Pop Culture

'Red' alert: Is Taylor Swift country enough for the CMAs? 

Larry Busacca/TAS / Today
Taylor Swift wraps the North American portion of her "Red" tour playing to a crowd of more than 14,000 fans on the first of three sold-out hometown shows at Nashville's Bridgestone Arena on Sept. 19.

Taylor Swift is a seven-time Grammy Award-winning artist, two- time VMA winner, a hit songwriter, and an international pop icon. But one label that doesn’t really rise to the top anymore is that of "country music artist." Still, come Nov. 6, she’ll be front-and-center at the 47th annual Country Music Association Awards, where she’s up for entertainer of the year, female vocalist of the year and album of the year, as well as three others.

Swift will also receive a Pinnacle Award, a distinction given to artists who have achieved worldwide success and recognition unique to country music. Garth Brooks is the only previous winner and these accolades and distinctions underscore one of the biggest debates in country music: whether crossover country-pop artist Swift deserves so much country praise.

Although she made her mark in 2006 as a country artist with her self-titled debut, with each succeeding album she’s moved further afield from the genre. Her 2008 album, "Fearless," was a giant step into pop and by 2010’s "Speak Now" Swift seemed to be taking a page from Shania Twain’s playbook by pushing the music way beyond its roots.

But with last year’s "Red," Swift left those roots in the dust. In their place were funky pop beats (“We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together”) and even dubstep ("I Knew You Were Trouble"). Considering what’s actually on the CD, “Red” is likely to go down in history as the most un-country album to be nominated by the CMA for album of the year.

So why all the CMA love? Part of the reason is that Swift sells a whole lot of records for the Nashville-based Big Machine label. But "Red" isn't entirely what you would call a "Nashville" album. Some of it was recorded as far away as Sweden and Swift’s collaborators included Swedish producers Max Martin and Shellbach, known for their work with Britney Spears and Pink, among others.

No artist should be criticized for wanting to grow artistically and judging by the massive popularity of "Red," Swift’s metamorphosis into a pop singer has been a huge success. But that doesn’t means she fits in with the CMA crowd anymore. Kelly Clarkson, who is also up for female singer of the year, sounded more country on her single “Don’t Rush” than Swift has in years.

So why is Swift still the CMA’s darling? Simply put, she fills a room, and more eyes will be on the CMAs with her around. Swift has also expanded country’s audience with her massive fan base. Had she not stepped away from country completely, a good argument could have been made that she was broadening the palette of country the way the Beatles expanded the vocabulary of rock.

Swift’s moving country away from its roots also follows a pattern of sorts. The music has gone through previous pop phases, like the ’60s countrypolitian of Glenn Campbell and Conway Twitty and the ’80s urban pop of Mickey Gilley or Johnny Lee. But both times traditionalists came along to bring the music back home. Kacey Musgraves, who received six CMA nominations this year, might be the artist who does that again.

Swift could save face if she does not perform one of her newer songs alongside fellow entertainer of the year nominees Blake Shelton, George Strait, Jason Aldean, or Luke Bryan. She’s got a better, genuine new country-song option in the aforementioned "Highway Don’t Care," which topped the country charts. It might not be her song, but it’s definitely a country number. And Swift’s participation on the track shows she’s still a little bit country, even if "Red" isn’t.

  • Slideshow Photos

    Isaac Brekken / FR159466 AP

    Image: Taylor Swift

    Taylor Swift

    Country music’s young superstar is making a splash from Nashville to Hollywood.

  • Image: Justin Timberlake, Taylor Swift

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Taylor and Timberlake -

    Singer Taylor Swift, left, and Justin Timberlake, right, perform a skit during the Walmart shareholders' meeting in Fayetteville, Ark., on June 1, 2012. Swift has been a star since her early teens, and was described by the New York Times and Rolling Stone as one of music's best songwriters.

    AP / AP
  • 47th Annual Academy Of Country Music Awards - Show

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Entertainer of the year -

    Swift accepts the Entertainer Of The Year Award onstage at the 47th Annual Academy Of Country Music Awardsin Las Vegas on April 1, 2012.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Nickelodeon's 25th Annual Kids' Choice Awards - Show

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Honored by the first lady -

    Swift accepts The Big Help award from First Lady Michelle Obama onstage at Nickelodeon's 25th Annual Kids' Choice Awards in Los Angeles on March 31, 2012.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Taylor Swift Live In Perth

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Down Under -

    Swift performs live in Perth, Australia on March 2, 2012.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Premiere Of Universal Pictures And Illumination Entertainment's 3D-CG "Dr. Seuss' The Lorax" - Arrivals

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Loving the Lorax -

    Swift arrives at the premiere of 'Dr. Seuss' The Lorax' at Universal Studios Hollywood in Universal City, Calif on Feb. 19, 2012. She voices a character named Audrey in the film.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Image:

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Cover girl -

    Swift appears on the cover of the February 2012 issue of Vogue.

    AP / AP
  • Taylor Swift poses with the trophies for

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Grammy girl -

    Swift won Grammys for best country solo performance and best country song, both for "Mean," " at the 54th Grammy Awards in Los Angeles in February 2012.

    AFP/Getty Images / AFP/Getty Images
  • Image: Taylor Swift

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Smell like Swift -

    Swift launches her debut fragrance, "Wonderstruck," at Macy's Herald Square in New York on Oct. 13, 2011.

    AP / AP
  • Image: Grand Ole Opry 85th Birthday Bash

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Opry singer -

    Swift takes the stage during the Grand Ole Opry 85th birthday bash at the Grand Ole Opry House in Nashville, Tenn., on Oct. 9, 2010.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Image: Emma Stone

    Taylor Swift

    of

    That was 'Easy' -

    Swift, right, jons actress Emma Stone, star of the film "Easy A," at the premiere of the film in Los Angeles, on Sept. 13, 2010.

    AP / AP
  • Image: Taylor Swift

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Tap those feet -

    Swift performs at the MTV Video Music Awards in Los Angeles on Sept. 12, 2010.

    AP / AP
  • Image: Taylor Swift

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Maine attraction -

    Swift greets her fans after performing in Kennebunkport, Maine, on Aug. 27, 2010. The singer filmed her music video for the single "Mine" in the town made famous as a vacation spot for the family of President George H.W. Bush.

    AP / AP
  • Image: The 52nd Annual GRAMMY Awards

    Taylor Swift

    of

    A lot of hardware -

    Swift poses in the press room with her four awards during the 52nd Annual Grammy Awards at Staples Center in Los Angeles on Sunday, Jan. 31, 2010.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Image: 52nd Annual GRAMMY Awards - Salute To Icons Honoring Doug Morris - Roaming

    Taylor Swift

    of

    In good company -

    Katy Perry, left, Swift, Rihanna and Fergie pose during the 52nd Annual Grammy Awards -- Salute To Icons Honoring Doug Morris at The Beverly Hilton Hotel in Beverly Hills, Calif., on Saturday, Jan. 30, 2010.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Image: Taylor Swift

    Taylor Swift

    of

    A Swift response -

    Swift performs at the "Hope for Haiti Now: A Global Benefit for Earthquake Relief" in Los Angeles on Friday, Jan. 22, 2010.

    AP / AP
  • Image: Taylor Swift, Howard Stringer

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Taking in the big show -

    Swift, left, and Sony CEO Howard Stringer speak at the Sony booth at the Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas on Wednesday, Jan. 6, 2010.

    AP / AP
  • Image: People's Choice Awards 2010 - Show

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Thanking her people -

    Swift accepts the award for favorite female artist during the People's Choice Awards 2010 at Nokia Theatre L.A. Live in Los Angeles on Jan. 6, 2010.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Image: Z100 Jingle Ball Concert at Madison Square Garden

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Holiday spirit -

    John Mayer performs with Swift during Z100's Jingle Ball 2009 concert at Madison Square Garden in New York on Dec. 11, 2009. On her new album, due out Oct. 25, 2010, Swift addresses a reported romance with Mayer in a song called "Dear John."

    EPA / EPA
  • Image: Singer Taylor Swift accepts the Female Vocalist of the Year award at the 43rd annual Country Music Association Awards in Nashville

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Country superstar -

    Swift accepts the female vocalist of the year award as presenters Lee Ann Womack, left, and Kris Kristofferson look on at the 43rd annual Country Music Association Awards in Nashville, Tenn., on Nov. 11, 2009.

    Reuters / Reuters
  • Image: Taylor Swift

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Song remains the same -

    For the second year in a row, Swift holds her songwriting award as she attends the 57th Annual BMI Country Awards in Nashville, Tenn., on Tuesday, Nov. 10.

    AP / AP
  • Image: Columbus Blue Jackets v Los Angeles Kings

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Taylor times two -

    Swift, left, and Taylor Lautner attend the NHL game between the Columbus Blue Jackets and the Los Angeles Kings at Staples Center in Los Angeles on Oct. 25, 2009.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Image: "We're All For The Hall" Concert for Country Music Hall of Fame - Show

    Taylor Swift

    of

    They're jammin' -

    Jason Aldean, from left, Hillary Scott, Swift, Charles Kelly, Faith Hill and Dave Haygood perform at the "We're All For The Hall" benefit for the Country Music Hall of Fame at the Sommet Center in Nashville, Tenn., on Oct. 13, 2009.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Image: Taylor Swift, Penn Badgley

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Runway watcher -

    Swift, right, and Penn Badgley, who plays Dan on "Gossip Girl," watch the Tommy Hilfiger spring 2010 collection during Fashion Week in New York on Sept. 17, 2009.

    AP / AP
  • Image: Kanye West, Taylor Swift

    Taylor Swift

    of

    An infamous moment -

    Singer-rapper Kanye West takes the microphone from Swift as she accepts the best female video award during the MTV Video Music Awards in New York on Sept. 13, 2009. Later in the show, Swift got her chance to finish her acceptance speech.

    AP / AP
  • Image: Taylor Swift

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Dancing in the streets -

    Swift performs on the street outside Radio City Music Hall during the MTV Video Music Awards in New York on Sept. 13, 2009.

    AP / AP
  • Image: Taylor Swift

    Taylor Swift

    of

    From the heart -

    Swift poses in front of her newly unveiled star at Mohegan's "Walk of Fame" in Uncasville, Conn., on Aug. 28, 2009. The teenage singer has snagged at least two Country Music Award nominations, including one for the show's highest honor: entertainer of the year.

    AP / AP
  • Taylor Swift

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Rockin' out -

    Swift performs during a concert at New York's Madison Square Garden on Aug. 27, 2009, as part of her "Fearless" tour, her first as a headliner.

    AP / AP
  • Taylor Swift, Joe Elliott

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Mixing country and rock 'n roll -

    Swift and Joe Elliott of Def Leppard perform at the CMT Music Awards in Nashville, Tenn., on June 16, 2009.

    AP / AP
  • Taylor Swift

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Hitting the keys -

    Swift performs at the CMA Music Festival at in Nashville, Tenn., on June 14, 2009.

    AP / AP
  • Image: Taylor Swift And T-Pain Rehearse For The 2009 CMT Music Awards

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Wearing many hats -

    T-Pain, left, and Swift rehearse for the 2009 CMT Music Awards at the Sommet Center on June 9 in Nashville, Tenn.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • "Hannah Montana The Movie" Los Angeles Premiere - Red Carpet

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Teen star power -

    Actress-singer Miley Cyrus, left, and Swift arrive at the premiere of Walt Disney Picture's "Hannah Montana: The Movie" at at the El Captian Theatre in Hollywood, Calif., on April 2, 2009.

    WireImage / WireImage
  • 2008 MTV Video Music Awards - Backstage and Audience

    Taylor Swift

    of

    The love is gone -

    Swift and then-boyfriend Joe Jonas at the 2008 MTV Video Music Awards at Paramount Pictures Studios in Los Angeles on Sept. 7, 2008. Jonas reportedly broke up with her over the phone.

    FilmMagic / FilmMagic
  • 2007 ACM New Artists Party for a Cause - Backstage

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Gripping image -

    Swift, left, and Kellie Pickler pose backstage during the Academy Of Country Music New Artists' Show at the MGM Grand Ballroom in Las Vegas on May 14, 2007.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • 2007 CMT Music Awards - Show

    Taylor Swift

    of

    A star is born -

    Swift accepts the award for "Breakthrough Video of the Year" for the song "Tim McGraw" onstage at the 2007 CMT Music Awards at Belmont University in Nashville, Tenn., on April 16, 2007.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Colorado Rockies v Los Angeles Dodgers

    Taylor Swift

    of

    Playing the field -

    Swift sings the National Anthem before a baseball game between the Los Angeles Dodgers and the Colorado Rockies on opening day at Dodger Stadium in Los Angeles on April 9, 2007.

    Getty Images / Getty Images


0:00
 
0:00
Your video begins in
0:00
TOP