whether you've been together six weeks or six months.
What to get for your first Valentine’s Day together
We go together like... feel free to fill in the blank. Part of Hallmark’s adorable “better together” collection, this set comes with pancake and syrup plush toys that connect to each other via magnets. The collection also includes items like burgers and fries and peanut butter and jelly.
One of the best parts about a new relationship is that getting-to-know-you phase where you can’t stop asking each other questions. This creative game makes that process a little bit easier and comes with 200 playing cards that help you embark on meaningful conversations and perform comedic challenges. You can also play it with other couples!
It’s easier than ever to stock up for your next movie night or road trip, thanks to this variety pack of snacks. From gummy fish, peach rings, sour bears, caramels and more, there’ll be no shortage of sweets for your sugar.
Roses are red, violets are blue... flowers are a perfect way to help you win some major brownie points this Valentine’s Day, it’s oh so true. A dozen red roses are kind of a milestone for every new relationship, and this set makes it easy to order with a click of a button. You can select a simple bouquet or jazz things up with a vase, candy and plush.
Hosting a cheese and wine night? This baked brie board will have your guest in love. It comes in four different flavors and each one is filled with different ingredients like blueberries, chocolate and truffle. And if they’re a foodie, they will appreciate the heart details.
Valentine’s Day gifts for a new relationship
If you’re planning on cooking together, keep the theme all the way down to the pasta with these heart-shaped shells. You can go for a classic alla vodka dish or recreate this creamy Brussels sprout recipe.
Can’t decide on a place for date night? A simple roll of this food decider dice takes the pressure off both of you. It helps gamify what can be a tough choice for couples.
Planning a date night in? Set the mood with these heart-shaped pizzas from Detroit Style Pizza Co. that can be shipped anywhere in the country. Each pack comes with three pizzas — one cheese, one pepperoni and one deluxe (pepperoni, mushrooms, ham, red onions and green peppers) — that each serve two people. Yum!
First Valentine’s Day gifts for a new boyfriend
Named one of the “most popular” products on their site, Carhartt’s logo sleeve hoodie is one gift that will be hard not to steal. Offered in a wide range of sizes and colors, this cotton-polyester blend option is both warm and easy to wear.
This hoodie offers “versatility,” according to the brand, meaning that you could wear it to layer up when working outside or just to relax inside.
If you’re looking forward to spending more quality time with each other, cooking is a great way to bring you closer together. This set from Brightland makes all the difference in your cooking game, according to Shop TODAY social media editorial assistant Annie Shigo. Enjoy two bottles of the most popular olive oils and two fruit-infused vinegars.
If it’s time for them to upgrade their winter wardrobe, this insulated cardigan from Snow Peak is perfect for both indoor and outdoor wear. According to the brand, the deep red color is inspired by Japanese maple trees and the shell is water-resistant.
First Valentine’s Day gifts for a new girlfriend
Sometimes the best gifts are the ones that people can use for self-care. This bath bomb from Lush is handmade (with love) and features a scent of strawberries and cream.
Pretty much anyone could use a to-go cup upgrade, and this bestseller with its sparkly silicone sleeve is just as cheerful as it is useful. Plus, it comes in tons of colors in case sparkly and pink isn’t her thing.
If she’s into doing her own nails or loves to experiment with press-ons, this set from Never Have I Ever will get her excited. Each set comes with 24 hand-made nails, one nail glue, 24 glue sticker tabs, a cuticle stick and an alcohol pad.
People who take their coffee pretty seriously know that finding the right cup to hold your drink can make it that much more enjoyable. Yeti has you covered with this durable option that features a handle and double-wall vacuum insulation that keeps drinks cold or hot. The stainless steel mug is also dishwasher-safe and tailgate-ready!
These oversized, statement-making earrings bring heart jewelry to the next level. Not only are they Valentine’s Day festive, but they’re also super stylish for year-round wear.
If she’s anything like associate editor Kamari Stewart-Jackson, she won’t be able to stop thinking about this asymmetrical shoulder bag from Status Anxiety. “It’s the perfect brown color and is simultaneously large enough to fit the essentials but small enough to not be an inconvenience,” she says.
Easy Valentine’s Day gifts for new couples
We dare you to find us a person who doesn’t love playful socks. While you’re trying to think of someone, let us introduce you to these rad socks that can be customized with up to five faces and a phrase of your choice. They come in 20 color options and only cost $8, so it’s a great option for a brand-new relationship where you don’t want to drop too much cash so early on.
Van Leeuwen makes some of the most indulgent and incredible ice creams — and you can have it delivered right to your front door to eat with your heart-shaped spoons. Choose from flavors like Earl Grey Tea, Marionberry Cheesecake, Sicilian Pistachio and more. They also make delish vegan ice creams!
How cute are these? Bundle these with some delicious ice cream (like the Van Leeuwen pints above!) for the ultimate dessert night for two.
Best Lego gifts for Valentine’s Day
Whether you are in a situationship or coupled up, Lego sets are a great Valentine's Day gift that you both can share in and enjoy. Model and TV personality Tyler Cameron recently shared a few tips on how to impress your partner this Valentine's Day along with his favorite Lego set ideas for new couples.
“I love getting a nice Lego set. I have a Land Rover Defender and I put away my phone when I am about to focus and build one piece at a time, three hours go by and you feel so much better,” Cameron shared.
Celebrate the holiday by gifting this delicate heart ornament to your new sweetie. They can add it to their gallery wall or Valentine's Day-inspired tree. The best part? It's easy to build!
If they don't have a green thumb, you might be better off opting for these Lego roses instead of the real thing. It doubles as a fun date idea for quiet nights and beautiful decor for your home.
"Lego roses last forever and are a great idea for new couples. And probably last longer than a relationship. I know a lot of men and women that would love a Lego set," says Cameron.
If they're a Disney fan, they'll immediately be enamored by this adorable Lego version of Eve and Wall-E. At $20, it's the perfect price to get one for each of you to keep in your own homes.
"I was a huge Lego builder growing up. I would get Lego sets every time, such as the Lego Star Wars collection and Lego basketball collection. So, if you are in a 'situationship' don't go crazy. You can give a nice gesture without going too crazy," says Cameron.
If your partner is into plants, this is the perfect Lego set to gift them this Valentine’s Day. With 771 pieces, they can build a succulent display or arrange them into small groups around their apartment.
“The Botanical collection is a great idea and I didn’t realize how many people are collecting the flowers and botanicals out of my group of friends,” adds Cameron.
If they don't exactly have a green thumb but still love receiving fresh flowers, this set offers the best of both worlds! It comes with a dozen real red roses paired with the Lego roses set, so that you can have them on display long after the real ones are past their prime.
How we chose
The Shop TODAY editors and writers search the internet to find the best products out there that would make great gifts for people. We use our own personal experiences with products and brands to make shopping easier for our readers.
Don’t forget to check out Shop TODAY’s other gift guides to find the perfect Valentine’s Day gifts on Amazon, for long-distance relationships, for new couples and more.
