1. Headline
  1. Headline
By
updated 11/9/2011 3:10:53 PM ET 2011-11-09T20:10:53

Three years after Karen Kraushaar settled her sexual harassment complaint against Herman Cain and quit the trade association where they worked, she filed another complaint at her new job. She argued that supervisors there unfairly denied her request to work from home after a car accident and accused one of them of circulating a sexually oriented email, The Associated Press has learned.

  1. Stories from
    1. Why 5 Seconds of Summer Was So Scared of One Direction
    2. Very Pregnant Scarlett Johansson Debuts Very Short, Very Blonde New Haircut
    3. Was Missing New Hampshire Teen Abigail Hernandez Held in a Shipping Container for 9 Months?
    4. Nick Viall Asks Bachelorette Andi Dorfman to Remember Their 'Passion' in Letter
    5. This Cocktail Has 71 Ingredients - And They're All Packed Into One Glass

Kraushaar, 55, says she later dropped the complaint that she filed while working as a spokeswoman at the Immigration and Naturalization Service in late 2002 or early 2003 and left the agency to take a job at the Treasury Department. She says she considered the immigration service complaint "relatively minor."

But three former supervisors say the allegations, which did not include a sexual harassment claim, were investigated and treated seriously. Two former supervisors say she initially demanded a settlement of thousands of dollars, a promotion on the federal pay scale, reinstated leave time and a one-year fellowship to Harvard's Kennedy School of Government. The promotion itself would have increased her annual salary between $12,000 and $16,000, according to salary tables in 2002 from the U.S. Office of Personnel Management.

Details of the second complaint come as Kraushaar says she will provide specifics about the allegations she made against Cain, the GOP businessman now running for president who led the National Restaurant Association when she worked there. She is reaching out to three other Cain accusers, suggesting they can schedule a joint news conference to rebut Cain's insistence that he has never sexually harassed anyone.

First Read: Cain at center stage

Cain's campaign said news of Kraushaar's complaint at the immigration service and details about another accuser's financial problems were "interesting revelations."

"We hope that the court of public opinion will take this into consideration as they, the women, continue to try to keep this story alive," spokesman J.D. Gordon said in a statement Wednesday.

When Kraushaar filed her immigration service complaint against supervisors in late 2002 or early 2003, she turned to Joel Bennett, the same Washington lawyer who handled her earlier sexual harassment complaint against Cain.

"The concern was that there may have been discrimination on the job and that I was being treated unfairly," Kraushaar said.

Kraushaar said she did not remember details about the complaint and did not remember asking for a payment, a promotion or a fellowship. Bennett declined to discuss the case with the AP, saying he considered it confidential.

Kraushaar now works as a spokeswoman in the office of the Treasury Department's inspector general for tax administration.

Video: 2nd Cain harassment accuser goes public (on this page)

Her complaint at the immigration service was based on supervisors denying her request to work fulltime from home after a serious car accident in 2002, three former supervisors said. Two of them said Kraushaar also had been denied previous requests to work from home before the car accident.

The complaint also cited as objectionable an email that a manager had circulated comparing computers to men and women, a former supervisor said. The complaint contended that the email, based on humor widely circulated on the Internet, was sexually explicit, according to the supervisor, who did not have a copy of the email. The joke circulated online lists reasons men and women are like computers, including that men are because "in order to get their attention, you have to turn them on." Women are like computers, it says, because "even your smallest mistakes are stored in long-term memory for later retrieval."

Kraushaar told the AP that she remembered the complaint focusing on supervisors denying her the opportunity to work from home after her car accident. She said other employees were allowed to work from home.

Kraushaar, who is married and lives in suburban Maryland, was one of two women who formally settled harassment complaints against Cain in exchange for severance payments in the late 1990s when they worked at the restaurant association. Bennett has said Kraushaar settled her claim during the summer of 1999, shortly after Cain left the organization. Neither Kraushaar nor Bennett has described exactly what Cain was accused of saying or doing when she worked there. The New York Times has reported that Kraushaar received $45,000 in the settlement with the restaurant association.

Kraushaar agreed to discuss some aspects of the complaint at the immigration service if the AP agreed to protect her privacy, as it did in previous accounts of her complaint against Cain. She subsequently waived her privacy by confirming for news organizations her identity as one of two women who settled complaints against Cain, so the AP no longer is shielding her identity.

What last night's elections told us

Cain said allegations of sexual harassment by Kraushaar — whom Cain identified by name in a televised news conference Tuesday — were determined to be "baseless" at the restaurant association. But he did not explain who made this determination, and Kraushaar has disputed this. Cain said that after negotiations between Bennett and the association's outside counsel she received money under an employment agreement, which Cain said was different from a legal settlement.

"When she made her accusations, they were found to be baseless and she could not find anyone to corroborate her story," Cain said.

Cain said he remembered gesturing to Kraushaar and noting that she was the same height as his wife, about chin-high to him. The Georgia businessman said Kraushaar did not react noticeably, but he said the restaurant association lawyer later told him that was the most serious claim that Kraushaar had made against him, "the one she was most upset about."

"Other things that might have been in the accusations, I'm not aware of, I don't remember," Cain said.

Bennett told reporters Wednesday that Kraushaar suffered multiple incidents of harassment and would not have filed a claim based only on a comment about height.

"My client is an intelligent, well-educated woman. She would never file a sexual harassment complaint about a comment like that," he said.

Sharon Bialek, a Chicago woman who once worked for the restaurant association's education foundation, accused Cain this week of groping her and attempting to force himself on her inside a parked car after they had dinner in 1997. Another woman told the AP that Cain made unwanted sexual advances to her while she worked for the association, and a pollster said he witnessed Cain sexually harass another woman after an association dinner.

Video: Grading Cain’s response to harass claims (on this page)

The complaint at the immigration service was "nobody's business," Kraushaar said, because it was irrelevant to her sexual harassment settlement with Cain years earlier. "What you're looking for here is evidence of an employee who is out to get people," she said. "That's completely untrue."

Kraushaar, who started her career in Washington as a reporter, was praised for her work in 2000 when she traveled to Miami to help immigration officials during the coverage of the Elian Gonzalez case when federal agents seized the boy from relatives to return him to his father in Cuba.

"Ms. Kraushaar's assistance was invaluable and her performance extraordinary," wrote Robert A. Wallis, the immigration service district director in Miami. Kraushaar provided seven such letters of recommendation to show that her performance was commendable while working at the Consumer Product Safety Commission, the restaurant association and the immigration service.

Copyright 2011 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Video: Grading Cain’s response to harass claims

  1. Closed captioning of: Grading Cain’s response to harass claims

    >> much. star jones is a former prosecutor and veteran legal commentator and david gregory , moderator of "meet the press." good morning to you both.

    >> good morning.

    >> good morning, ann.

    >> is herman cain fighting fundamental questions about his credibility as much as he's fighting allegations of sexual misconduct ?

    >> we face the prospect of a number of accusers coming together at once to lay out a body of evidence, what she described to "the new york times" against herman cain and he was unequivocal, in the case of miss bialek, said declaratively i've never acted inappropriately at all. there are things verifiable. business bialek said he upgraded her room to a suite, presumably there's a receipt to prove whether she's telling the truth or is he. the settlement agreement with the national restaurant association more details about what allegedly occurred. then you're right, credibility becomes a question.

    >> he's not stepping down, continuing to suck the air out of the narrative. does the party now wish he would just go away?

    >> well there is no grand wizard in the party right now who can really force the issue. i've talked to cain's advisers in iowa, they think their support is still strong, it's not falling. there may be cracks in the foundation according to pollsters i'm talking to, that his numbers may be starting to shift but right now core support remains there. they think that holding a press conference like he did will ultimately give some people peace of mind , but the big if here, if nothing else comes up.

    >> star, about this report overnight from the ap, one of the women who has come out, karen kraushar, she subsequently in another job of circulating a sexually charged e-mail. could protesting too much affect her credibility in.

    >> i think what it really speaks to is how this particular employee deals with workplace conflict , if you will. she in a new job is particularly sensitive to certain behaviors, and her way of dealing with the conflict is to file a complaint. that's not necessarily negative. it may just be someone who will not take stuff from somebody else.

    >> what do you make of his answer to the lie detector test question?

    >> you know, i was surprised but then i realized we're not in a court of law , because of course, a lie detector test would not be valid in a court of law . we're in the court of public opinion and there's nothing more powerful than waving around i passed a lie detector test , but it only matters if the lie detector test is given under certain circumstances by the right person asking the right questions.

    >> david, you know politics like nobody else . if these four women come together and have a joint news conference to accuse herman cain of sexual misconduct , can herman cain 's presidential candidacy survive?

    >> there's no question that you're talking about a test of credibility, both the accusers would be evaluated in that way and herman cain will continue to be evaluated. sexual harassment is a very difficult thing to prove. there's no suit that's being filed here right now so a lot of this as star says will be in the court of public opinion . there's a debate tonight in michigan. mitt romney has said these are serious allegations that have to be addressed. some of the other candidates who want to play the anti-romney role are keeping their hands off of herman cain . his supporters will reluctantly come to the conclusion, true or not this is such a distraction ultimately herman cain can't win. they hope to inherity that support if that comes to pass.

    >> thank you for joining us, david gregory and star jones .

Discuss:

Discussion comments

,

Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments

More on TODAY.com

  1. Bravo / Steve Jennings/Bravo

    Extreme parenting: Who are we to judge?

    7/29/2014 6:52:01 PM +00:00 2014-07-29T18:52:01
  1. Obama joins EU to impose new sanctions on Russia

    President Obama announced on Tuesday that not only would the U.S. be imposing additional sanctions on Russia’s defense, energy and financial sectors, but that the European Union would also be imposing new sanctions on the country. 

    7/29/2014 7:55:14 PM +00:00 2014-07-29T19:55:14
  1. Courtesy of Steve Tillotson

    6-year-old 'Rapunzel' chops off her hair for kids with cancer

    7/29/2014 6:54:06 PM +00:00 2014-07-29T18:54:06
  1. Minnesota man is first American to die in Ebola outbreak

    The Ebola outbreak that has killed hundreds of people in west Africa has claimed its first American; Patrick Sawyer, 40, a consultant for the Liberian government.

    7/29/2014 3:36:41 PM +00:00 2014-07-29T15:36:41
  2. American aid worker who contracted Ebola doing ‘as well as could be expected’