1. Headline
  1. Headline
Image: Ted Geisel (Dr. Seuss)
Al Ravenna/World Telegram & Sun/
Ted Geisel (a.k.a. Dr. Seuss)
By
TODAY contributor
updated 4/26/2012 3:28:21 PM ET 2012-04-26T19:28:21

Is there a child around who doesn’t know green eggs are an especially delicious with ham, whether they’re eaten in a boat or in a house, with a goat or with a mouse?

Dr. Seuss books, a staple of childhood, have incited recent scrutiny for their apparent political undertones. The Prince Rupert School District in British Columbia, Canada is alleging that a certain Dr. Seuss quote is unfit for children due to its vaguely disguised political messaging meant to promote unrest and incite rebellion.

9 most subversive children’s books ever written

The quote in question comes from the story “Yertle the Turtle” about a turtle, Yertle, who is the king of the pond and stands on other turtle’s backs in an attempt to reach higher than the moon. The story reads, “I know up on top you are seeing great sights, but down here on the bottom, we too should have rights.” The turtle on the bottom says, “I’ve pain in my back, my shoulders and knees — how long must we stand here, your majesty please.” The lowest turtle then burps and Yertle falls into the mud, ending his rule.

Happy birthday, Dr. Seuss!

The teacher that has spurred the controversy did not use the quote from “Yertle the Turtle” in the classroom, but brought it to a meeting with school management when she received a notice about the visible union material in her car, which is a no-no on school property.

  1. More in books
    1. Harlan Coben returns with ‘Six Years’
    2. ‘I Would Die 4 U’: How Prince became an icon
    3. ‘Until I Say Good-Bye’: Living for love in the face of ALS
    4. Letters from the life of George H.W. Bush
    5. Mom turns sleeping baby into fairy-tale star

The school was not amused by the teacher’s use of the quote, and has barred use of it in the classroom, whether it is displayed or worn on clothing. Dave Stigant, acting director of instruction for the B.C. school district, said that it was necessary to review the Dr. Seuss quotes to shield children from political messaging.  “It’s a matter of legality and living up to our obligation to children and their families,” Mr. Stigant said.

The fiasco has exacerbated an already existing problem between the school and the teachers of the Prince Rupert School District, who are currently embroiled in a labor dispute.

The best Dr. Seuss books and apps

It isn’t only the school that has accused Seuss’s stories of not being the innocent fables they purport to be, but vessels of liberal-leaning indoctrination aimed at children. Just recently, Lou Dobbs of Fox Business called the film adaptation of Seuss’s “The Lorax” a product of “the President’s liberal friends in Hollywood…using animation to sell their agenda to children.” The story features the Lorax, a creature speaking for the trees about the dangers of industrialization to forests. Dobbs accused the story of “espousing green energy policy.” Conservative radio host Matt Patrick said he suspected the story could create “occu-toddlers.”

The New York Times recently wrote about Dr. Seuss in an article titled, “The Children’s Authors Who broke The Rules.” The article cites not only his “stylistic eccentricities,” but also that his stories challenged the idea of what children’s books should be. Seuss rejected the idea that children's stories should only be about modeling good behavior and even called himself "subversive as hell." If that subversiveness is still pushing the envelope in 2012, one would think Seuss would be mighty proud.

TODAY.com contributor Jillian Eugenios likes to eat green eggs with ham on a log or on a mat, with a dog or with a cat.

© 2013 NBCNews.com  Reprints

Video: How well do you know Dr. Seuss?

  1. Closed captioning of: How well do you know Dr. Seuss?

    >>> o cf1 o with more of today. we're ready to play "who knew?" since today is dr. seuss 's birthday, fun facts about his books. kathie lee is across the street at the nbc.com digital cafe . she's ready to hand out 100 bucks to those who get it right, to those who don't they get her beautiful music . here with me, chip gibson. i didn't realize e was that old. 100 years.

    >> a lovely group of teachers and students from alabama. all right. which of the following was dr. seuss 's first children's book? green eggs and ham , the cat ii the hat, and to think that i saw it on mulberry street , or the lorax.

    >> to think that i saw it on mulberry street .

    >> wow.

    >> no hesitation.

    >> that's a smart kid.

    >> that was a first one. tell us about it.

    >> actually, it was the first dr. seuss book and nearly the last. 30 publishers rejected this thing. dr. seuss told the story he was walking back after his last rejection heading home to burn the manuscript and start his new career as a dry cleaner. he ran into an old pal that had just tarted his new career as a publisher. jackpot.

    >> what is dr. seuss 's real name ? george ggisel or none of the & above.

    >> theodore geisel .

    >> how do they know all this stuff?

    >> i bet that that clever person didn't know that the original name was dr. theofastus seuss , hard to say even though i've been practicing since 7:00 in the morning. doctor is completely made up. but it beats mr. seuss .

    >> back across to kath .

    >> this family is from atlanta. so far this guy has known everything. a real know it all. how many different words did dr. seuss use to write green eggg 50.

    >> what's goong on? kathie lee , i need to ask kathie lee , what's going on out there? how is it that everyone's getting every one right. she doesn't ccre.

    >> you know what --

    >> tell us the story.

    >> 50 words. seuss 's original publisher, bennett surf, a gambler, bet dr. seuss he cculdn't write a book using only 50 words. you try it this afternoon. it is nearly impossible. he did it brilliantly. he sold 13 million copies of the book.

    >> great story. back across to kath .

    >> this is a strange combination. wisconsin and switserland. we're not going to even ask questions. finish this rhyme from "the cat in the hat ." i know it is wet, and the sun is

    >> fun --

    >> it's only an hour show.

    >> all right. i don't know.

    >> they ddn't know it! they're going to get a great cd.

    >> the correct answer there is "lots of good fun that is funny."

    >> another challenge. back in the early '50s there was a crisis in reading in america. there were all these dreadful -- you're too young. i grew up with readers like "run, jane, run." " see dick run ." nobody looked them. phey weren't interesting. literacy was going down. seuss was challenggd to write a book that was fun. " cat in the hat " came out. he revolutionized everything.

    >> what color was the original grinch in "how the grinch stole christmas?" yellow?

    >> what do you think? red and green. everyone has a story

    >> she loves giving those cdss.

    >> the correct answer, black and white with pink eyes.

    >> i thought green. morning. down the book this black and white with pink eyes. it wasn't until the classic 1966 tv special with chuck jones that he became green. he's been pretty much green in my eyes ever since.

    >> back across to kath .

    >> one quick one. the following quote is from which dr. seuss 's book. "con frajlations! today is your day. you're off to great places! you'reeoff and away!

    >> the places you'll see?

    >> thht's close.

    >> he eeds the money. "oh, the places you'll go!"

    >> he needs my cd more, hoda.

    >> all right.

    >> he's going tooget both of them!

    >> i like it.

    >> i think it's the single greatest graduation and life gift you can ever give. 1991 , it was published. editor's office, delivered thii she knew she had a hit when a few months later at her daughter nicole's college graduation, the valedictorian got up, read the book, closed it to a tanding ovation. it's been a

Explainer: 9 most subversive children’s books ever written

  • Image: Cover of "Dear Genius: The Letters of Ursula Nordstrom"
    HarperCollins

    Ever notice how many kids’ books encourage 3-, 4- and 5-year-olds to stick it to the man? Books with subversive themes — some subtle, some unmistakable — are part of a proud tradition that began decades ago in children’s literature.

    Legendary children’s book editor Ursula Nordstrom had a simple, subversive vision: to publish “good books for bad children.” And, from 1940 to 1973, that’s just what she did. During her remarkable tenure, Nordstrom edited the likes of Shel Silverstein, Maurice Sendak, E.B. White and Margaret Wise Brown and helped bring to birth such classics as “Where the Wild Things Are,” “Charlotte’s Web,” “Harriet the Spy” and “Goodnight Moon.”

    Granted, “Goodnight Moon” isn’t overwhelmingly subversive — (although that old lady who whispers “Hush!” all the time sure seems to be a thorn in the side of that little bunny). But make no mistake: Plenty of classics published in the early and mid-20th century by Nordstrom and others have encouraged thousands upon thousands of little ones to think for themselves. To see how, just click on the “next” arrow at left or click on “show more items” below and keep scrolling down.

  • "Where the Wild Things Are" (1963)

    Image: Cover of "Where the Wild Things Are"
    Harper Collins

    A staple in thousands of children’s book collections for decades now, “Where the Wild Things Are” stars a misbehaving little boy named Max. The tale begins with Max donning his wolf suit and making “mischief of one kind and another” — i.e., ruining a wall inside his house, chasing his dog with a fork and yelling at his mom. He gets sent to bed without his supper — and then gets rewarded for all of that bad behavior with the adventure of a lifetime. “In a way that book is saying that Max is justified in doing what he did because he has this unbelievable, amazing experience,” said children’s book publisher Anne Schwartz, vice president of Schwartz & Wade Books. Max gets to set sail in his own private boat to a land where impressionable, friendly monsters eagerly play with him for hours on end. If you could have an experience like that, would you consider misbehaving?

  • “The Red Balloon” (1956)

    Image: Cover of "The Red Balloon"
    Doubleday Books

    There’s so much to examine in “The Red Balloon” — the classic Albert Lamorisse book adapted from the film by the same name — that it’s worthy of dissection in a Ph.D. dissertation. Throughout the tale, though, one message becomes clear: Adults can be morons. Almost every grown-up in the life of Pascal — a Parisian boy who looks to be about 8 or 9 — fails him in large and small ways. His school principal locks him up in a bathroom-less office for hours; the church guard kicks him out of church for a minor offense; and, in a fit of anger, his mother takes the one item that has made her lonely son a tiny bit happy — a red balloon — and throws it out the window. The circumstances of the story lead readers of any age to cheer Pascal on when he sneaks his balloon friend back into his bedroom and conceals it from his mother. Even better: When the balloons of Paris unite and take Pascal far, far away from all the kid bullies and short-sighted grown-ups in his life. Hooray!

  • “The Little Engine That Could” (1930)

    Image: Cover of "The Little Engine That Could"
    Grosset & Dunlap

    This famous tale of can-do optimism gave us the phrase, “I think I can — I think I can — I think I can” ... but did it also contain a subtly subversive feminist message? Consider this: The engine that breaks down in the beginning of the book is female. She had been trying to take an assortment of toys and food to the good little boys and girls on the other side of the mountain. When she cannot go any farther, the dolls and toys flag down other engines and ask for a ride. A shiny new passenger engine (male), a powerful freight engine (male), and a rusty old engine (male) all refuse to help. “I am a very important engine indeed,” the freight engine says. “I won’t pull the likes of you!” It turns out that the only other engine who deigns to worry compassionately about the children on the other side of the mountain is a very little blue engine, who is — you guessed it — female. Go girl power!

  • “The Story of Ferdinand” (1936)

    Image: Cover of "The Story of Ferdinand"
    Viking Juvenile

    “The Story of Ferdinand” casts a strong and mighty bull as the ultimate pacifist. Who knew Ferdinand’s utter disinterest in fighting could be so wildly unpopular? Noting how big and brawny Ferdinand is, influential power brokers haul him all the way from Spain’s peaceful countryside to the bustling city of Madrid. They expect him to battle ferociously in Madrid’s famed bull fight. But when he gets there, sweet-natured Ferdinand sits down in the middle of the ring so he can smell all the flowers being worn by the many lovely ladies in attendance. Of course, his flower-fueled, peaceable stance stuns and angers everyone around him — but it saves his life and the lives of untold numbers of banderilleros, picadores, horses, and, of course, the matador himself. Ole!

  • “The Lorax” (1971)

    Image: Cover of "The Lorax"
    Random House

    Pretty much any book you’ll pick up by Theodor Seuss Geisel — a.k.a. Dr. Seuss — is bound to be at least somewhat rabble-rousing. In fact, Dr. Seuss once said, “I’m subversive as hell! I’ve always had a mistrust of adults.” While he tried to avoid sledgehammer-style morals in his books — on the grounds that “kids can see a moral coming a mile off” — he tackled serious issues and left no question about his feelings on corporate greed, materialism, the environment, equality and authoritarianism. In “The Lorax,” Dr. Seuss lambasts the greed and short-sightedness of the Once-ler, who chopped down every single Truffula tree he could find and polluted the air and water in order to keep on “biggering and biggering and biggering and biggering” his business. In the end, even the Once-ler comes to his senses, telling a little boy, “Unless someone like you cares a whole awful lot, nothing is going to get better. It’s not.”

  • “Yertle the Turtle” (1950)

    Image: Cover of "Yertle the Turtle"
    Random House

    Speaking of subversive Dr. Seuss books, “Yertle the Turtle” is practically a call to arms. Some turtles in a nice little pond on the far-away Island of Sala-ma-Sond were happy and content — until their self-appointed king Yertle became overcome by delusions of grandeur. The power-hungry turtle said, “I’m ruler of all that I see. But I don’t see enough. That’s the trouble with me.” So, he kept ordering turtles to pile up in a stack so he could perch atop them and enjoy his heady new view. He started with a nine-turtle throne, then progressed to a 200-turtle throne, then made a move to stack up 5,607 turtles — and that’s when Mack, a plain little turtle at the very bottom of the stack, burped. The turtle stack shook and toppled, causing Yertle to crash, humiliated, into the mud of the little pond. The book’s conclusion? “... all the turtles are free as turtles and, maybe, all creatures should be.”

  • “Madeline” (1939)

    Image: Cover of "Madeline's Rescue"
    Puffin

    Madeline, the smallest of 12 girls who live in a boarding school in Paris, is tough. She’s not afraid of mice or the growling tiger at the zoo — and she also isn’t afraid to stand up to authority figures. This becomes especially apparent in “Madeline’s Rescue,” one of the later books in the “Madeline” series. In that book, fearless Madeline falls into the river Seine after monkey-ing around on a bridge. A dog saves her life, then comes home to live with the girls at the school. Happiness prevails for about six months — until trustees visit the school to conduct an annual inspection. The horrified trustees cite an arbitrary rule about dogs not being allowed in school — and then the president of the board of trustees, Lord Cucuface, heartlessly sends the life-saving dog Genevieve away. Madeline cries, “Lord Cucuface, beware! Miss Genevieve, noblest dog in France, you shall have your VEN-GE-ANCE!” The moment the trustees leave, all 12 girls and their headmistress take to the streets of Paris to search for their furry family member. When Genevieve is found, they allow her — and all 12 of her newborn puppies — to stay with them, regardless of the rules.

  • “Curious George” (1941)

    Image: Cover of "The Original Curious George"
    HMH Books

    For nearly 70 years now, a mischievous little monkey named George has been teaching us that curiosity is a good thing, not a bad thing. Of course, George’s insatiable curiosity tends to get him into trouble. In the original “Curious George” book — published in 1941 and written by a German Jew who escaped the Nazis with his monkey watercolors strapped to his bicycle — the story begins with George becoming overwhelmingly curious about a yellow hat he spots on the ground in his African jungle home. He tries the hat on, obscures his vision and — blam! — gets thrown into a sack and shipped off to a zoo in a faraway city. “George was sad, but he was still a little curious,” the classic book notes. As the story unfolds, curiosity prompts George to fall overboard during his trans-Atlantic journey, set off a false alarm with the fire department in his new city, get thrown into prison, escape from prison and cause a terrible traffic jam — and readers can’t help but cheer him on every step of the way.

  • “Click, Clack, Moo: Cows That Type” (2000)

    Image: Cover of "Click, Clack, Moo: Cows That Type"
    Atheneum

    Thankfully for kids’ brains everywhere, the longstanding subversive tradition in children’s literature has continued to thrive in modern times. Here’s just one noteworthy (and hilarious) example: “Click, Clack, Moo: Cows That Type.” In this book, Farmer Brown’s cows have figured out how to type — and they’ve also figured out how to stick up for themselves. They begin leaving the grumpy farmer notes, starting with this one: “Dear Farmer Brown, The barn is very cold at night. We’d like some electric blankets. Sincerely, The Cows.” When he refuses, the cows go on strike and refuse to produce milk. The hens also want electric blankets, and when the farmer stalls, they join the strike and stop laying eggs. The standoff continues, with Duck (a neutral party) delivering messages back and forth between the barn and Farmer Brown’s house. Can you guess whether or not this story ends with toasty warm cows and hens?

    Plenty of other modern-day books for very young kids highlight the antics of bright, independent children and animals. To name just a few memorable characters: Jack, the Little Red Hen and others in “The Stinky Cheese Man and Other Fairly Stupid Tales” (1992); the gorilla and other zoo animals in “Good Night, Gorilla” (1994); Olivia in the “Olivia” series of books (first published in 2000); the little boy (and the cows) in “Cows Can’t Fly” (2000); the pigeon in “Don’t Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus!” (2003) and other pigeon books; the big sister in “How to Be a Baby ... by Me, the Big Sister” (2007); and the big sister in “17 Things I’m Not Allowed to Do Anymore” (2007). Do you have your own favorite books in this vein — either modern-day works or classics?If so, share them here!

Discuss:

Discussion comments

,

Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments

More on TODAY.com

  1. 20th Cenrtry Fox via Everett Col

    Should you see ‘Gone Girl’? From Affleck to Fincher, 4 reasons to buy a ticket

    9/30/2014 5:37:22 PM +00:00 2014-09-30T17:37:22
  1. J. Scott Applewhite / AP

    White House breach was ‘unacceptable,' Secret Service director testifies

    9/30/2014 6:37:10 PM +00:00 2014-09-30T18:37:10
  1. Detroit Lions via Twitter

    Fumble! NFL player injured while potty-training his puppy

    9/30/2014 4:23:14 PM +00:00 2014-09-30T16:23:14
  1. Boxwood Clippings, Kirsten Kraso

    6 ways to transition your home decor for fall

    9/30/2014 4:00:55 PM +00:00 2014-09-30T16:00:55