There’s nothing like a good glass of wine at the end of a long day. I’m partial to white wines but sometimes the occasion calls for red. And to get the most out of your red wine, you’ll need a decanter.
To fully understand the why and how behind using wine decanters, I consulted three expert sommeliers. Plus, they shared the ones that have earned their seals of approval.
The best wine decanters, according to experts
Sommeliers Keith Wallace and Jaime Haener both recommend this Riedel Cabernet decanter for a versatile, introductory model. “Made with crystal class and dishwasher-safe, its low profile can effortlessly fit alongside any size meal or table,” says Haener.
Sommelier Lee Musho is a fan of Glasvin’s decanter “because of its simplicity. It has a wide base which allows for aeration, as well as a long neck which can be used to hold the decanter while swirling — which helps to introduce more oxygen. It’s also chic but not too precious, and pretty affordable,” she says.
“If you’re gifting a decanter, I encourage researching independent glass artisans for one-of-a-kind, quality pieces with personality. I love the FLOW Decanters from Nate Cotterman, a North Carolina-based artist,” says Haener. “My favorite is the Tall Tilt, but you can choose from seven unique shapes.”
Your shortcut to editor approved picks
“My newest favorite is the ETO 750 Wine Decanter,” says Haener. “It’s a splurge, but has a great bonus feature and lifetime warranty. It has an appealing profile and functions well to decant and serve. Its patented design and premium materials can also preserve open wine for two weeks or more.”
If you’re willing to invest in a quality decanter, Musho suggests this one, calling it “gorgeous. It’s pricier but still a simple design that makes it easy to hold.”
More wine essentials
Taught by James Suckling, this MasterClass focuses on wine appreciation by teaching the skills of reading the label, honing your senses and conducting tastings.
For those who enjoy a chilled glass of wine, this insulated stainless steel tumbler is designed to keep the chill as you sip. It also comes with a lid so you can take your party outside and not worry about spilling.
“I’ve recently become a convert to the red wine fan club after trying this brand, and can confirm that you don’t need the priciest bottle to guarantee a great quality wine,” says editor Vivien Moon. This Cabernet Sauvignon from Ménage à Trois is made with grapes sourced within California’s North Coast which were barrel aged in French and American oak.
“It learns what you like and caters to your wants, which is really smart to me. I have tried the wines and was really impressed with the way it worked and how well it catered to my personal wine preference. This makes for a great gift for both the expert and the newbie,” says Moon of this subscription service. The first month of the service is currently offered at 50% off.
Did you know that the Shop TODAY-loved brand, Yeti, also made wine chillers? This pick comes in a variety of colors, has a silicone landing pad to keep the bottle safe and fits most wines and champagnes.
What to look for in a wine decanter
Here are the main things to consider when shopping for a wine decanter:
- Material. “Wine decanters are made from either glass, or crystal. Glass is thicker, sturdier and more likely to be dishwasher-safe. Glass is also more affordable, but often has a shorter lifespan. With proper care, a crystal decanter is more durable and elegant. It’s also the more aesthetic choice, with superior light refraction and thinner walls that allow for more intricate designs and customization,” says Haener.
- A large surface area. “A typical wine bottle has a thin neck, which means it has a small surface area for oxygen to touch the wine inside. You want to choose a decanter that drastically increases that surface area,” advises Musho. “There are ones with a wider, larger base which are best for really rich, bold red wines, and there are ones that have more of a narrow neck which allow for a gentle decanting and separation of sediment. I’d choose a wider-based decanter for a Napa Cab and a narrow neck decanter for a Burgundy.”
“The width will determine the surface area exposed to oxygen. So think about the wines you drink most often and how long,” adds Haener. - Ease of use. “They can look beautiful but be a hassle to fill, pour from and clean,” says Musho. “You also want to be able to pick it up and pour your wine, so you really do need something with either a narrow neck or a handle of some fashion,” adds Wallace.
- Easy to clean and dry. “I’d argue the number one quality of a good decanter is how quickly it dries after use,” says Haener. “Some intricate shapes and angles collect water, extending dry time and leaving water spots that can be difficult to reach.”
“The most common decanter failure is allowing wine residue to remain and slowly turn into a biology experiment,” adds Wallace.
Frequently asked questions
The experts mostly mentioned using decanters for red wines, but Haener adds that complex white wines are also suitable. “Everyday wines that seem ‘just ok’ or a bit harsh when opened can benefit greatly by decanting 15-30 minutes before pouring,” she says.
“If your red wine tastes like someone replaced your saliva with sandpaper and apple seeds, then you really need to whip out your decanter,” adds Wallace. “Oftentimes, these are red wines like Cabernet Sauvignon, Syrah or Nebbiolo, including Barolo and Barbaresco.”
The experts agree on three wines that shouldn’t be used in a decanter:
- Sparkling wines. Simply put: “You’ll lose the sparkle!” says Musho.
- White wines. “There are some cases where decanting a white wine can be a good idea, but those are rare sommelier-level wines that you won’t be seeing at your local wine shop or restaurant,” notes Wallace.
- Rosé. “The majority of pink wine is made in a fresh, bright, ready-to-drink style. Decanting delicate, crisp wines can steal their vibrant charm,” says Haener.
Wallace says all of these wines become “dull and boring if exposed to oxygen for too long.”
The experts say there are two main reasons why you would or should use a wine decanter: to aerate the wine and to filter sediment.
Aerating, also known as “opening up a wine,” adds oxygen to the bottle to help “soften its tannins and help volatile compounds you don’t want (like notes of sulfur) to come off the wine,” explains Musho. Wallace adds, “Those young reds will always taste better if given a chance to breathe for an hour or so.”
Decanters can also be used to help filter out sediment from longer-aged bottles. “If a wine has been aged for many years (we’re talking ten or more), sediment will gather on the bottom. If you use a clear decanter, after pouring the wine in, you can easily see if any sediment has fallen to the bottom. Then when you pour glasses of the wine, you can stop pouring before the sediment comes out,” Musho says.
Ultimately, Haener says, “People should use a wine decanter when they are planning to serve an entire bottle and would like the wine at its most expressive from the very first glass.”
Each of the sommeliers we spoke to shared a few pieces of parting advice before you buy your own wine decanter:
“Always taste before deciding to decant. If the wine doesn’t need it, don’t waste your time,” advises Wallace. “If you do opt to decant, then make it count. For young red wines, maximize the splashing and swirling and give it at least 30 minutes in there before you pour your first glass.”
“And if you have an old wine with sediment, plan ahead,” he suggests. “That bottle needs to stand upright for at least 24 hours before decanting. Otherwise some of the sediment will still be floating around and end up in the decanter.”
Musho says decanters are “nice to have, but not a necessity. Unless you’re regularly drinking wines with a lot of age, or really bold reds, you don’t need one!”
Haener recommends buying a drying stand! “Unless your decanter is strictly for decor, it should be relatively practical to clean and maintain. Drying stands start around $15 online and keep your decanter secure while efficiently draining water. Just be sure to choose one with silicone pads that protect the glass.”
How we chose the best wine decanters
The Shop TODAY editors and writers search the internet to find the best products out there. We interview expert sources, comb through customer reviews and even use our own personal experiences to make shopping easier for our readers.
We curated a list of the best wine decanters via expert and editor recommendations.
Meet the experts
At Shop TODAY, our reporters interview a range of qualified sources and experts to capture a wide scope of perspectives on a given topic. We also ensure that all expert guidance and recommendations are provided independently and without any undisclosed financial conflicts of interest.
- Lee Musho is a certified sommelier and wine journalist based in New York who specializes in wine education, tasting and food pairings.
- Jaime Haener is a sommelier with over seven years of experience in wine importing and distribution, and has a WSET Level 3 Award in Wines.
- Keith Wallace is a former winemaker and the founder of the Wine School of Philadelphia.
Luseta Beauty Rice Water Jet-Set Strengthen & Shine Kit
Luseta Beauty Rice Water Jet-Set Strengthen & Shine Kit
























