John Galliano's alleged anti-Semitic insults may have tarnished his employer Dior, but the fashion house's sacking of its star designer now offers it the opportunity to breathe fresh life into the brand.
Behind the scenes, Dior is telling industry watchers it is glad Galliano is gone, as it wanted to move away from his theatrical style and embrace a more subtle and refined elegance to better reflects post-economic crisis society.
"This could be a driver for positive change, which is what Dior itself was looking for," said luxury goods analyst Davide Vimercati at UniCredit.
Dior fired Galliano Tuesday, hours after an online video clip spread around the world showing him hurling anti-Semitic abuse at people in a Paris bar.
The next day, Galliano apologized and said anti-Semitism and racism "have no part in our society."
The saga began Thursday evening when Paris police were called to La Perle bar in the Marais district where they found an inebriated Galliano shouting abuse. Saturday, another woman lodged a complaint for similar behavior back in October.
The British designer will stand trial later this year on charges of making racist insults in public
Although Dior was swift to cast Galliano aside, few expect Dior will be ready to reveal the identity of a successor when his latest collection is presented in his absence in the gardens of the Paris Rodin museum Friday.
"Although they are likely to announce it relatively quickly, I do not think they can do it that fast," a person close to Dior parent LVMH said. "Contract negotiations with all the parties involved take time."
While there are many names in the hat to replace Galliano, most fashion experts point in the direction of Riccardo Tisci who has won praise for his work at Givenchy, which like Dior is owned by LVMH, the world's biggest luxury group.
"Tisci is the best placed because he has the ability to make fully rounded collections, has an eye for volumes and is very creative," the chief executive of one of Europe's top fashion labels told Reuters under conditions of anonymity.
"Based on what I have seen at Givenchy, what he misses is the ability to play with colors, as a lot of it is black, but overall he has done some wonderful things and I think he would be capable of interpreting Dior's universe."
Tisci, who like Galliano attended the prestigious Central St Martins school in London, caught the eye of LVMH's talent-spotters when he launched his own collection.
Tisci has revitalized Givenchy since 2005, with his dark, romantic and slightly melancholic designs, critics say.
However, some industry experts have suggested that Galliano, who was at Givenchy for a year before joining Dior in 1996, could also be replaced by one of his top lieutenants.
The move would let the brand, rather than the designer, take center stage so Dior could break with the star designer system.
PPR, which owns fashion house Alexander McQueen, followed that route when it appointed his right-hand aide Sarah Burton to replace him after he committed suicide last year.
Some people have also suggested Alber Elbaz, the bow-tied designer who has resuscitated Lanvin over the past decade, as a potential candidate to replace Galliano.
But a person with firsthand knowledge of the matter said the move was unlikely as the designer held a minority stake in Lanvin and its controlling shareholder, the Taiwanese media magnate Shaw-Lan Wang, would not let him go.
Another name circulating was that of Hedi Slimane, who used to work for Dior's menswear, but several fashion sources said he did not get along very well with the LVMH group and his style was too minimalist and one directional to fill Galliano's shoes.
Luxury analysts say Galliano was not regarded as a driver of Christian Dior's Couture sales, and some had heard complaints he was spending too much on his eponymous own label, whose future now looks uncertain without Dior's financial backing.
Dior's sales rose 15 percent in 2010 to 826 million euros ($1.15 billion), underperforming the sector's 20 percent average growth and close rivals such as Lanvin with growth of about 30 percent.
Since the scandal broke Friday Dior shares gained four percent on the prospect Galliano would be fired but then slipped once the news was confirmed Tuesday as his departure created uncertainty as to his replacement.