While buzzier new materials like memory foam or cooling latex may catch your eye, there’s a reason why down pillows have been popular for as long as they have: They provide a luxury feel, as well as reliable softness and comfort.
But who should use one? And what should you keep in mind when shopping for one? We consulted with sleep experts to answer all of your burning questions.
Who are down pillows best for?
“Stomach sleepers and back sleepers who like a lower, softer pillow do really well on down, because it doesn’t push the neck up at an awkward angle,” says Chicago-based sleep consultant Kelly Murray. She adds, “It’s also great for the ‘pillow scrunchers,’ people who move their pillow around all night.”
But don’t worry, side sleepers! If you also want the luxury of having a down pillow on your bed, you just want to look for a firmer down pillow or “high fill” version, so your head stays level with your spine.
Keep reading to discover some expert and editor favorites, as well as down alternatives.
Best down pillows, according to an expert
Murray says that she recommends Helix’s pillow for side sleepers, as it features both down and feathers, which are separated into three chambers: The blend in the middle with both down and feathers, and two outer cores of plush down. “The feathers give it enough structure to hold your head up, and the down keeps it soft,” she says.
For someone who wants to splurge on “that luxury hotel feel,” Murray says that she points them to Parachute Home’s Down Pillow. According to the brand, the pillow is designed to feel extraordinarily soft, yet still supportive. It comes in three firmness levels and you can even get it in a side sleeper style.
“I’ve been really happy with the Brooklinen Down Pillow,” Murray says. “I like that it comes in several firmness levels, so I can match it to how someone sleeps instead of handing everyone the same pillow, and it’s well priced for real down.”
Your shortcut to editor approved picks
Best down alternative pillows, according to experts and editors
Shop TODAY contributor Chassie Post stopped by the show to share some of the best early Black Friday deals that you can shop now at Walmart, and she included these as one of her picks. She’s even tried them herself and loves that they have a soft feel while still providing support for all kinds of sleepers.
If you’re looking for a budget-friendly option, Murray recommends Brooklinen’s Down Alternative Pillow. “It’s hypoallergenic and comes in different firmness levels.”
It features double-stitched edges and is also encased in a sateen shell, which the brand says is quiet to keep noise to a minimum if you’re moving around at night.
“If I had to replace all my pillows and start my bedding all over again, I would just get multiples of this pillow because it’s honestly become my favorite in the last year,” says editor Vivien Moon. “It’s perfectly plush, hasn’t become lumpy and is just the most comfortable pillow I own.”
Murray says that she recommends this pillow often. “It’s tall and supportive enough for side sleepers but still has that soft, fluffy feel, so it doesn’t feel like you’ve settled for a lesser pillow,” she shares.
Are down pillows good for you?
Pillows aren’t usually a one-size-fits-all product, and the best one for you typically depends on your personal preferences and sleep style. However, there are some benefits to using a down pillow.
“My favorite thing about down is that you can mold it,” says Murray. “You can scrunch it, fold it and reshape it until it fits your neck and shoulders, which you can’t do with a solid foam pillow.”
Dr. Chris Winter, a neurologist and sleep specialist, says not only can down pillows feel luxurious, they’re also lightweight. “For people like me who like their arm under their pillow, the pillow feels weightless.”
Murray shares that this kind of pillow is “light, quiet and breathes much better than memory foam.” Plus, with proper care, she adds that it can last years.
Frequently asked questions
Someone who prefers their pillow to be hard or firm is not well-suited for down, Winter says.
Murray notes that those with allergies or sensitivities to down, feathers or dust mites may want to stay clear or choose a down alternative.
"It also isn’t my first pick for people who need firm, steady support, like side sleepers with broad shoulders or clients dealing with neck pain," she adds.
"Down is the soft, fluffy layer that sits under the outer feathers of ducks and geese," says Murray. "It doesn’t have the hard quill a feather has, which is why it feels so light and airy."
Most pillows labeled as being "down" are blends of both down and feathers, and if you want something softer, you'll want to go with one that has a higher ratio of down.
Down alternative pillows are typically filled with polyester microfiber, which can be called microdenier or gel fiber.
"Down alternatives are hypoallergenic and usually go straight in the washing machine," says Murray, so they're more suitable for those with allergies or those who prefer lower-care options.
"They’re also a good fit for people who avoid animal products, and they’re often cheaper. They tend to hold a firmer, more consistent shape, which many side sleepers like," she notes.
Meet the experts
- Kelly Murray is the founder and owner of Kelly Murray Sleep Consulting in Chicago.
- W. Chris Winter, MD, is a neurologist and sleep specialist. He is the owner of Charlottesville Neurology and Sleep Medicine clinic and host of the “Sleep Unplugged” podcast.
How we chose
The Shop TODAY editors and writers search the internet to find the best products out there. We interview expert sources, comb through customer reviews and even use our own personal experiences to make shopping easier for our readers. All of the above pillows were chosen by experts or members of our own editorial staff.
As an editorial team, we independently create content and determine coverage based on research, reporting and what we think TODAY.com readers would like to read about.










