Pop Culture

hated it

Msnbc.com readers had very strong opinions on the “Twilight” sequel, “New Moon,” which pulled in more than $140 million domestically in its opening weekend. From Kristen Stewart acting to the film's director, there was very little middle ground.

Here is just a sampling of opinions from msnbc.com readers. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.

________________

The film was not in the slightest faithful to the book, nor did it bring anything new or fresh to the story. I personally think the first Twilight movie was terrible, but this really takes the cake on just plain bad. Side note, whoever commented on 3+ hour Harry Potter movies may want to check running times (people who think this movie should be longer really bug me)

Go rent “Let the Right One” in and see a good vampire story. — Jack, Grayslake, Ill. 

________________

As an avid reader of the Twilight Saga series since the publication of Twilight in 2005, I was extremely pleased with the New Moon movie. They left a few parts out, but it was for cinematic reasons and the missing parts did not seriously effect the overall understanding of New Moon. I feel Chris Weitz did a fantastic job showing the relationship dynamics that develop between Bella and Jacob without over doing it. I am also very happy that they decided to keep Taylor Lautner in the cast as Jacob Black. Taylor is a fantastic actor from previous roles, and the dedication he showed to keep his part for the role of Jacob in New Moon is utterly amazing. Not only was he physically prepared for the role, but I feel his emotional portrayal and performance of an extremely complex and intricate character showed how far he has come as an actor and that he deserved the part of Jacob Black. His performance as very well done. The end of the movie was very well done in my opinion. After Bella and Edward returned from Volteri, and after the confrontation between Jacob and Edward ... The ending still came as a bit of a shock, but I think it was a very effective cliffhanger. As both a movie goer and a book reader, I was very happy with the New Moon movie. — Kendra Miller, Shelton, Conn.

________________

“New Moon” was boring to the nth degree, badly scripted, the special effects were terrible (The wolves did not have that werewolf factor — intensely frightening) and Kirsten Stewart is a horrible actress. The best thing about the acting are the vampires in Italy, which include Dakota Fanning; an actress who was on screen ten minutes and simply transformed her part. Aro was excellent. They should shoot the director and start over. Stephen King was right when he said, rightfully so that the author of these books is a horrible writer, and these movies are just like the books. In our world of mediocrity and children and people without their own thoughts or purpose in life, for some this is what it has come to. Nothing. — Anita Debarge, Laguna Beach, Calif.

________________

  • Slideshow Photos

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    The hot vampire series is taking cinemas by storm, and its stars' off-screen romance only helps matters.

  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Family affair

    In "Breaking Dawn Part 2," young Mackenzie Foy plays the half-human half-vampire child of Bella (Kristen Stewart) and Edward (Robert Pattinson). Jacob (Taylor Lautner) also plays an important role in Renesmee's life.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Next generation

    Mackenzie Foy, 11, plays Renesmee Cullen, whose name is a hybrid of her two grandmothers, Renee and Esme.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Super couple

    While Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson's relationship progressed to marriage and a child onscreen, the actors' offscreen romance had a few bumps in the road.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Cullen clan

    Plenty of vampires, including Edward's adoptive father Carlisle (Peter Facinelli), take sides in the war between the Volturi and the Cullens in "Breaking Dawn Part 2."

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Love gives a lift

    Pattinson as vampire Edward Cullen gives Bella Swan a lift in "Breaking Dawn, Part 1."

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Ready for a fight

    Taylor Lautner, as Jacob, gives a menacing glance as a blood-splattered Edward and his parents stand behind him in "Breaking Dawn Part 1."

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Like picking up a toothpick

    Kellan Lutz and Nikki Reed move some trees in "Breaking Dawn, Part 1." We assume they're making a clearing for Edward and Bella's wedding. Good thing vampires have that super-strength!

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    What lies ahead

    Smile while you can, Edward and Bella. Things are about to get crazy.

  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Team Jacob

    In between his "Twilight" duties, Taylor Lautner found time to shoot the action movie "Abduction."

  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    If the shoe fits

    Ashley Greene as Alice convinces Bella to try on some possible wedding shoes in "Breaking Dawn Part 1."

  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Awaiting the bride

    Ashley Greene, Jackson Rathbone, Elizabeth Reaser and Peter Facinelli await the "Breaking Dawn" wedding.

  • Image:

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Wedding night at last

    Reportedly the wedding-night scene involves Edward biting through the pillows, with feathers flying. The sex scene itself, however, had to stay PG-13.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • Image:

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Hot honeymoon

    Edward and Bella's honeymoon was shot in Brazil, which stands in for Edward's adoptive mother's own private island.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • Image:

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Baby on the way

    Bella and Edward didn't believe she could become pregnant with a half-vampire baby. Boy, were they wrong. Their daughter Renesmee enters the world in "Breaking Dawn Part 1," but the battle over her existence will mostly take place in the second film, due out in 2012.

  • Image:

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    I'm getting married in the morning

    Ashley Greene (Alice Cullen) and Nikki Reed (Rosalie Hale) help Bella get ready to walk down the aisle in "Breaking Dawn."

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • Image:

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Greeting the guests

    Elizabeth Reaser, as Edward's adoptive mother, Esme, greets Denali coven guests Irina (Maggie Grace), Kate (Casey LaBow) and Tanya (MyAnna Buring) as they arrive for Edward and Bella's wedding in "Breaking Dawn."

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • Image:

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Vegetarian vamps

    Mia Maestro and Christian Camargo play Carmen and Eleazar, vegetarian vampires from Alaska's Denali coven who come south to attend Bella and Edward's wedding.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • Image:

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Not going to RSVP, then?

    Jacob (Taylor Lautner) is furious when he receives the invitation to Bella and Edward's wedding.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • Image: Premiere Of Summit Entertainment's "The Twilight Saga: Eclipse" - Arrivals

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Facing up to a star

    A fan gets up close and personal with an image of "Twilight" star Robert Pattinson during the 2010 Los Angeles Film Festival at Nokia Theatre L.A. Live on June 24, 2010, in Los Angeles.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Image: Premiere Of Summit Entertainment's "The Twilight Saga: Eclipse" - Arrivals

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    The terrific threesome

    Taylor Lautner, Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson arrive at the premiere of the third movie in the series, "Eclipse," during the 2010 Los Angeles Film Festival at Nokia Theatre L.A. Live on June 24, 2010, in Los Angeles.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Image:

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    A childhood pal grows up -- and fills out

    While vampire Edward Cullen is Bella's true love, Taylor Lautner, as Jacob Black, who can phase into a giant wolf, is the true monster star of the third film, thanks in no small part to Lautner's abs and tendency to take his shirt off often.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • Image:

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Another vampire couple

    Alice Cullen (Ashley Greene) and Jasper Hale (Jackson Rathbone) are two of the vampires who are part of the Cullen coven. In "Eclipse," Jasper tells how he became a vampire, when, as a Confederate major in the Civil War, he was bitten by the bewitching Maria.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • Image:

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Shirts? We don't need no stinkin' shirts!

    The "Twilight" wolfpack is allergic to chest coverings.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • Image:

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Murdered by her fiance

    Rosalie Hale (Nikki Reed), shown here with partner Emmett Cullen (Kellan Lutz), is another of the Cullen coven with a tortured past. Her fiance was a drunk who orchestrated her gang rape and then left her for dead. As a vampire, she sought revenge and killed her rapists one by one.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • Image:

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    You only hurt the one you love

    Emily Young (Tinsel Korey) is permanently scarred from a wolf attack by her boyfriend, Sam Uley (Chaske Spencer). He lost control and didn't mean to hurt her, and forever feels guilty for her injuries.

    Summit Entertainment. / Summit Entertainment.
  • Image:

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    A force to be reckoned with

    Vampire Riley (played by Xavier Samuel, center) leads a group of newly undead planning to kill Bella and anyone who gets in their way -- including the Cullens and the werewolves.

  • Image: THE TWILIGHT SAGA: ECLIPSE

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Bella in the middle

    In "Eclipse," Bella once again finds herself forced to choose between two men she loves dearly -- vampire Edward and her childhood pal, Jacob, who has secrets of his own.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    The Cullen clan

    Is it an ad for denim? No, just a meeting of the Cullen clan, vampires who have bonded together as a family and managed to hide in plain sight of the mortal world. Shown in a scene from "Eclipse," from left, are Ashley Greene as Alice, Nikki Reed as Rosalie, Elizabeth Reaser as Esme, Jackson Rathbone as Jasper and Peter Facinelli as family patriarch Carlisle.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • Image: The Twilight Saga: Eclipse

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Just friends?

    Jacob grabs a rare moment alone with Bella in "Eclipse," the third film in the saga. There's one more book, "Breaking Dawn," which will be split into two films.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • Image: Scene from holiday movie "The Twilight Saga: New Moon" undated publicity photograph

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Cute couple

    In the second film, "New Moon," Bella and Edward are inseparable until a major threat rips them apart.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Frail Bella

    In "New Moon," the sequel to "Twilight," Bella starts off deliriously happy and in love with the vampire Edward Cullen, but falls apart and becomes a shell of herself after he leaves her. When she realizes that she hears Edward's voice and sees visions of him whenever her life is in danger, Bella engages in high-risk activities as a way to hang on to her memories of him.

  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Three's company

    Edward watches on as Bella chats with her friend Jacob Black in "New Moon." Jake, who harbors a not-so-secret crush on Bella, brings her back to life after she is crushed from the breakup with Edward.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    A crushing blow

    After Edward breaks up with her, Bella lies in the forest in shock overnight until her police chief dad, Charlie (played by Billy Burke), scours the woods for her with his squad. When they find her, she is unresponsive and remains in a deep depression for months.

  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Boy no more

    In "New Moon," Jake transforms from a lanky teen to a beefy hunk, thanks to his new werewolf status. To prepare for the physical change the role required, Taylor Lautner started hitting the gym and eating 3,200 calories a day to gain muscle so that his physique would better resemble Jacob's.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    If you love them, let them go

    Though it nearly kills him, Edward breaks up with his beloved Bella in "New Moon" in an attempt to keep her safe from the constant dangers of the vampire world.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Give me death

    When Edward hears that Bella has died, he goes to Italy to see the Volturi, a powerful coven of vampires that governs the laws of their world. He asks that the Volturi will grant him his wish: to destroy him, as he has no desire to live in a world without Bella. Here, the Volturi tracker Demetri stands over him.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • Image: Robert Pattinson, Kristen Stewart and Taylor Lautner Meet Young Fans

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Team Edward!

    A female fan kisses a poster showing the face of actor Robert Pattinson before the presentation of his new film, "The Twilight Saga: New Moon" at an HVB youth event at the Olympic Hall in Munich, Germany, on Nov. 14.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Playing heroine

    When Bella discovers that Edward plans to have the Volturi destroy him after coming to believe that she has died, she races to Italy to save him.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Finding love in the 'Twilight'

    Though Edward finds Bella's scent intoxicating and dangerously irresistable, he can't help but be drawn to her in "Twilight."

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Hunk with a hidden life

    English actor Pattison moved from modeling to the role of Cedric Diggory in "Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire" before taking on the role that would make him famous, that of hunky vampire Edward Cullen in "The Twilight Saga."

    Summit Entertainment, EPA / Summit Entertainment, EPA
  • Actors arrive for the 'RocknRolla' film premiere in Los Angeles, California.

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Muscling up but staying sweet

    Kellan Lutz plays Emmett Cullen in the "Twilight" movies. He's considered Edward's brother in the film and books, but in reality, the young vampires aren't related -- they were brought together by an older vampire and present themselves as a family to the outer world. Lutz bulked up for the films, but insists it hasn't interfered with his addiction to gummy bears, gummy worms, chocolate and other sweet treats.

    EPA / EPA
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Leading the vampire clan

    Peter Facinelli (husband of "90210's" Jennie Garth) and Elizabeth Reaser play the Cullen parents, Carlisle and Esme, in the "Twilight" movies. Carlisle, a doctor, managed to gather his small band together as a family and convince them to kill only animals to slake their bloodlust. They occasionally clash with other vamps who aren't quite as compassionate where humans are concerned.

    Summit Entertainment, Getty Images / Summit Entertainment, Getty Images
  • 'Watchmen' film premiere in Los Angeles, California.

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    So my daughter's in love with a vampire ...

    Billy Burke plays Bella's father, Charlie, and serves as the chief of police in their small rainy town of Forks, Wash. The Cullen vampire clan resides in the damp town because it's low on the bright sunshine that would reveal their non-human identities. Vampires in the "Twilight" universe sparkle brightly in direct sunlight.

    EPA / EPA
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Hanging with the wolf pack

    Bella's pal Jacob (far right) has a secret of his own, and it involves a wolfy transformation often associated with the full moon. His dad, Billy Black (Gil Birmingham, in wheelchair) is good friends with Bella's father, Charlie (Burke, in blue shirt). When Bella's relationship with Edward puts her father in danger, Billy and his community protect Charlie.

    Summit Entertainment / Summit Entertainment
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Bella, Bella

    Beautiful Bella Swan leaves her mother in sunny Arizona and moves to the Pacific Northwest, where she stumbles upon Edward Cullen and his vampire clan. Instead of being horrified, she confesses her love for Edward, and wants him to change her into a vampire as well, something he tries to resist doing.

    Summit Entertainment, Getty Images / Summit Entertainment, Getty Images
  • Premiere Of Summit Entertainment's "Twilight" - Arrivals

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    This sister's trouble

    Nikki Reed plays Cullen sister Rosalie, a gorgeous vampire who resents her status and takes some of her anger out on Bella. She doesn't want her brother's human girlfriend to join her clan, leading to trouble in the second book of the series, "New Moon."

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Look out for Laurent

    Edi Gathegi, seen here with Peter Facinelli in a scene from "Twilight," plays Laurent, a vampire from a group of nomad vampires that does battle with the Cullen clan.

    Summit Entertainment, Getty Images / Summit Entertainment, Getty Images
  • Premiere Of Summit Entertainment's "Twilight" - Arrivals

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    It's tough to be a bloodsucker

    Jackson Rathbone plays Cullen brother Jasper. The newest vampire in their clan, he must constantly struggle to fight off his urges to kill humans, Bella included. His fascinating backstory includes a history as a Confederate soldier in the Civil War and years spent training newborn vamps to learn to control themselves. He has the power to feel and manipulate the emotions of others.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    On the prowl

    Vampire James, played by Cam Gigandet, is considered a "tracker," and once he discovers Bella's human scent, plans to pursue her until her death. In "Twilight," he convinces her that her mother is in danger and thus forces her to sneak away from Edward and meet him in the Arizona ballet studio where she studied as a child.

    Summit Entertainment, Getty Images / Summit Entertainment, Getty Images
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    The hunt continues

    Fiery-haired Victoria makes up the third and final member of Laurent and James' coven. Her mate dominates the action in the first book, "Twilight," but by the third book, "Eclipse," Victoria takes center stage to try and wreak bloody revenge on Bella and the Cullens. Rachelle Lafevre, center, plays Victoria in the first two films, but when she needed time off for a movie, she was fired and replaced by actor Ron Howard's daughter, Bryce Dallas Howard, right.

    AP / AP
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Team Jacob or Team Edward?

    While Jacob Black is a Native American in the books and the films, actor Taylor Lautner himself is not. He was nearly replaced for the second film when moviemakers thought he couldn't convincingly pull off the bulk required for the role, but an impressive workout routine changed that.

    Summit Entertainment, Getty Images / Summit Entertainment, Getty Images
  • 40th NAACP Image Awards - Red Carpet

    'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Life with the vampire royals

    Young actress Dakota Fanning plays Jane in the "Twilight" sequel "New Moon." Jane is a member of the Volturi guard, working with the royal family of vampires who reside in Italy. Jane has an especially cruel power that allows her to create the illusion of pain and thus torture others.

    Getty Images for NAACP / Getty Images for NAACP
  • 'Twilight' mania lights up Hollywood

    of

    Waiting for 'Twilight'

    "Twilight" fans are among some of the most devoted around, with numerous Web sites, fan clubs and conventions gathering groupies to discuss and debate both the books and the films. Here fans reach for free T-shirts at the Los Angeles premiere of the first movie, in November 2008. Stores such as Hot Topic offer plenty of "Twilight" merchandise, including "TEAM EDWARD" and "TEAM JACOB" shirts, allowing fans to declare their allegiance to one of Bella's suitors.

    AP / AP

The guys were soo hot. That is all I hear from these reviews of these terrible books and movies. This is a classic example of young uninformed teenage girls going gaga over something with no depth, just like New Kids on the Block, Nsync, Back street Boys and so on.  — Anonymous

________________

I actually think it was a good movie. It was better then the first movie and did move quickly through the storyline. The only thing I can say is in the absence of the first movie the connection between Bella and Edward didn't seem quite as strong. Bella seemed tortured after Edward left but the book expressed it better then the movie. Still, I enjoyed the movie and am looking forward to Eclipse. — Jacquelyn Andula, Hamburg, N.Y.

I have seen the movie twice now and plan to see it again! I loved it! I know it is hard to make a two hour movie from a 500+ page book but I thought they picked up all the essential parts. No movie is ever as good as a book! I'm disappointed in reading how many people disliked the movie. Again, I loved the movie! — Debbie Baker, Sacramento, Calif.

________________

Saw New Moon last night. It was okay but didn hold attention. I was ready to leave after 30 minutes into the movie. Nothing excited me about it, nothing that makes me want to rush out and see it again or want to go at midnight and buy the DVD. Bella (Kristen Stewart) did not impress as Bella, she doesn't know how to act and it sad to see her try. Edward (Robert Pattinson) needs to wax and work on his abs. When he stepped out to expose himself. I was like ewww, gross. Jacob (Taylor Lautner) he held his own. I really felt sorry for him when Bella told Jacob goodbye at the end of the movie. Overall, the movie didn live up to its hype, like Twilight did. I think they should have stayed with the same director and things might have been different. Hopefully, the 3rd and 4th movie are better, but not holding my breath.  — Christina Haroer, Plainfield, Iowa

________________

I think new moon was great yeah, maybe it needed more of the book in it. but other then that it was better then twilight. i really loved seeing half naked jacob!!!! whoop-whoop!  — Anonymous, Alvin, Texas

As a huge fan of the books, I was very excited for the newest "Twilight Saga" installment. The movie disappointed only in the way that all 400 plus pages couldn't be brought to life. The acting from Kristen Stewart and Rob Pattinson improved ten fold from Twilight. I was so happy Taylor Lautner returned as Jacob, and boy did he look the part! I also thought the Volturi Coven was well cast. With Rachel Levre going to be absent from the next film, I was sad to see her part so minimal. All in all, I rather enjoyed the movie and can't wait to see it again, and again. — Kym Tambini, South San Francisco, Calif.

________________

I am a 44yr old married mom of a teenage girl. I love the books and this movie is excellent. I loved it more than I loved the first one. My 17 yr old loved it, and she didn't care much for this book in the series. I love the way it stayed closer to the book than the first (but given the lack of budget for the first one that had to happen). This one stayed true to Stephenie Meyers book that all fans truly love. I only wish that if you haven't read the books, don't judge the film. This story is one of true love, and loss. It hits it on the head for teenage girls and the fact that Jacob has killer abs and Edward (Huge fan of Pattinson here) is the perfect man who thinks he is a monster and doesn't realize how perfect he is, makes us all feel the true meaning of being a teenage girl again.

So to the critics, lay off. We love it regardless of your reviews.  — Natalie Babb, Land O'Lakes, Fla. 

________________

I thought I was the only one disappointed by the movie's soap opera score. it ruined the movie for me- i actually thought about leaving half way through. The music from Twilight was PERFECT. If they had gone that route, the movie would have been much better. I waited so long for this, read new Moon like 7-8 times, watched twilight countless times... i can believe how bad the music ruined it for me. I hope Eclipse's score is back to the original format. —Amy, Manville, N.M.

________________

I grudgingly went to the midnight showing of New Moon with my wife to garner some much needed favor points to be redeemed at a later date for beers with the boys. I had to forego 4 hours of sleep for what I knew would be a teenage shriek fest any time some shirtless beau dashed across the screen. Having read the books and enjoyed all 4, albeit New Moon the least of them all, I was expecting a slow moving, depressing saga with too little Edward to please the wife, too little quality acting to please me. Sadly New Moon met my expectations and then some. First, let me start by saying the sound track was dreadful. I really can't surmise why they would choose such obscure artists to begin with. Secondly, perhaps it was the screaming post-pubescents or maybe the click click click of constant texting, but I could scarcely hear a word of the apparently moving dialogues. Maybe my beagle could have picked out what Edward said. I did manage to pull my head out of my movie theater nachos complete with fake cheese for the fight scenes and thoroughly enjoyed the wolf-transformations. Having mentioned fake cheese, perhaps it would be prudent to add that it, the fake cheese that is, was far superior to the supremely cheesy "cliff-hanger" at the end of the movie. I have to say I think a cadaver at the morgue could have uttered that line with more life and conviction. All that said, Billy Burke was the standout of the bunch again. Kristin Stewart did a better job than she did in Twilight, and Jacob was almost believable this go around. My glowing two thumbs-down obviously won't influence any torso craving ladies, but for the guys, stay home and watch football.  — Andrew Bryant, Kennesaw, Ga.

________________

Here's the thing people... you say its "boring" and my comment is did you read the book?? It's the slowest one of the 4. It is about heartache and suffering. Not exactly heart pumping action. You say "not enough Rob"... did you read the book??? Come on people... the movie stuck pretty close to the book so why on earth are you shocked?? This movie is essential to bridge the gap to the much faster paced Eclipse. So before you go all "I am bored" with this one... read the book and know that this is one part of a much bigger picture!

And on another note... Miley Cyrus thinks this is a cult?? Perhaps she should look at her own fans who have her face on their bedsheets. Jealous much?  — Kim Colbert, Atlanta

Choice root canal with no anaesthetic, seeing New Moon again. No contest, hello dentist.

This movie was full of drivel, drivel and more drivel mixed with some teenage angst drivel. Boring, silly and a waste of time. — Steve Hoff 

________________

I was a little nervous to see New Moon after the big disappointment I had w/the first movie, Twilight. Because I loved the books so much I decided I would give New Moon a chance, and I am so happy I did. I loved it! The acting, directing, and special effects were 100 times better this time around. I can't wait for the next movie to come out.  — Mary Carnley, Bellevue, Neb.

film was "OMG AWESOME" It was as faithful as any movie taken from book form. Was a thousand times better than twilight which was very choppy. I blame that on Director, was still an ok movie as a first in a series can be. Taylor as always was Jacob to the T. The acting of all was spot on, they seem to become the character that they are acting.

As for the ending it was great place to end it, the theatre I was in had a large moan and lots of NOOOOOOOOOOO's so I think the director made the right move on how to end it. My only criticism I have is the fact that Summit Films is replacing Rachelle Lefevre (Victoria) in the next installments.

Breaks up the chemistry of the film for me. I think that a lot of the twilight fans will be disappointed that this action was taken. Just my opinion.

My overall rating is 5 Howls, Team JACOB...  — Anonymous, Coeur d'Alene, Idaho

________________

Saw the movie this evening with my 2 sisters and nieces. Never read the books, and only saw the original yesterday because we were going to see the second today. As a 40 something year old Mom, I have to say, the best part of the movie (which I thought quite good) was watching with an entire theater packed with 3-17 year old girls. Listening to the collective GASP from the audience when the hunk removed his shirt (revealing his perfect abs) to clean a wound was HYSTERICAL. Listening to my almost 50 year old sister ask them to REWIND THAT PART was even better.

Hearing my other sister (at the end) say...WE AREN'T LEAVING THIS SPOT UNTIL THE NEXT MOVIE COMES OUT...priceless! Great unoffensive movie to giggle through with your teen daughter, ladies!  — Kim Portz, Penn.

________________

Hate it. Bring back catherine hardwicke! what happened to the smoking sound track, and edginess of the Twilight. I think this movie was made for my mother, and I'm no teenager. Hollywood has done what it normally does to european movies — make them bland! Luckily for Stephenie, her books are so loved they'll forgive her this 1 flop. — Anonymous

________________

I don't believe I saw the same movie as everyone else. Half the audience was male, like me, which probably meant half the audience hadn't read the book. I hadn't. I enjoyed it thoroughly. Booing, missles, laughing - where do you boorish people live? Get a life. Bet you won't stay home when the next one comes out. You'll be right there trying to find everything you can to criticize. — Anonymous, Burlington, Vt.

________________

I loved it. I am a HUGE fan of the books. I am 29 normal and married. My husband came with me and he even liked it. He is such a man, that I was worried, but for him to give his approval..... it has to mean something. I don't think they strayed far from the book. They stayed right on track in my opinion. The acting was much much better, the special effects, the whole thing was great. You could tell they had the proper resources this time around.

Just some comments on other reviews:

Of course she was a zombie, she was utterly heart broken and depressed.

It's a movie based off a book, it's not going to be like you pictured it in your head.

It's a depressing book, so of course the movie will seem that way too.

I can't wait to see it again! June can't come fast enough- Eclipse. — Jenny Zimmer, Holland, Mich. 

________________

Seems like they slammed it out, for the big bucks, and lost the true emotion of the story in the process. Not to mention, what they changed, was terrible, and so much that was important, left out! All of the actors did their part, too bad they had a bad boss!  — Barb ott, Saint Marys, Penn.

________________

I wasn't thrilled by this adaptation of the book. Although I think physically Taylor Lautner had Jacob down, his voice and facial expressions didn't do Jacob justice. And what's with Bella e-mailing Alice, why did they have to add that in?! My husband nailed it when he said that the actors seemed detached from the storyline. Granted Kristen Stewert played a very good depressed Bella, but something was just missing. The part with the Volturi was the best, even though they added that fight scene. It's hard to believe Stephenie Meyer was okay with that screenplay. — JMS, Surprise, Ariz.

________________

I am not a Twimom, but just a normal 50 yo woman. the movie made wish I was 20 again. either for Jacob or Edward :) Taylor and Robert respectively played their parts well. Taylor still has a ways to go, but honestly he's not as stiff as he was in the first movie.

People have to realize. This is not Citizen Kane or Casablanca. it wasn't written to be either. It was written to be a fun movie with a different beat to it. And in that context it works, very well.

While I'm not a huge Catherine Hardwick fan (way to many to close close ups for me) she DID make you feel like she FELT it. She got it. The editing was a huge problem with Twilight. That being said, I loved what Chris Weitz did with it. While some of the pauses of the characters was a bit to drawn out and a bit to many of them, I believe he pulled the screenplay that was written together. I do wish that Edwards and Bellas reunion had been a bit deeper. After all her running thru the streets the moment she gets to him was over far to quickly and easily for me. I mean they had been separated for MONTHS...... he thought she was dead and she thought he would be dead.....

I just wish Stephenie Myer had more input on the screenplay.

Overall to me it was worth not getting home until after 3am whenI still had to be at work at 8.

I'll see it again, and again and again, mostly cuz I'm a crazy old woman who really enjoys the cute hotness of the guys :)  — Soozie Laubach, Denver

TOP