IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

What Rat Pack tunes should ‘Idols’ sing?

The "American Idol" finalists can choose this week's tunes from the Rat Pack songbook. Here are some suggestions matched to each remaining singer.
/ Source: Entertainment Weekly

Fingers crossed that American Idol's decision to go back — way back — in musical time for an evening of songs popularized by the Rat Pack will pay dividends. The show has history on its side: Big Band Night was one of the undeniable highlights of Season 1 — remember Kelly's "Stuff Like That There" and Tamyra's "Minnie the Moocher"? — and both 1950s Night and Great American Songbook Night in Season 5 were pretty killer, too. Check out my request list for the season 8 top 5 below, then post your own picks in the comments section below!

Adam Lambert: We all know Adam can take an obscure song arrangement and sell it like it's cold, bottled water in the desert. And we all know he's got a knack for infusing a lyric with added subtext and meaning. (See: "Mad World," "Black or White.") On that note, I'd love to see him put a beat-heavy twist on "I've Got You Under My Skin" the way Neneh Cherry did for 1990's Red Hot + Blue benefit album (sans Neneh's added lyrics, of course).

Danny Gokey: Needs a "moment" worse than Octomom needs a Diaper Genie, and for that to happen, he needs to break the karaoke shackles. Best way to do that is to avoid a song that everyone knows, and instead aim for a gorgeous, intimate melody, maybe accompanied only by piano. I'd suggest Dean Martin's "Under the Bridges of Paris" or Sammy Davis, Jr.'s "What Kind of Fool Am I?"

Allison Iraheta: Here's a contestant who deserves to/needs to have a little fun up on the Idol stage, and what better way than covering Frank Sinatra's "That's Life" (preferably in a chic gown that's not red and black). And for a contestant who's becoming a permanent bottom-three fixture, what better lyric than "Each time I find myself laying flat on my face/ I just pick myself up and get back in the race"? (Also apropos if — GAH! — she has to give an encore performance on Wednesday.)

Kris Allen: He can do romantic — "Falling Slowly," "How Sweet It Is to Be Loved By You," "To Make You Feel My Love" — but surely the man has felt the blues, no? Frank Sinatra's "Drinking Again" might provide the perfect opportunity to use his puppy-dog eyes and hangdog voice to extol the glory of a broken heart.

Matt Giraud: Dude needs to take his place at the piano and avoid OD-ing on falsetto and vocal acrobatics — preferably on something jazzy, crowd-pleasing, and with an undeniable melody. I'm requesting "Luck Be a Lady" or "Autumn in New York."