IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

Who picked Gabby and who picked Rachel on 'The Bachelorette'?

During the season's third episode, suitors split up into two groups. Meet "Team Gabby" and "Team Rachel."

Think of Season 19 of "The Bachelorette" as an experiment. For the first time, the show has two Bachelorettes at the same time — dating from the same group of men. How will it all work? As the episodes go by, we learn more.

During the rose ceremony at the end of the third episode on July 25, the remaining contestants sorted themselves into two groups: Those dating Gabby Windey and those dating Rachel Recchia.

By accepting a rose from Windey or Recchia, they were essentially committing to a journey with that bachelorette.

The decision was prompted by three men telling Windey during a group date that they were more interested in Recchia. However, during the rose ceremony, Recchia was rejected three times, with Termayne Harper, James Clarke and Alec Garza saying they were more interested in Windey (though Clarke asked for Recchia back during the end credits).

Recchia called the experience "humiliating" and the hardest part of her time as Bachelorette. “This was supposed be us taking the power back. We literally handed it to them,” she told Windey.

Below, find out who is going after each Bachelorette, as of Episode Three.

Gabby Windey's suitors

  • Jason Alabaster
  • Kirk Bryant
  • Johnny DePhillipo
  • Mario Vassall
  • Nate Mitchell
  • Erich Schwer
  • Spencer Swies
  • Michael Vaughan
  • Quincy Williams

Rachel Recchia's suitors

  • Tino Franco
  • Jordan Helman
  • Aven Jones
  • Ethan Kang
  • Hayden Markowitz
  • Tyler Norris
  • Logan Palmer
  • Zach Shallcross

And potentially, James Clarke — better known by his nickname, Meatball. After turning down Recchia's rose, Clarke asked for another chance.