News

Obama shields Sasha, Malia from fishbowl life

President Barack Obama's face brightened as he looked up and saw his 8-year-old daughter Sasha on the White House's Truman Balcony. He gave an exaggerated wave, she waved back and photographers captured a rare, unscripted moment.

It seemed innocent enough, yet White House officials asked news organizations not to distribute the image.

Weeks later, when Obama took his daughters for ice cream the Saturday before Father's Day, photographers were permitted to provide family friendly pictures to cable news networks and newspaper front pages. The popular Parade magazine put a candid shot of the First Family on its cover the same weekend, illustrating an article about fatherhood that the White House had suggested.

The two events reflect both the First Family's insistence on raising their young daughters away from the spotlight of the White House and their penchant for carefully using them to bolster the president's political image.

"He's going to try to have it both ways until and unless people start to question his value system and his sincerity in playing that role," said Gerald Shuster, a political communications expert at the University of Pittsburgh.

There haven't been children this young in the White House since the Kennedys nearly 50 years ago. Pictures of Caroline and John went hand-in-hand with the image of youthful vibrancy that administration was trying to project. There's a reason why politicians from the local dogcatcher to potential presidents like pictures of kids — the young, non-misbehaving kind. They're political gold.

  • Slideshow Photos

    National Archives / Getty Images North America

    President Richard Nixon dances with his daughter

    First sons and daughters

    Under many administrations, the corridors of the White House have resounded with the patter of little feet.

  • Barack Obama Holds Election Night Gathering In Chicago's Grant Park

    First sons and daughters

    of

    The future first family

    President elect Barack Obama waves to supporters along with his wife Michelle and daughters Malia and Sasha during an election night gathering in Grant Park on November 4, 2008 in Chicago, Illinois.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Image: The 2012 Democratic National Convention in Charlotte, North Carolina USA

    First sons and daughters

    of

    Proud of dad

    President Obama celebrates with first lady Michelle (left) and daughters Sasha and Malia (right) after speaking at the final night of the Democratic National Convention in Charlotte, North Carolina, on Sept. 6, 2012.

    EPA / EPA
  • The Christian Science Monitor Archive

    First sons and daughters

    of

    Seeing double

    President George W. Bush’s daughter Barbara Bush (left) and her fraternal twin sister Jenna introduce their mother, Laura Bush, during the Republican National Convention at Madison Square Garden in New York City on Sept. 2, 2004.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • The 2012 Couture Council For The Museum At FIT Award For Artistry Of Fashion To Oscar De La Renta

    First sons and daughters

    of

    Stylish sisters

    Fraternal twin sisters Jenna Bush Hager (left) and Barbara Bush, the daughters of President George W. Bush, attend the Couture Council of the Museum at FIT on September 5, 2012 at Lincoln Center in New York City.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Today

    First sons and daughters

    of

    From White House to 30 Rock

    Jenna Bush Hager, daughter of President George W. Bush, became a contributing correspondent for TODAY in September 2009, where she covers a variety of topics.

    NBC / NBC
  • CLINTON

    First sons and daughters

    of

    A family vacation

    Chelsea Clinton holds hands with her mother, first lady Hillary Clinton, and father, President Bill Clinton, as they depart for vacation across the White House lawn in August 1998. Also enjoying the walk is presidential pet Buddy.

    AP / AP
  • Clinton And Chelsea

    First sons and daughters

    of

    Put your head on my shoulder

    First daughter Chelsea Clinton gets some fatherly support from her dad, President Bill Clinton, at the White House in 1993.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Rock Center with Brian Williams

    First sons and daughters

    of

    First daughter makes a difference

    Chelsea Clinton, daughter of President Bill Clinton, joined NBC News in 2011 where she reports for "Nightly News" and often contributes to their "Making a Difference" series. Clinton also reports for the newsmagazine "Rock Center."

    NBC / NBC
  • Sam Leblond;George H. W. Bush [& Family];Pierce Bush;John E. Jr. Bush;Jenna Bush;Marshall Bush;Barbara Bush

    First sons and daughters

    of

    Pajama party

    President George H.W. Bush and first lady Barbara Bush are likely to get little rest as they share a bedroom get-together with their grandchildren in 1990: from left, Pierce; twins Barbara and Jenna (in bed); Marshall; Jeb. Jr., and Sam LeBlond.

    Time & Life Pictures/Getty Image / Time & Life Pictures/Getty Image
  • Portrait Of Ronald Reagan And Family

    First sons and daughters

    of

    Family portrait

    President Ronald Reagan poses for a photo with first lady Nancy Reagan and their family at Rancho del Cielo near Santa Barbara, California, on November 28, 1985.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Gingrich Campaigns Across Florida One Day Before Primary

    First sons and daughters

    of

    A former first son's endorsement

    Michael Reagan, son of President Ronald Reagan, speaks at a campaign rally for Republican presidential candidate, former Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich, who listens with his wife Callista at the Hyatt Regency Jacksonville Riverfront hotel January 30, 2012 in Jacksonville, Florida.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • First sons and daughters

    of

    Back to school

    Amy Carter, daughter of President Jimmy Carter, seems less than eager as she walks by a group of reporters and photographers at Thaddeus Stevens School in Washington, D.C. for her first day of classes in January 1977. She was escorted by first lady Rosalynn Carter and Secret Service agents.

    AP / AP
  • President Carter & Daughter In Oval Office

    First sons and daughters

    of

    Daddy's girl

    In the Oval Office in 1978, President Jimmy Carter takes daughter Amy into his lap for a fatherly talk.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • 1976 Presidential Elections - Ford's Concession

    First sons and daughters

    of

    The agony of defeat

    First lady Betty Ford comforts her son John ("Jack") Ford as the family gathers in the Oval Office following the President Gerald Ford's concession of the 1976 presidential election to his Democratic opponent, Jimmy Carter on November 3, 1976. Pictured from left to right are the president’s sons Steven Ford and John Ford; Betty Ford; President Gerald Ford; his daughter Susan Ford; his daughter-in-law Gayle Ford; and her husband Michael Ford.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Susan Ford And Gerald Ford

    First sons and daughters

    of

    Formal fun

    In white tie and tails, President Gerald R. Ford jokes with his daughter Susan prior to a diplomatic reception on Oct. 5, 1974. First lady Betty Ford could not attend the event due to mastectomy surgery.

    Time & Life Pictures/Getty Image / Time & Life Pictures/Getty Image
  • 6th Annual MusiCares MAP Fund Benefit Concert - Arrivals

    First sons and daughters

    of

    Supporting a cause

    Susan Ford Bales, daughter of President Gerald Ford, arrives at the 6th Annual MusiCares MAP Fund Benefit Concert at Club Nokia on May 7, 2010 in Los Angeles, California. Ford Bales is a former chairman of the board of the Betty Ford Center for alcohol and drug abuse.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Ex-President Richard M. Nixon Leaves The White House

    First sons and daughters

    of

    Farewell to the chief

    From left, President Nixon’s daughter Julie Nixon Eisenhower; her husband, David Eisenhower; Betty Ford, and Vice President Gerald R. Ford watch President Nixon's helicopter take off from the White House lawn moments after Nixon's resignation, August 9, 1974. Ford stepped into the office as president that day.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • First sons and daughters

    of

    Two presidents in the family

    Julie Nixon Eisenhower, youngest daughter of President Richard Nixon and wife to President Dwight Eisdenhower's grandson David, speaks at the China Institute Annual Benefit Gala at the Mandarin Oriental Hotel June 15, 2005 in New York City.

  • President Richard Nixon dances with his daughter

    First sons and daughters

    of

    Dancing with Dad

    President Richard Nixon dances with his daughter, Tricia, during her June 12, 1971 wedding reception at the White House.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Patricia "Tricia" Nixon Cox (born Februa

    First sons and daughters

    of

    A father's legacy

    The oldest daughter of President Richard Nixon, Patricia "Tricia" Nixon Cox, introduces U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton at the United States Institute of Peace "The Week That Changed the World," to mark the 40th anniversary of her father's trip to China and to discuss the future of U.S.-China relations on March 7, 2012.

    AFP / Getty Images / AFP / Getty Images
  • Lucy Baines Johnson

    First sons and daughters

    of

    Laughing Lucy

    With the Washington Monument as backdrop, President Lyndon B. Johnson’s daughter Lucy Baines Johnson enjoys a cheerful moment outside the White House in 1964.

    Time & Life Pictures/Getty Image / Time & Life Pictures/Getty Image
  • Lyndon B. Johnson;Lynda Bird Johnson;Lucy Baines Johnson

    First sons and daughters

    of

    Three LBJs

    President Lyndon B. Johnson enjoys some family time with daughters Lucy Baines Johnson (left) and Lynda Bird Johnson (right) on March 1, 1964.

    Time & Life Pictures/Getty Image / Time & Life Pictures/Getty Image
  • Image: Luci Johnson

    First sons and daughters

    of

    Remembering their father

    Luci Baines Johnson (left) and her sister, Lynda Johnson Robb, talk during ceremonies to commemorate the 100th birthday of their father, President Lyndon B. Johnson at the family cemetery on the LBJ Ranch, located near Stonewall, Texas on Aug. 27, 2008.

    AP / AP
  • John Kennedy Jr. playing in the Oval Office

    First sons and daughters

    of

    Hide and seek

    John Kennedy Jr. seems to be playing secret advisor to his dad, President John F. Kennedy, in the Oval Office in October 1963.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • John F. Kennedy [& Family];Caroline B. Kennedy

    First sons and daughters

    of

    Hop, skip and a jump

    President Kennedy walks hand-in-hand with his daughter at the White House, but it appears Caroline would rather skip the cracks between the paving stones, March 17, 1961.

    Time & Life Pictures/Getty Image / Time & Life Pictures/Getty Image
  • Obama Accepts Nomination On Final Day Of Democratic National Convention

    First sons and daughters

    of

    Sweet Caroline

    Caroline Kennedy, oldest child of President John F. Kennedy, walks on stage during the final day of the Democratic National Convention at Time Warner Cable Arena on September 6, 2012 in Charlotte, North Carolina.

    Getty Images / Getty Images

Yet even during the Kennedy administration, first lady Jacqueline didn't like the children being photographed, and a picture taken outside the White House of Caroline and her pet pony infuriated the first couple, said Dennis Brack, former chief of the White House News Photographers Association.

Images are great when they can be controlled. And when it comes to the Obama kids, the White House can be very controlling.

Sasha and her 10-year-old sister Malia have been shielded carefully from the public, but they are by no means invisible.

"If the children are participating in official events with the president and first lady, then they're part of the first family," said White House press secretary Robert Gibbs. "But when the children are alone, or when the president and first lady are in their roles strictly as mother and father, there should be a wide berth of privacy extended to the family."

Protecting the children in their new fishbowl life was a learning process for the Obamas. The girls answered questions, with their parents, during a soft "Access Hollywood" interview last summer. Obama later said he regretted setting that precedent, and they haven't been interviewed since. But the interview came just as Obama was kicking off his general election campaign and the girls no doubt helped cement in the public mind an image of Obama that campaign officials relished.

During NBC's recent "Inside the Obama White House," the family turned down the network's request to film the girls. NBC showed tape of Obama cheering on the sidelines at Sasha's soccer game; photographers complied with a request not to shoot her playing.

The administration asks that no pictures be taken at the White House of the girls unless they're at a public event; the residence and the outside grounds are off limits. Those were the boundaries they were trying to protect with the lawn and balcony photos.

The White House has made available a handful of images of the children online through its own photo service on the FlickR Web site, showing them playing on the new swing set, walking their dog Bo or giggling with dad. It's primarily an attempt to control paparazzi by eliminating their market, Gibbs said.

Gibbs adds an extra layer of control by posting only low-resolution pictures. So if a magazine or other publication wants to use a family photo, they'd have to specifically ask the White House for a better-quality version. Gibbs has refused some of those requests, in effect becoming an editor. The Parade magazine photos, for instance, were all provided by a White House photographer.

It illustrates the fine line politicians dance upon with families, said John Matviko, editor of "The American President in Popular Culture."

Matviko noted last summer how Republicans admonished reporters for prying into Bristol Palin's pregnancy while the family of vice presidential candidate Sarah Palin was prominently on display at the Republican convention. "Either the children are out of bounds, and you don't put them in the photo ops, or you don't complain when somebody wants to talk about them," he said.

There is some discontent among White House photographers about the administration's aggressiveness in putting out their own images while trying to restrict the work of professionals. In the case of the White House lawn photo, some organizations — including The Associated Press — refused the request not to use the picture of Obama's waving daughter.

News photographers may not be happy, but there's likely to be public sympathy for the Obamas' position. It seems the family is giving a lot of attention to how the kids are being raised, said Joe Kelly, co-founder of Dads and Daughters, an organization that promotes father-daughter relationships.

"There is a big demand," Kelly said. "People want to see pictures of the kids. Better to try to sate that demand in some measured way than to allow a horde of photographers to follow them wherever they go."

TOP