News

For female candidates, Clinton conservative trumps Palin chic

At a glance, Ms. Palin — she of the designer jackets, rump-hugging skirts and knee-high boots — would seem to have been a game changer, loosening up a restrictive, if unwritten, campaign dress code with one that expresses a more conventionally feminine look. Her bright, curve-enhancing garments and loose, shoulder-grazing hair — even her rimless glasses — have been taken up by a handful of candidates on the climb. This is especially true of fellow Republicans like Nikki Haley of South Carolina, Christine O’Donnell of Delaware and Representative Michele Bachmann of Minnesota, who appear to be following Ms. Palin’s style cues with striking fidelity.

Lisa A. Kline, the image consultant behind Ms. Palin’s controversial $150,000-plus fashion makeover during the 2008 campaign, views her client’s embrace of an overtly female archetype as a signal of rebellion. “Women want to change their image.” Ms. Kline said in an interview. “They had been in the mimicking-men phase for so long. Now they are going for femininity.”

Well, look again, Ms. Kline. For all the ridicule that Mrs. Clinton’s boxy pantsuits have generated over the years — she seems to own one in every color, from turquoise to fuchsia — her mannishly functional wardrobe remains the go-to choice for women on the path to power.

On their own steam — or perhaps at the suggestion of a battery of campaign advisers — the majority of candidates are retreating, as they have for decades, to the relative safety of an anodyne uniform. Understated to a fault, its chief components are a formless suit, flat or low-heeled shoes and a noncommittal hairstyle. It’s a brusquely masculine image tempered occasionally by a strand of pearls and dainty, never dangly, earrings (the latter deemed too distracting for television cameras).

BLTWY: Copycat style: Are O'Donnell and Palin twins spirits?

“A Palin effect? Show it to me,” said Christine K. Jahnke, a media trainer who advised Mrs. Clinton during her presidential campaign. “Women aren’t trying to look like Sarah Palin. That would be a mistake.”

They are for the most part “still walking a tightrope,” said Ms. Jahnke, who advises female candidates to adopt a high-quality, low-key wardrobe befitting a corporate chief executive. “You have to look approachable and, at the same time, look like you can handle the job,” she said.

Siobhan Bennett, president of the Women’s Campaign Forum, a bipartisan group that seeks to get women elected, sees plenty of Americans adopting Ms. Palin’s glasses and “bedhead” coif. “But that’s in the general populace,” Ms. Bennett stressed, “not on the campaign trail.”

Indeed, there is much to suggest that women who aspire to office continue to dress defensively. Frightened, even terrified, of committing a wardrobe gaffe on national airwaves, most adhere to a rigid, patently dated style that has all the allure of a milk carton.

The prevailing look, modeled on corporate executives, with an occasional nod to the astringent style of female news anchors, is anathema to professional style-watchers. When, during her presidential campaign, Mrs. Clinton declined an invitation to appear in Vogue magazine for fear, her handlers said, of appearing “too feminine,” Anna Wintour fired off a scathing editor’s letter.

“The notion that a contemporary woman must look mannish in order to be taken seriously is frankly dismaying,” Ms. Wintour chided. “I do think Americans have moved on from the power suit mentality. Political campaigns that do not recognize this are making a serious misjudgment.”

BLTWY: Style mavericks: Ten rule-defying politicos

But even a cursory rummage through news clips and Web sites indicates that women courting power still adopt a strategic style of dress conceived to keep their curves — and their characters — neatly under wraps.

Among those candidates, including Palin acolytes, sophistication is in short supply, said Sharon Graubard, a senior executive with Stylesight, a trend-forecasting firm in New York. “These women have yet to figure out a way to project a confident femininity,” Ms. Graubard said. They have yet to work out “an elegant look that doesn’t rely on ill-fitting suits and bad colors.”

The $2,500 Valentino suit that Ms. Palin wore at the Republican convention is cited by Ms. Graubard as an example. “The quality was an improvement over typical campaign wear, but the styling certainly didn’t push any envelope,” she said. Despite her pricey fashion face-lift, Ms. Palin, she said, “looked like a mall mom.”

Larry W. Smith / EPA
epa01476660 Alaska Governor and Vice President nominee Sarah Palin address the third session of the 2008 Republican National Convention in the Xcel Energy Center in St. Paul, Minnesota, USA 03 September 2008. The convention is scheduled to run through 04 September where Arizona Senator John McCain is expected to receive the Republican nomination as a presidential candidate. EPA/LARRY W. SMITH

Simon Doonan, the creative director of Barneys New York, has attempted to temper such arguments with a dose of common sense. Writing last week in Slate, he argued that flamboyance and politics are mutually exclusive. “Leave the Cavalli jumpsuits and Balmain new-punk to we constituents,” Mr. Doonan pleaded.

While common sense would seem to dictate that an essentially conservative formula is being adopted chiefly by women over 45, that is not necessarily the case. In matters of wardrobe there is no discernible generational divide, according to Ms. Jahnke. The tendency among women of varying ages is to adopt a style that is “office appropriate,” she said, “and that by definition is conservative.”

There is a generational divide in the way these women approach their appearance. “Younger women almost instinctively know they have to pay attention to how they look,” Ms. Jahnke said. “They’ll say: ‘Help me fix my hair. What makeup do I need for high-definition television?’ ” Older women, she said, tend to be less focused on appearance. “You need to convince or cajole them to update their hairstyle, their eyeglasses, their suits.”

Didi Barrett, a Democratic candidate for the State Senate in New York, favors a wardrobe of all-occasion shirt-jackets custom-tailored by a seamstress in Rhinebeck, N.Y. At a Democratic rally in Hyde Park last week, she wore a plain-Jane teal jacket and windowpane shawl. “When you are courting voters,” she said, “you need to accommodate their expectations.”

Barbara Jeter-Jackson, who represents Poughkeepsie, N.Y., in the Dutchess County legislature, was turned out at the rally in a chalk-stripe pantsuit that echoed the garb of her constituents, who, regardless of age, for the most part wore unlined jackets or cardigans and loose pants. Ms. Jeter-Jackson made sure her suit would violate no unofficial taboos. After all, as she said, a woman in office “can’t be too provocative.”

  • Slideshow Photos

    Alex Wong / Getty Images North America

    Image: First Lady Michelle Obama Hosts Talent Show At White House

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    The first lady looks as sophisticated in designer dresses as she does in outfits from J. Crew.

  • Image: First Lady Michelle Obama Hosts Talent Show At White House

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    The first lady looks as sophisticated in designer dresses as she does in outfits from J. Crew. Take a look at her great style:

    Michelle Obama, wearing a a Michael Kors optic white dress, speaks during a talent show at the East Room of the White House May 20, 2014 in Washington, DC.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Image: First Lady Michelle Obama Hosts Annual Mother's Day Tea Honoring Military Mothers

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Silver lining

    Michelle Obama, wearing a festive shirtdress, hosts the annual Mother's Day tea to honor military mothers at the White House May 12, 2014 in Washington, DC.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Image: President Obama attends White House Correspondent's Association Dinner - Washington

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Giving the bold shoulder

    Michelle Obama wears a white Marchesa gown with a drop shoulder strap at the annual White House Correspondent's Association Gala on May 3, 2014.

    EPA / EPA
  • Image: Michelle Obama

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Berry beautiful

    Michelle Obama smiles as she answers questions during the White House's annual "Take Our Daughters and Sons to Work Day," on April 24, 2014, wearing a Sophie Theallet cardigan and leather and chiffon skirt.

    AP / AP
  • Image: Michelle Obama, Jill Biden, James McConville

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Fashion forward

    First lady Michelle Obama wears a colorful wrap dress and sits with Jill Biden, wife of Vice President Joe Biden, and Maj. Gen. James McConville at a jobs fair for military members and spouses at Fort Campbell, Ky. on April 23, 2014.

    AP / AP
  • Image: President And Mrs Obama Host Annual White House Easter Egg Roll

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Keeping it casual

    Wearing a plaid blouse and black pants, the first lady walks her dogs Sunny and Bo on the South Lawn of the White House at the annual White House Easter Egg Roll in Washington on April 21, 2014.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Image: US-POLITICS-EASTER-OBAMA

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    White House, white dress

    Dressed in all white, Michelle Obama and President Barack Obama depart from the White House in Washington on April 20, 2014 as they head to Easter services at St. John's Episcopal Church.

    AFP - Getty Images / AFP - Getty Images
  • Image: Obama and Bow Wow hold a forum with high school students at Howard University in Washington

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Rappin'

    Michelle Obama and hip-hop artist Bow Wow hold a forum with high school students at Howard University in Washington on April 17, 2014. Obama rocked a maroon pantsuit and black flats.

    Reuters / Reuters
  • Image: US-POLITICS-OBAMA-CIVIL RIGHTS

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Classy for a cause

    The first lady wears a simple black and blue striped skirt paired with a white top and matching shrug to speak at the Lyndon B. Johnson Presidential Library in Austin, Texas, during a civil rights summit on April 10, 2014.

    AFP - Getty Images / AFP - Getty Images
  • Image: US-MILITARY-SHOOTING-OBAMA

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    In mourning

    President Barack Obama and First Lady Michelle Obama leave after paying their respects during a memorial service at Fort Hood in Texas on April 9, 2014.

    AFP - Getty Images / AFP - Getty Images
  • Image: Michelle Obama, Dynasty Meade, Silas Stutz

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Gettin' dirty

    First Lady Michelle Obama gets down and dirty in a tunic, pants and trenchcoat while planting oats with students at the White House Kitchen Garden at the White House in Washington on April 2, 2014.

    AP / AP
  • Image: First Lady Michelle Obama Travels to China - Day 2

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Radiant in red

    First lady Michelle Obama, wearing a red Alexander McQueen gown, posed with her mother Marian Robinson during a visit with Chinese President Xi Jinping and his wife Peng Liyuan at the Diaoyutai State guest house on March 21, 2014 in Beijing, China.

    Pool via Getty Images / Pool via Getty Images
  • Image: Michelle Obama

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Ping-pong fun

    Michelle Obama plays table tennis at the Beijing Normal School, a school that prepares students to attend colleges overseas, in Beijing, China on March 21, 2014.

    AP / AP
  • Image: Michelle Obama, Sasha Obama

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Welcome to China

    Michelle Obama waves as she and her daughter Sasha leave their plane at Capital International Airport in Beijing on March 20, 2014.

    Pool via AP / Pool via AP
  • Image: Obama and Kenny attend a St. Patrick's Day Reception

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Green day

    Vice president Joe Biden, first lady Michelle Obama, and Irish Prime Mininster Enda Kenny's wife Fionnuala O'Kelly smile during a St. Patrick's Day reception in the East Room of the White House on March 14, 2014.

    EPA / EPA
  • Image: The First Lady And Joint Chiefs Chairman Dempsey Host Screening Of Muppets Most Wanted

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    We're green with envy

    Kermit the Frog is welcomed by Michelle Obama, who is wearing a printed Diane Von Furstenberg wrap dress, at a screening of Disney's "Muppets Most Wanted" on March 12, 2014 in Washington, DC.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Image: US-POLITICS-OBAMA-VACATION-RETURN

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Seeking shades

    President Barack Obama and Michelle Obama make their way to board Air Force One before departing from Homestead Air Reserve Base in Homestead, Florida on March 9, 2014.

    AFP - Getty Images / AFP - Getty Images
  • Image: The First Lady Hosts Women In Soul Music Workshop And Performance At White House

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Pretty prints

    Michelle Obama delivers remarks during s workshop titled "I'm Every Woman: The History of Women in Soul" with (L-R) Grammy Museum Executive Director Robert Santelli, and music artists Melissa Etheridge, Janelle Monae and Patti LaBelle in the State Dining Room at the White House March 6, 2014 in Washington, DC.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Jump to it

    Michelle Obama sports a chic black jumpsuit during an interview with Jimmy Fallon on Feb. 20, 2014.

    NBC; Getty Images / NBC; Getty Images
  • Image: Michelle Obama, Rose Cameron

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Pretty as a painting

    Michelle Obama, in a bold print skirt, is escorted by Rose Cameron, CEO and founder of WAT-AAH!, a line of bottled water targeted to kids and teens, as they view the "Taking Back the Streets" art exhibit at the New Museum in New York on Feb. 20.

    AP / AP
  • Image: U.S. First Lady Skis In Aspen

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Snow bunny

    Michelle Obama skis at Buttermilk Mountain in Aspen, Colo. on Feb. 15. This is the third year in a row that Michelle Obama has vacationed in Aspen over the long President's Day weekend.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Image: US-FRANCE-DIPLOMACY-OBAMA-HOLLANDE

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Ultimate elegance

    President Barack Obama and Michelle Obama, in a dramatic Carolina Herrera ball gown, arrive at a state dinner at the White House on Feb. 11. The dress featured a sheer black top with hand-embroidered and beaded appliques and sleeves that dipped just below the first lady's elbows.

    AFP - Getty Images / AFP - Getty Images
  • Image: President Obama And First Lady Welcome French President  Hollande To The White House

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Lady in red

    First lady Michelle Obama wears a ravinshing red Thom Browne coat and, along with French President Francois Hollande and President Barack Obama, waves at the balcony of the White House on Feb. 11.

    Getty Images / Getty Images
  • Image: U.S. first lady Michelle Obama (C) waves next to U.S. Army Ranger Sgt. First Class Remsburg prior to President Barack Obama's State of the Union speech on Capitol Hill in Washington

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Deep green

    Michelle Obama, in a hunter green Azzedine Alaïa dress, waves next to U.S. Army Ranger Sgt. First Class Cory Remsburg, who was injured while serving in Afghanistan, prior to President Barack Obama's State of the Union speech in Washington on Jan. 28, 2014.

    Reuters / Reuters
  • Image: US-POLITICS-EDUCATION-OBAMA

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Vision in blue

    First Lady Michelle Obama smiles as she listens to President Barack Obama speak at an event on expanding college opportunity in the South Court Auditorium of the Eisenhower Executive Office Building in Washington on Jan. 16, 2014.

    AFP - Getty Images / AFP - Getty Images
  • Image: US-POLITICS-OBAMA-EDUCATION

    Michelle Obama’s effortless style

    of

    Bold bling

    Michelle Obama wore a festive lucite necklace while speaking about education in underserved communities in the State Dining Room following a screening of the movie "The Inevitable Defeat of Mister and Pete" at the White House on Jan. 15, 2014.

    AFP - Getty Images / AFP - Getty Images

OR too careful, it would seem. In an age of punctilious correctness, commenting on a candidate’s attire is perceived more than ever as trivializing, if not sexist or downright demeaning. Yet women seeking office continue to attract the kind of physical scrutiny that is rarely directed at a man.

In a 2008 article, “Cutting Women Out: The Media’s Bias Against Female Candidates,” Erika Falk, who studied eight races in the 2008 elections, concluded that “coverage of how women candidates look — while ignoring such observations about men candidates — has been an ongoing problem.”

Ms. Falk, who runs the master’s degree program in communication at Johns Hopkins University, found that each of eight female candidates that year received about “four physical descriptions for every one that described a man.” At the time, she added, about 29 percent of articles about Hillary Clinton contained a physical description.”

“Historically, we’ve associated masculinity with leadership,” Ms. Falk said in an interview. “If you’re a woman politician, it makes pretty good sense to come off in a stereotypically masculine way.”

To ignore that assessment is to invite the pointed and often distracting comments that continue to pepper mainstream media coverage. A July profile of Ms. Haley in Newsweek began by observing that the candidate wore “a snug, saffron-colored suit and stilettos you could impale a small animal with.”

In September the Daily News coyly observed that Senator Kirsten Gillibrand, who is seeking re-election in New York, has become “a leaner, meaner campaign machine ... showing a slimmer silhouette as a tough election battle looms.”

Only last week the Daily News took a swipe at Mrs. Clinton, observing that she “has had more hairstyles than a beauty-school dummy.”

Senator Gillibrand, who, with Nancy Pelosi, the House speaker, is often singled out as a smartly tailored fashion role model, likes to deflect that sort of commentary. “You would never write about Chuck Schumer’s shoes,” she told a reporter for New York magazine in response to a question about her flats.

Yet she submitted to a fashion makeover in the November issue of Vogue, shedding her earnest navy or gray tailored suits for a form-fitting Michael Kors sheath and a reefer coat. Was Vogue’s sartorial endorsement a boost or bane for her campaign? Senator Gillibrand’s office declined to comment.

Which underscores the quandary. Ignore current fashion and you risk seeming out of touch. Embrace it too warmly and you undermine your credibility. Ms. Bachmann, it might be argued, is a case in point. Her expensive-looking wardrobe, Ms. Jahnke maintained, “puts her out of step with her district,” which has a high unemployment rate.

A successful politician, Mr. Doonan wrote in Slate, must appear Prada-oblivious: “Any hint of dandyism or vanity would indicate a superficial, self-indulgent character.”

Politicians, he added, “dress as to be unremarkable.”

He might have been describing Ms. Barrett, the State Senate candidate, who has tried to distance herself from flashier peers by giving up the biker boots and folkloric scarves she wore in her pre-stump days. Appearance is a concern, she acknowledged. “But in the pecking order of campaign priorities, I don’t think it’s a significant one.”

Still, she said, after a beat, “When I see myself on television, I think, ‘Ah, image.’ ”

This story, “The Fashion Conservatives," originally appeared in The New York Times.

TOP