The nurse, teacher and parent-loved Bogg Bag was considered the "it" bag of the summer last year. Its Croc-like look and feel makes it an appealing option for the beach or park and everywhere in between as it is able to vent out sand, debris and water alike.
However, TikTokers are pitting this bag against another one — the Yeti Camino Carryall Tote. It doesn't have the same summer-ready colors or patterns as the Bogg Bag, instead offering a more rugged, functional design and color options.
How I tested both bags
Each bag boasts the ability to comfortably carry everything you need for a day spent out and about. So, I packed each bag to take on a girls' trip upstate, testing them for durability, waterproofness and how easy they were to sling over my shoulder or carry in my hands while commuting.
Which bag is more waterproof?
I tested each bag's waterproof capabilities by pouring a cup of water on the outside to see if it would simply roll off, create a puddle, or seep through to the inside.
- Yeti: The brand promises a waterproof material on the "inside and out" of this bag, saying it'll survive rainy pavement and spilled juice boxes. Water was contained to the exterior surface of the Yeti bag, remaining in a pool in the middle. It easily wiped off, however some water clung to the fabric handles.
- Bogg Bag: The Bogg Bag was designed with beach and pool days in mind, the holes meant to filter out sand, water and other unwanted debris. Water obviously dripped through the holes, otherwise it rolled off the EVA plastic exterior. Bogg Bag's site doesn't explicitly say its products are waterproof, yet they mention you can hold wet towels inside without fear of ruining the bag, and the brand offers accessories to clip onto the inside that are waterproof or water-resistant in case you need a place to store some cards or cash.
Which bag is better for commuting?
I took both bags on the subway multiple times, testing their structured bottoms, how comfortable the shoulder straps were and more.
- Yeti: The Carryall Camino Tote is a more reasonably-sized tote, making it more ideal than the Bogg Bag for placing on my lap in a packed subway car. While the shoulder straps were a bit rigid and dug into my shoulders, the more I packed (and the heavier the bag became), the additional carrying straps resolved this issue when I wanted to give my shoulders a break. Plus, the hook-and-loop closure helped to seal the bag to ensure nothing fell out.
- Bogg Bag: While the Bogg Bag was too large to fit on my lap while sitting down, it managed to sit between my feet just fine. Otherwise, the straps were comfortable and didn't dig into my shoulders when carrying it while standing. There were times when the straps got twisted and it took me a minute to figure out how to revert them, otherwise, they proved to be more comfortable than the Yeti straps. And, its structured, textured bottom helped it to not slip or slide while on the subway floor.
Which bag is better for packing?
I took both bags on a trip to upstate New York for a girls' weekend. On the way there, the Yeti fit all the odds and ends I couldn't otherwise fit into a duffel, such as my water bottle, laptop, wine, a book and more. On the way home, I conserved space by putting the Yeti into the Bogg Bag, and it proved to be easier to carry.
- Yeti: Because of its more structured base and the curvature of the sides, I found that items were less likely to roll around or become jumbled in the Yeti bag. I utilize the internal side pockets as a courier for water and wine bottles; however, they can also be pushed open to double as dividers and a means to separate items. In the past, I've taken this bag to the park, stowing picnic blankets, a hammock, sunscreen and more inside, carting it the half-mile walk there. Everything's always fit perfectly inside, with room to spare for a water bottle and my Kindle.
- Bogg Bag: The Bogg Bag comes complete with two zippered pouches that can be secured to either the inside or outside of the bag, to store essentials or items you don't want sinking to the bottom. If you've ever attached a charm to Crocs, the process is similar when adjusting and rearranging the zippered pouches on this bag. While it also has a structured bottom, depending on how full you pack it, loose items still have a tendency to roll around. However, when packed with blankets or sweatshirts, items remain secure and in place.
My personal pick
I've been using the Yeti Camino Carryall Tote for a couple of years, appreciating its spacious interior, including water bottle pockets and overall, its durability.
However, if you're looking for a bag that can hold significantly more items and remains flexible no matter how much you pack into it, the Bogg Bag might be a preferred choice.
Why trust Shop TODAY?
I put these bags through a series of tests, commuting with them, carrying them to the park and on the subway, testing their waterproof claims and seeing how much would fit in each bag.
This isn't my first take on comparing products, either, having previously compared water bottles, travel mugs and more to see which is best based on a series of tests.
