1. Headline
  1. Headline

Video: Royal family suing over topless photos of Duchess Kate

  1. Closed captioning of: Royal family suing over topless photos of Duchess Kate

    >>> prince william and kate middleton continue their tour of southeast asia , but it is photos that were taken halfway around the world and published in a french magazine that have created an international scandal. nbc's duncan golestani is outside the palace.

    >> reporter: the duke and duchess of cambridge will take legal action against the french tabloid which posted topless pictures of the princess. there has been a furious response, a level of anger rarely seen. kate and william 's tour of southeast asia has provided countless images of the royal couple. but now the most talked about pictures are the ones they can't control. printed across five pages of a french gossip magazine , intimate photos taken on vacation last week in which the duchess can be seen topless.

    >> for me, those pictures are not shocking. just beautiful couple and in love couple.

    >> kate and william disagree. first they were said to be saddened. later that changed to furious. the palace called publication grotesque and totally unjustifiable, saying it's reminiscent of the worst excesses of the press and paparazzi during the life of diana, princess of wales . it was also in france she spent her last days. it is a harsh reminders about the pearls of the paparazzi.

    >> i would think that he would be absolutely furious. absolutely livid. how could he not be? because it will bring everything back to him and what his mother went through. i do not want that to happen to the duchess of cambridge . i saw what it did to diana and it's absolutely hideous.

    >> reporter: "closer" magazine rejects the comparison and insists they weren't trying to hide themselves. no british tabloid plans to use the pictures, unlike the nude photos of prince harry , which made front page news. this morning, kate and william had a tree top adventure to keep them busy. but they know a far greater challenge is waiting for them when they return home. legal experts agree it won't be too difficult to win a court case in france . the problem is already an italian gossip magazine says it too will print the nude pictures . that means they are spreading around the world and there's no stopping them. kate ?

    >> thank you. martin bashir , longtime royal follower. this is really the first time the palace has taken legal action about a photo. why is this so different?

    >> if you put it in its historical context, it's 30 years to the day virtually that a telephone conversation between princess diana and james gilby was reported on in the sun newspaper . it's 20 years since sarah ferguson was photographed having her toes sucked by a texan millionaire. 15 years since princess diana died being chased by paparazzi. on none of those occasions did the royal family take any legal action . this is unprecedented and an indication of how appalled they are.

    >> does it have anything to do with what we saw just last month with prince harry and the partying photos? are they feeling an intrusion, a deeper intrusion than before?

    >> i don't think so. i think this is william , as princess diana 's friend said in the piece, this is william deciding he has to establish some red line . the problem with this is that "closer" magazine is a french magazine and the version that published these images is in france . but it's owned by the italian former prime minister. so the anxiety is that this is going to be a contagion. i think the hope is that by issuing some kind of litigation, it may have the effect of slowing down what will eventually become a wildfire and spread.

    >> this is so personal for prince william , isn't it? i mean, he's spoken before in the past about his mother and how deeply he felt about how her life went.

    >> to be perfectly honest, prince william has been unhappy with the media and the press since he was born. he still harbors the belief that the paparazzi killed his mother. and therefore, this is a terrible echo of the experience of his mother being chased and pursued. the idea that they went to a private residence owned by a relative and assumed that it was miles from anybody else, nobody else was nearby, and they still couldn't have any privacy, to him must be deeply disturbing.

    >> and quickly, kate middleton has had this reputation of never putting a foot wrong. does this tarnish that in any way, topless photos?

    >> i don't think so. i think the issue becomes one of the fact that she has to understand, i guess, that as a member of the royal family , she has no privacy whatsoever.

    >> even on the balcony of your vacation home .

    >> in a private residence owned by a relative. and that's the lesson from this. it was never her fault. it was down to the fact that they made an assumption that they wouldn't be photographed and they were.

    >> always great to have you. thank you so much.

    >> great to see you, kate . thank you.

updated 9/15/2012 12:38:39 PM ET 2012-09-15T16:38:39

An Irish tabloid newspaper broke ranks with its British and Irish rivals to publish topless pictures of the wife of Prince William on Saturday, angering its British co-owners and risking legal action from the royal family.

The royal couple have already begun action against the French magazine Closer for publishing a dozen shots of Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge — the former Kate Middleton — taken as she slipped off her bikini top while sunbathing at a secluded French country house.

The Irish Daily Star published a two-page spread of 10 photographs of the duchess from Closer magazine under the headline "Angry Kate to sue mag over snaps". A teaser headline on the front page promised "the magazine shots everyone wants to see".

A spokeswoman for Prince William condemned the publications, saying: "There can be no motivation for this action other than greed."

An Italian gossip magazine said it would follow suit with a by publishing a 26-page reportage on the duchess on Monday that would include the pictures.

"I did this as a service to our readers, I'm a little taken aback by the reaction in the UK," Irish Daily Star editor Mike O'Kane told the BBC.

"It only seems to be an issue in the UK because she is your future queen. But from our point of view in Ireland, Kate Middleton is just another of the fantastic line of celebrities."

Prince William, Kate 'hugely saddened' by publication of topless photos

The British media group Northern and Shell, which owns 50 percent of the Irish Star, said it had no editorial control over the paper and accused it of a "grotesque" invasion of privacy.

The group, which publishes the Daily Express and Daily Star in Britain, said it was consulting lawyers over what it considered a "serious breach of contract".

Considering response
The Irish media group Independent News and Media, which owns the other 50 percent, declined immediate comment.

  1. Stories from
    1. Paula Deen: I Used the N-Word, but Don't Condone Racism
    2. Meet the Ecstatic Schoolgirl Who Photographed Princes William & Harry
    3. E L James Reveals Director for Fifty Shades of Grey Movie
    4. Kathryn Fiore Remains Hospitalized Following Daughter's Difficult Delivery
    5. Jaime Pressly Chops Off Her Hair - What Do You Think?

The office of Prince William, second in line to the British throne, said in a statement that it would not comment on possible legal action other than saying "all proportionate responses" would be kept under review.

"Any such publication would serve no purpose other than to cause further, entirely unjustifiable upset to the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge, who were enjoying time alone together in the privacy of a relative's home," it said.

Kate, William file lawsuit after French magazine publishes topless photo

The pictures have reignited a debate over privacy and freedom of the press, especially in Britain, where media could face new regulations after a series of publishing scandals.

All British papers have refrained from publishing the photographs, including the Sun, the only British title to run pictures of William's brother Harry naked in a Las Vegas hotel last month.

Italy's Chi magazine said its special edition on Monday would include some unpublished shots of the royal couple.

"The fact that we are dealing with the future British monarchs makes it certainly more interesting and in line with a modern conception of the monarchy," Chi Editor in Chief Alfonso Signorini said.

Both Chi and Closer are controlled by the Italian publisher Mondadori, part of the media empire of former prime minister Silvio Berlusconi and chaired by his daughter Marina.

Diana friend: 'History repeating itself' with Kate

Closer's pictures, already circulating widely on the Internet, were also picked up by several foreign publications.

The Greek newspaper Eleftheros Typos had two photographs of the duchess, one showing her topless, on its front page.

"Her picture will be probably available online until the end of the earth. But it's not the end of the world," commentator Maria Laura Rodota wrote in Italy's biggest daily, Corriere della Sera.

(c) Copyright Thomson Reuters 2012. Click For Restrictions - http://about.reuters.com/fulllegal.asp

Discuss:

Discussion comments

,

Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments

More on TODAY.com

None
  1. Guinea pig fans go extreme: $22,000 outfit, 'pignics'

    6/19/2013 9:56:44 PM +00:00 2013-06-19T21:56:44
None
  1. Google: 'We're not in cahoots with the NSA'

    Google’s chief legal officer tries to reassure customers that their gmail and Internet browsing history are safe from government prying.

    6/19/2013 6:49:04 PM +00:00 2013-06-19T18:49:04
None
  1. Tyler Golden / NBC

    Blake's favorite 'Voice' moment? Meeting Cher

    6/19/2013 10:39:17 PM +00:00 2013-06-19T22:39:17
None
  1. Say it ain't so! Cap'N Crunch not really a captain?

    Everyone knows Cap’N Crunch for its deliciously sweet corn taste and lovable nautical mascot, but an eagle-eyed cereal lover has just uncovered a potentially shocking secret.

    6/19/2013 9:00:39 PM +00:00 2013-06-19T21:00:39
  2. capncrunch.com
None
  1. What Duchess Kate’s ‘maternity leave’ means

    Officially, the Duchess of Cambridge is off the grid, trying to spend the final weeks of her pregnancy out of a limelight. Unofficially, she has gone on leave, one that may stretch through the rest of the year – and possibly longer.

    6/19/2013 3:52:49 PM +00:00 2013-06-19T15:52:49
  2. Kate to give birth in same hospital as Princess Diana
  3. slideshow Duchess Kate’s maternity style
  4. Getty Images