There are numerous types of outerwear on the market, including wool coats, rain jackets, cardigans and more that keep us warm and stylish during the colder months. But, trench coats and peacoats tend to be the most reached for and have been sartorial standouts. However, there are some distinctions that make them differ and not just in their design.
"Peacoats are typically shorter and made for colder weather, unlike trench coats, which are made with water-resistant properties," says New York-based stylist, Liz Teich.
However, there are other key factors that differentiate the styles. From the materials to their button closures, design and even length, both outerwear categories are far from similar. "A trench is typically knee-length or longer, creating a sleek silhouette, whereas a peacoat is shorter and more structured," says style expert Julie Kraus.
As someone who owns over 30 coats, I am particularly biased toward trench coats, but peacoats also deserve stage presence. Since peacoats are made with a heavier wool fabric, they are more appropriate for colder days. At the same time, trench coats are ideal for in-between weather, especially when you're transitioning from winter to spring.
Read below to learn what the style experts have to say about both outerwear pieces and which one is right for your daily looks.
Trench coats vs. peacoats
The main differences between a trench coat and a peacoat lie in the material, design and care, according to celebrity stylist and author of “Style for Everybody,” Kim Appelt.
- Material: “Trench coats are typically made from cotton gabardine or a water-resistant blend; peacoats are thick wool for warmth.”
- Design: “Trench coats are longer with a belt, offering a cinched silhouette, while peacoats are cropped, boxier, and feature large buttons.”
- Care: “Trench coats require more delicate cleaning due to their fabric, while peacoats can handle a little more wear and dry cleaning.”
What is a trench coat?
A traditional trench coat has epaulets, gun flaps on the front and a British-inspired style, according to Teich. "A trench coat is a lightweight, usually belted coat with a structured collar, originally designed for British Army officers in World War I. Made from water-resistant fabric like cotton gabardine, it’s the ultimate all-weather classic," adds Appelt.
Their effortless and sophisticated style offers a seamless transition from day to night. They come in different materials, but ideally, trench coats are made with waterproof or water-resistant materials. "They are lightweight, often water-resistant and designed for layering in transitional weather," shares Kraus.
Trench coats approved by experts
Everyday coat: J.Crew Rain-or-shine Trench
- Lightweight
- Chic appearance
- Material feels like plastic
Size: XXXS-3X | Colors: 3 | Material: 100% recycled polyamide
Teich recommends investing in a trench coat as it never goes out of style. For an affordable option, she recommends J.Crew, for their easy-to-style and versatile options. For a chic twist on a rain jacket, opt for this trench coat featuring storm flaps to keep the rain away.
White elegance: Mango Long Oversized Double-Breasted Trench Coat
- Chic silhouette
- Lightweight
- Limited plus sizes
Size: XXS-4XL | Colors: 3 | Material: 62% cotton, 38% polyester
For an elegant statement, Kraus recommends this trench coat. "This trench is a perfect blend of timeless style and modern ease. I love that it comes in three versatile color options, making it easy to find one that suits different wardrobes and personal styles. The contrast button detail on the lighter version is especially striking — it adds a polished, elevated touch that makes the coat feel fresh and unique," says Kraus.
Classic fit: Everlane The Modern Trench Coat
- Ideal for spring
- Lightweight
- Oversized fit
Size: XXS-XXXL | Colors: 4 | Material: 100% recycled polyester
Kraus likes this style if you're looking for a minimalist and cool, everyday look. You can easily layer it with sweaters underneath as the coat offers an oversized fit. According to shoppers, this design is made from a durable material and fits perfectly around the arms.
All covered: & Other Stories Trench Jacket
- Covers the neck
- Easy to button
- Oversized fit
Size: XS-L | Colors: 1 | Material: 51% polyester, 49% viscose
"A fresh take on a classic piece — I love how this trench from & Other Stories balances structure and movement effortlessly. The inner detail that allows you to cinch and define the waistline is such a game-changer — it creates a flattering shape while still feeling relaxed and modern. The voluminous sleeves keep it on trend, adding just the right amount of drama without overwhelming the look," says Kraus.
Trench coats approved by editors
Effortless chic: Forever 21 Belted Faux Leather Trench Coat
- Comfortable
- Trendy
- Limited sizes available
Size: XS-XL | Colors: 1 | Material: 94% polyester, 6% spandex
Associate editor Kamari Stewart has owned this Forever 21 trench coat for six months and loves it. "Every time I tell someone it's from Forever21, they can't believe it and are immediately interested in getting their own. It's definitely going to become a staple in my wardrobe this spring. I also love that they offer it in plus sizes because I was able to get the best fit without sacrificing any of the style," says Stewart. It already sold out in the plus size but they have standard sizes available.
Business ready: London Fog Women's Double-Breasted Hooded Trench Coat
- Flattering
- Not too heavy
- Has a hood
- Not entirely waterproof
Size: XXS-XXL | Colors: 4 | Material: Cotton and polyester
This was a Christmas gift associate editor Shanon Garlin received last Christmas and it’s the "perfect in-between season coat to keep you warm and protect you against the elements like wind and rain. The style is ultra-chic, has a waist-synching belt and the length is pretty long; it makes me feel like a spy. I also love that it has a hood to help further protect you from rain, too."
Garlin also says, "I was surprised at how deep the pockets are, too. You probably could fit a small umbrella, wallet and your phone!"
Luxurious feel: Dynamite Military Faux Leather Trench Coat
- Smooth texture
- Lightweight
- Buttons are delicate
Size: XXS-XL | Colors: 2 | Material: 100% Polyurethane
I [Espinal] own this trench coat in two colors, and it's one of my go-to's for the spring season. It's lightweight, has deep pockets and is easy to style. Plus, the coat has a soft texture, a relaxed fit and a bit of a stretch in case you're layering. It feels expensive without the price tag and after several washes, the coat has kept its shine and structure.
What is a peacoat?
Typically, a peacoat has a double-breasted base and is reminiscent of a sailor's uniform since it was worn by Americans and Europeans in the Navy. "A peacoat is a shorter, wool coat with a structured, double-breasted design and wide lapels. Originally a naval staple, it’s made from thick wool for warmth and durability, making it ideal for colder months," says Kraus.
While most peacoats are double-breasted, there are some variations with zipper closures and longer hems.
Peacoats recommended by experts
Upgraded peacoat: Marcella Melanie Wool Coat
- Ideal for colder days
- Great for layering
- Chunky look
Size: XS-XXXL | Colors: 3 | Material: 100% virgin wool with viscose lining
Kraus recommends this peacoat if you want more of an elevated feel with added structure. "This coat is a fresh, modern take on the classic peacoat, with a sleek, streamlined silhouette that feels effortlessly sophisticated. I love how it ditches the traditional boxy shape, making it incredibly flattering while still maintaining that structured wool look. The minimalist design and subtle details make it feel elevated and versatile—perfect for layering over everything from casual denim to polished workwear," shares Kraus.
Other peacoats to shop
Casually fitted: H&M Short Pea Coat
- Great for layering
- Good for business attire
- Runs big
Size: XS-XXL | Colors: 4 | Material: 90% polyester, 10% other fibers
If your goal is to stay warm yet elegant, opt for this affordable choice from H&M. It comes in four neutral hues and has an oversized fit, ideal for those who want to layer it with thick sweaters.
Elegance elevated: Ann Taylor Twill Double-Breasted Peacoat
- Great for business casual
- Good quality
- Runs large
Size: XXS-XXL | Colors: 1 | Material: 100% polyester
This peacoat is warm, elegant and offers a structured silhouette. According to shoppers, this design goes with everything and the buttons at the cuff open, unlike other coats, which feature buttons just for adornment. Some say it fits large but offers a sophisticated flair, regardless.
Warm feels: Quince Italian Wool Short Peacoat
- Button closure
- Feels warm
- Boxy cut
Size: XS-XL | Colors: 3 | Material: 80% Italian wool, 20% nylon
While the J.Crew style recommended by Appelt is sold out, this Quince peacoat is a close alternative. It features a luxe design with a double-breasted front closure and a short length that pairs well with business casual clothes. Shoppers say this is an ideal choice for petite women or those looking for a loose fit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Trench coats are very versatile and pair well with many looks. "For a chic, everyday outfit, layer a classic beige trench over jeans, a relaxed T-shirt, and flats. For a more elevated look, drape it over a dress or a tailored suit with heels. Since trenches are lightweight, they’re perfect for transitional layering — can be belted for a modern look or worn open for an effortless feel," says Kraus.
However, it's not necessary to wear a belt when you don a trench coat, but you can tie it in different ways. "You can either do a square knot or a half bow when wearing a trench coat. The traditional rule is to either go one or two inches above a dress hem, or you can go longer otherwise," says Teich.
Since peacoats feature a more structured design, they can be paired effortlessly with many different pieces. Peacoats look great with "tailored trousers and a turtleneck for a sharp, put-together feel or casually with denim and sneakers for an easy weekend outfit," says Appelt.
They are also great for cool-weather styling. "They pair effortlessly with jeans, a turtleneck, and boots for a cozy look. For a more refined outfit, wear one over tailored trousers and loafers. Because of their shorter length, peacoats create a balanced silhouette that works especially well for petites, as they don’t overwhelm the frame," adds Kraus.
How we chose
We selected trench coats and peacoats based on the recommended features by stylists, and selected options tested by editors. We also considered popular brands and some affordable options with numerous sizes available.
Meet the experts
- Liz Teich is a New York-based stylist and style expert. She’s contributed to a handful of Shop TODAY pieces, including commenting on why capri pants are trending (again!).
- Juli Kraus is a fashion stylist and on-air style expert.
- Kim Appelt is a personal and celebrity stylist and author of the Amazon bestselling book “Style for Everybody,” which focuses on creating a classic and timeless wardrobe for individuals based on their body, style and life.
