IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

When 'sorry' doesn't cut it: Teaching kids to apologize

How many times have our kids given the obligatory “I’m sorry” when we know good and well they didn’t really mean it?By Amy McCready, Positive Parenting Solutions founder and TODAYMoms contributorYou know the drill…the child does something unsavory to a sibling or friend, and mom or dad mandate that an apology be issued right now! The child grudgingly complies with a half-hearted “I’

How many times have our kids given the obligatory “I’m sorry” when we know good and well they didn’t really mean it?

By Amy McCready, Positive Parenting Solutions founder and TODAYMoms contributor

You know the drill…the child does something unsavory to a sibling or friend, and mom or dad mandate that an apology be issued right now! The child grudgingly complies with a half-hearted “I’m sorry” so he can “check it off the list” and get on with his business.

Forcing kids to apologize in the heat of the moment usually makes parents feel better but does little to help children understand the effects of their behavior on others or how to resolve conflicts in the future.

Instead, wait until everyone is calm and follow these five guidelines to teach kids how to take responsibility for their actions, develop empathy for others and learn from their mistakes:

1. Don’t “shame” or punish your child.  This only makes her feel bad about herself and doesn’t help her learn for the future.  Instead, be very clear that the behavior was not okay but now she has an opportunity to learn from the experience and “make it right” with the other person.

2. Avoid the temptation to lecture.  Instead, use questions to help your child process what she was feeling. For example, “What/how were you feeling before you hit Jenny?” This teaches her to take responsibility for her feelings. If the child is too young to identify the feeling, you can help “label” it by saying, “It looked like you were really angry.” We want to reinforce that feelings are OK; however, the action that followed was not.

3. Connect the dots.  Tie your child’s feeling to her action and the effect it had on the other person. “When you felt angry and hit Jenny, how do you think that made her feel?”  This teaches that her actions affect other people.

4. Make amends. Focus on solutions to “make it right” with the injured party by asking, “What can you do to make it right with Jenny?” That may be a verbal apology if it’s truly heart-felt, but children typically learn more by taking some action to make the other person feel better – perhaps writing a note, drawing a picture, or showing some other act of kindness.

5. Role-play the “re-do.”  Don’t miss the opportunity to help your child learn to make a better choice next time.  Ask, “If you could have a re-do, what would you do differently when you were angry at Jenny?”  Brainstorm more constructive ways to handle the situation next time and role-play them. She’ll be more likely to use positive conflict resolution tactics next time if she’s had the chance to practice them with you.

Amy McCready is the founder of Positive Parenting Solutions and mom to two boys, ages 12 and 15. Positive Parenting Solutions provides online education for positive discipline know-how and parenting peace. For free training resources, visit: www.PositiveParentingSolutions.com