IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

For the perfect German chocolate cake, we turned to Reddit — and it didn't disappoint

Over the next few days, the cake's flavors only intensified, growing more sweet, moist and chocolaty as time passed.
When my father-in-law requested a German Chocolate Cake for his 70th birthday, I headed over to the r/Old_Recipes subreddit for the perfect vintage version.
When my father-in-law requested a German Chocolate Cake for his 70th birthday, I headed over to the r/Old_Recipes subreddit for the perfect vintage version.Terri Peters / TODAY
/ Source: TODAY

As I've cooked my way through the r/Old_Recipes subreddit, I've learned that you truly can't go wrong by resurrecting a tried-and-true recipe from years past.

So when I told my father-in-law, who would be visiting my home on his 70th birthday, that he could request any type of birthday cake he wanted and I'd find the perfect recipe, I meant it.

The birthday guy's request? German chocolate cake.

After diving into the r/Old_Recipes rabbit hole, I found a fellow user had put out a call for the best German chocolate cake recipes a few months back. The response that caught my eye was from Redditor u/BestOfShow32569, Tony Thompson, who collects old recipe boxes and cookbooks and posts them on his website, Vintage Recipes.

The Adkins family's German chocolate cake recipe, as posted on Vintage Recipes.Tony Thompson/Vintage Recipes

Thompson told TODAY Food he found his recommended German chocolate cake recipe in a collection acquired from a Tennessee estate he believes belonged to a family by the name of Adkins who lived in Alabama then Tennessee.

"The name Adkins, along with a Birmingham address, appears on a letter stored in the collection. Of course, there is a recipe written on the back of the page," said Thompson. "Once I started processing the recipes, I found indications that the owner also lived in Tullahoma, Tennessee … The recipe collection looks like it contains recipes from the late '60s through the mid-'80s."

The recipe called for shortening and buttermilk to create the chocolate cake batter.Terri Peters/TODAY

While Thompson has not tried the Adkins' German chocolate cake himself, I was eager to give it a try, so I gathered the ingredients and readied my kitchen for a test run. The recipe calls for shortening and buttermilk in the cake batter, so I was anticipating a moist, flavorful cake. And the icing, which includes a stick of margarine and plenty of coconut and pecans, sounded like the perfect complement.

When my mother-in-law and I started our prep work, we realized we knew little about the history of German chocolate cake. After some researching at my kitchen island, we learned the cake gets its name from the chocolatier who created German chocolate, Samuel German. German created his special chocolate for the Baker's Chocolate Company in 1852, and in 1957, the Dallas Morning News featured a cake using the chocolate, created by a Texas homemaker, as its recipe of the day. Baker's Chocolate started circulating the recipe and the rest is chocolaty history.

German chocolate was developed by chocolatier Samuel German for Baker's Chocolate Company in the 1800s.Terri Peters/TODAY

We baked our birthday cake in two round pans, stacking it into layers and icing it with the coconut custard concoction when it was cool. While not all German chocolate cakes are served with the sides iced, but I wanted to cover mine. The recipe only made enough frosting for the middle layer and the top of the cake, so in the interest of time, I grabbed some cream cheese frosting from my pantry to fill in where needed.

Next time, however, I'd double the frosting recipe, both to decorate the cake consistently and because it was incredibly tasty.

A combination of margarine, coconut, vanilla, sugar, egg yolks and milk went into our pan to create the delicious frosting.Terri Peters/TODAY

And there will be a next time: The Adkins' cake was decadent, moist and perfectly sweet. My in-laws loved it so much, they had it for lunch the following day and then again for dessert that night.

And, like my sweet father-in-law, this German chocolate cake only gets better with age.

On the days following our birthday celebration, the cake's flavors only intensified, growing more sweet, moist and chocolaty as time passed.

Our German chocolate cake after being sliced.Terri Peters/TODAY

Like most vintage recipes, the cake was labor-intensive, but making a cake like this from scratch was a fun kitchen project to take on.

Thompson, who has uploaded nearly 1,500 old recipes from various family collections to his blog, believes it's that level of effort, combined with the beauty of an old, handwritten recipe, that compels people to try vintage recipes in their modern homes.

The cake only got better as time went on, providing delicious leftovers for days.Terri Peters/TODAY

"I appreciate these collections as works of art," said Thompson. "A homemaker or housewife spent time writing, typing or clipping these recipes and organizing them in the system that worked for them … A recipe that's found and used from a traditional website is convenient and efficient, but an old recipe that someone took time to write down has a personality of its own.

"And, the fact that someone took the time to write or type a recipe gives the recipe some credibility from the start," he said.