Shop TODAY is editorially independent. This celebrity picked these items: some may be from their own product line and some may be from a brand they are paid to promote. When you buy through our links, we earn a commission. Learn more.

Amanda Seyfried Talks ‘SNL,’ ‘You Can See Everything’ and Go-To Holiday Gifts

We caught up with the actress at Shop TODAY’s Holiday House event.

To quote “Mean Girls,” you could say that Amanda Seyfried is “not like a regular mom.”

The actress has starred in countless beloved movies, including the aforementioned fan-favorite film (her first big-screen role), as well as “Mamma Mia!,” “Les Misérables” and more. She co-founded the children’s play brand Make It Cute, whose sustainable and stylish playhouses are so popular, they’re currently sold out on the brand’s site. She made an appearance in one of the most buzzed-about films of the year, Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s documentary about Elizabeth Holmes, “You Can See Everything.” (Some are saying it could even nab her her first Academy Award.) Oh, and she’s raising two kids and taking care of a host of animals on her farm in upstate New York.

Even with everything she has going on, Seyfried still made the time to sit down for a conversation with TODAY’s Dylan Dreyer at the Shop TODAY Holiday House on November 19 at GH on the Park in New York City, where they discussed everything from the brand to her role in “You Can See Everything,” as well as her upcoming gig hosting “Saturday Night Live” (a career first for the actress).

“It was never my plan to ever do it, ever, because of my stage fright,” Seyfried says about the show. She later added, “I have had moments of dissociating on live television that you’ve never seen, but that have happened to me and traumatized me, and a lot of actors have those experiences. So the more people I talk to about it, the better I feel.”

However, Seyfried says that she loves “comedy and satire.” She shares, “That should be the win here, for me to get to do something like that. And my parents are going to be there; my ex-husband and my daughter will probably be there ... We have to jump and then fly. You know? And the only way to fly is to give yourself the opportunity to jump.”

As for Seyfried’s other most talked-about role of the year, her appearance in Fielder’s documentary, it was a surprise to most people, though she said that it wasn’t exactly a secret in her circle. “I’m the least discreet person you’ll ever meet ... I told a lot of people.”

She adds, “I was so excited to be on the road with them. I’m an investigator; I like to interview people ... I get asked the questions all the time, and I want to ask the questions. So I got to do that, and it was cool. But it is absolutely a one-of-a-kind experience.”

Given that the event was all about getting in the holiday spirit, Dreyer asked Seyfried about the most memorable gift she’d ever received, which she said was “a donkey” that they named Gus.

“My ex-husband [Thomas Sadoski] bought me a donkey for Christmas.” She continues, “It was exactly what I wanted, without knowing I wanted it. And he’s been in our family for like six years now, seven years.”

But that isn’t the only memorable gift Sadoski has given her; there’s one that goes all the way back to her first dream job of being a meteorologist. “I have a date to storm chase ... in May.” She shared, “My ex-husband got it for me for Christmas a couple years ago.” She adds, “He pulled strings ... he’s a good one.”

For anyone else who needs a little inspiration (and isn’t feeling adventurous enough to go the storm-chasing route), we sat down with Seyfried after the panel to hear about some of her top gifting picks for the season.

Amanda Seyfried’s gift guide

Her top gift for kids:

Make It Cute Modern Farmhouse Playhouse

“I think it’s essential that kids have their own place to have their imagination run wild, and I think we made the perfect thing for that,” she says about Make It Cute’s playhouse. (Which is also a Shop TODAY Gifts We Love winner.) She adds that when they were creating it, they wanted to make “something that we would want to hang out in as parents.”

She shares, “Sometimes kids don’t appreciate the same things that parents appreciate, but the fact that we can make it for both — and kids are really appreciating the stars, the floor and the little animals outside, the birds — it feels so fulfilling and satisfying to know that those little ideas that you had really clicked with people.”

The gag gift she would give Nathan Fielder:

If she were to get Fielder a gag gift, she shares that it would be “one of those boxes that has something weird” on the outside, “but it’s really just a box, and you just give the real gift.” She adds, “You can get them on Amazon, they’re really funny and they’re just boxes of weird stuff.”

Though, she also has an alternative idea: “I’d get Nathan Fielder a taxidermied animal,” she shares. As for what animal, she says that it would be, “something exotic, like a meerkat. But I would get it ethically sourced, obviously.”

The PJs she loves for the whole family:

Hanna Andersson Holiday HannaJams Pajama Pants

As for whether she’s a fan of matching PJs, she says that she’s for the holiday tradition, “for the kids.” And she even gets in on the fun! “We all match,” she says.

“Hanna Andersson does it really well,” she adds.

BETA
Shop with Today

Your shortcut to editor approved picks

The gift on her daughter’s wish list:

Strathmore 300 Series Tape Bound Bristol Pad

While the playhouse is obviously huge in her house with her two kids, many of the gifts they want are surprisingly simple.

“[For my son], nothing is good enough except empty boxes — which is so, so bizarre — he loves tape as well.” As for her daughter, she says, “She just loves a new sketch pad, like the good Bristol paper or the thick marker paper. She really loves new markers and loves blank pages.”

The book she wants to gift this holiday season:

As someone who lives on a farm in upstate New York, it’s not surprising that she occasionally checks the “Farmer’s Almanac.” Though, up until now, she says that she’s been using the online version.

“I was thinking the other day about buying the actual hard cover and doing it the analog way, and I think it’d be a good gift to give to people.”

Her go-to gift for holiday hosts:

If Seyfried is going to a holiday party, you can guarantee she won’t be showing up empty-handed. She tells us she’ll either bring “really good natural wine” (her favorite is the Bencze Atlas Pinot Noir) or she says that she’ll bring “a homemade potholder or homemade flowers. I’ll bring a glass bottle vase, repurposed, and I crochet a lot of these anemones, and then I’ll put two in a vase.”

She previously shared that she uses a pattern from Crochet Oasis.

What she’d bring to a gift exchange:

If Seyfried were to attend a white elephant or “favorite things” style gift exchange, these would be the items she would bring.

While she tells us that socks are actually one gift that she thinks people should stop giving, she’s breaking her own rule for these. “Baserange is a really good brand, and I love their socks — they have the most beautiful colored socks.”

Her other pick would be “really good candlesticks.” She says, “Cire Trudon makes these great taper candles that are actually scented in the Gabriel scent that I love, and they’re beautiful.” (Her favorite scent is not currently available online in candlestick form, but you can get it as a scented candle or order one of their other scented taper candles.)

Her go-to gift when she’s not sure what to get someone:

“I like to go to John Derien online and get a really good little vase from Astrid de Villette,” she says. Skippy Cotton is another favorite brand of hers for gifts. “Skippy Cotton and John Derien are the best gift sites. I really like getting people vases and little mugs. I think it’s cozy and you can never fail [with those].”

BETA
Shop with Today

Your shortcut to editor approved picks