Commander's Palace's Low-Cooked Crispy Fish
Tory McPhail's Easy "Low-Cooked" Crispy Fish
print recipe
3.8064516 (31 rated)
Cook time:
Prep time:

This is one of my favorite recipes that we serve at Commander's Palace restaurant in New Orleans. I love it because it's very healthy, it's one-pan cooking, easy clean up, it only cost a few dollars per portion, it's a show stopping presentation and it empowers you to cook seafood in your home without your home smelling fishy for days after.

Technique tip: Use a sharp serrated knife to cut the lemon rounds evenly.

Swap option: You could swap redfish or another medium-bodied fish.


    • Four 4-ounce stripped bass filets, skin on
    • 1½ cups shiitake mushrooms, chopped
    • 2 pinches smoked sea salt, divided
    • Salt and pepper, to taste
    • 3/4 cups fennel, cut into thin matchsticks
    • 1½ cups grape tomatoes
    • 2 cups arugula
    • 1/2 cup basil, ripped
    • 3 tablespoons mint, ripped
    • 1 lemon, sliced thinly into 12 rounds and seasoned with salt and sugar
    • 2 oranges, peeled and cut into segments
    • 2 teaspoons lemon infused avocado oil
    • 2 teaspoons crushed red pepper flakes, finely ground


1. Place the fish filets on a tea towel let sit at room temperature for at least 20 minutes to absorb as much moisture as possible.

2. In a bowl, season the mushrooms with a pinch of the smoked sea salt, mix thoroughly and leave to marinate for several minutes or overnight.

3. Season the meat side of the fish filets with salt and pepper. Turn the fish over so the skin side is up and lightly brush the fish skin with olive oil. Season the skin with salt and ground pepper to taste.

4. Place a heavy gauge non-stick pan over low heat. Brush the pan with olive oil and lay the fish into the pan, skin side down. Space the filets evenly so the fish isn't touching each other. Do not shake the pan or disturb the fish as it cooks.

5. Next add the shiitake mushrooms and fennel between the gaps between the fish and around the pan. Slowly sear the fish over low heat for about 7-10 minutes, depending on the thickness of the filet or until the fish has cooked 75% of the way on the skin side. Stir the mushrooms and fennel as needed so that the vegetables are cooking evenly but do not disturb the fish as it cooks.

6. The edges of the fish should be cooked, turning white and remainder of the raw flesh should look slightly opaque. Using a fish spatula, gently turn the fish over, add the tomatoes, arugula, basil and fresh mint around the fish to allow the fish to steam in the fresh aromas for the last 2 minutes or until the fish is done. Season the vegetables with a pinch of salt and pepper and gently fold together as it steams.

7. Arrange three slices of seasoned lemon in a triangle shape around each warm serving plate. Place a fish filet, skin side up, in the middle of each plate making sure you can see the fresh lemon on all sides. Mix the vegetables in the skillet making sure to get any remaining crispy pieces up and into the vegetables. Spoon the vegetables onto the plate between the lemon rounds and around the fish. Place the orange segments attractively on top of the fish.

8. Lastly, in a small bowl, mix the ground red chili flakes and avocado oil and stir well. Spoon around the plate as the final garnish.

Related video

Closed Captioning
apply | reset x

Make this delicious low-cooked crispy fish New Orleans-style

Play Video - 2:45