1. Headline
  1. Headline
Follow in the fun on Twitter and Instagram: #TODAYinHawaii

Video: Who makes the best lobster roll in NYC?

TODAY recipes
updated 6/4/2012 10:46:53 AM ET 2012-06-04T14:46:53

Three contestants from the TastingTable.com's annual Lobster Roll Rumble started the competition a bit early this morning, previewing their dishes for judges Kathie Lee and Hoda.

The contestants were Barbara Lynch, CEO of Barbara Lynch Gruppo, Marc Murphy, executive chef and owner of Landmarc and Ditch Plains restaurants, and Luke Holden, president and founder of Luke's Lobsters.

See which dish our fourth-hour gals' gave top billing in the video above. But don't take Kathie Lee and Hoda's word for it: Make the three recipes at home and tell us in the comments which one tastes best.

More:Lobster rolls: Do you go butter or mayo?

Recipe: Lemon Aïoli Lobster Rolls (on this page) Recipe: Ditch Plains Lobster Roll (on this page) Recipe: Luke’s Lobster Roll (on this page)

Recipe: Lemon Aïoli Lobster Rolls

Ingredients
  • 4 lobsters, each about 1 1/4 pounds
  • 1 cup lemon aioli or 1 cup mayonnaise mixed with 1 teaspoon fresh lemon juice
  • 1/2 cup peeled, very finely chopped celery
  • Kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper
  • 4 top-split hot dog rolls (I like Pepperidge Farm)
  • 4 tablespoons or a 1/2 stick unsalted butter, at room temperature
  • 1 tablespoon finely chopped fresh chives
Preparation

Bring a large pot of water to a boil and fill a clean sink or very large bowl with ice water.

Cook the lobsters, covered, for about 10 minutes. Plunge them into the ice water to halt the cooking.

Twist the tails off the bodies. Cut each tail lengthwise into two pieces, removing the intestinal tracts. Remove the claw meat by snapping off the little pincers first. Using the back of a heavy chef’s knife or good kitchen scissors, crack open the claws and remove the meat. Remove the knuckle meat too. Cut the meat into generous bite-sized pieces.

Gently toss the lobster meat with the aioli and celery. Season to taste with salt and pepper and refrigerate until ready to serve.

To serve, open up the rolls as wide as you can to accommodate all the lobster meat. Butter the hot dog rolls on the outside and toast them on a griddle or in a skillet until nicely golden brown. Taste the lobster salad again to see if it needs more seasoning (cold foods often do) and divide it among the 4 rolls, overstuffing them. Garnish the lobster with the chives.

Serving Size

Serves four

Recipe: Ditch Plains Lobster Roll

Ingredients
  • 2 pounds of lobster meat, approximately three to four lobsters
  • 3/4 cup mayo
  • 1/4 cup dijon mustard
  • 1 tablespoons roasted garlic
  • 1 tablespoons tarragon, finely chopped
  • 1 tablespoons parsley, finely chopped
  • 1 cup celery fine dice
  • 1/3 cup scallions sliced
  • 1 teaspoons old bay seasoning
  • Lemon, halved
  • 1 onion, halved
  • 3 ribs of celery, rough chopped
  • 2 cups of white wine
  • Salt
  • Black pepper
Preparation

Break down the lobster by removing the two claws and the tail.

Bring a large pot of water to a boil, add 1 lemon, 1 onion, 3 ribs of celery and 2 cups of white wine. Add the lobster to the pot and continue to boil. The tails will take about 10 minutes and the claws will take between six and seven minutes.

Once the lobster is cooked, take it out of the water and place in an ice bath to stop the cooking. Remove the meat from the tail and claws. Cut the tail in half lengthwise and then again in half lengthwise and chop. Cut the claw meat in half and chop the same size as the tail meat.

Mix chopped lobster meat with mayo, mustard, roasted garlic, tarragon, parsley, celery and scallions until incorporated. Season with old bay and salt and pepper.

Place into the refrigerator and let sit for about an hour. Serve on grilled and buttered potato hot dog buns.

Serving Size

Serves four

Recipe: Luke’s Lobster Roll

Ingredients
  • 1/4 pound fresh Maine lobster meat
  • Spoonful of mayonnaise
  • Drizzle of butter, melted
  • 1 New England-style hot dog bun
  • Pinch of celery salt
  • Pinch of black pepper
  • Pinch oregano
Preparation

Our rolls are served Maine style: The seafood is served chilled on a toasted split-top bun with just a swipe of mayo, a drizzle of lemon butter and a dash of our secret spices.

Butter both sides of a split New England-style hot dog bun and grill until golden brown.

Line the inside of the bun with some mayonnaise. Add 1/4 pound of fresh Maine lobster meat.

Drizzle some melted lemon-butter on top of the lobster.

Sprinkle a little Luke’s Lobster Secret Spices — equal parts celery salt, black pepper, oregano -- on top. Serve!

Serving Size

Serves one

Discuss: What did you think of this recipe?

How many stars would you give the dish? If you made changes, tell us how you customized it.

Discussion comments

,

More on TODAY.com

None
  1. Behind the scenes of TODAY’s American Adventure

    Producers are on location, scouting out the very best things to see and do in Hawaii, Yellowstone, Chicago, Orlando and the Jersey Shore.

    5/17/2013 9:32:50 PM +00:00 2013-05-17T21:32:50
  2. TODAY’s itinerary: From Hawaii to the Jersey Shore

    The anchors are packing their bags! For the first time in TODAY history, all five anchors — Matt, Savannah, Natalie, Al and Willie — are traveling together.

    5/17/2013 11:34:16 AM +00:00 2013-05-17T11:34:16
  3. Facts about TODAY’s Hawaii location

    The show's broadcasting from Honolulu's historic Royal Hawaiian hotel, a landmark in Hawaii since 1927.

    5/20/2013 11:18:39 AM +00:00 2013-05-20T11:18:39
  4. NBC
None
  1. 1 killed, 21 hurt as tornadoes ravage Plains

    A vast area of the central U.S. was warned to prepare for storms on Monday, after tornadoes killed one and injured 21 in Oklahoma and also hit Iowa and Kansas.

    5/20/2013 9:10:03 AM +00:00 2013-05-20T09:10:03
None
  1. John Shearer / AP

    Taylor Swift a hit, others miss at Billboard awards

    5/20/2013 5:37:27 AM +00:00 2013-05-20T05:37:27
None
  1. Obama to college grads: ‘No excuses’

    5/20/2013 2:25:53 AM +00:00 2013-05-20T02:25:53