1. Headline
  1. Headline
IMAGE: World Trade Center
Paramount Pictures
Nicolas Cage plays a police officer who finds himself trapped under the collapsed towers in 2006's "World Trade Center," one of the few Hollywood films about the attacks to attract big stars and big audiences.
By
TODAY contributor
updated 9/7/2011 2:34:26 PM ET 2011-09-07T18:34:26

After the 9/11 attacks, it at first seemed as if the film industry would respond in a major way, telling many stories related to that day.

In fact, exactly one year later, in the fall of 2002, a collaborative effort from 11 international filmmakers quietly arrived in arthouse cinemas in a few American cities. The movie was called, simply, “11. 09. 01 — September 11” and was a mix of short films, all of which addressed either directly or obliquely the events of that day. Some were bluntly painful, such as “Babel” director Alejandro González Iñarritu’s news footage depicting falling bodies from the Twin Towers. Others, such as Iranian filmmaker Samira Makhmalbaf’s brief visit with elementary-school-aged children discussing the nature of divine punishment (“God hasn’t got airplanes,” says one little girl. “God builds humans.”) were quietly and sadly wise.

Story: In 9/11 movies, it's little moments that touch us

But after that small offering, it felt like Hollywood might be taking a hands-off policy. Two 2006 projects attracted reasonably large audiences: “World Trade Center,” with its heartfelt, real-life story of two police officers trapped under the collapsed towers, and “United 93,” a harrowing real-time account of the events that may have taken place aboard the flight that crashed in a Pennsylvania field. “United 93” earned two Academy Award nominations for direction and editing. Two other wide releases, the Adam Sandler drama “Reign Over Me” and Robert Pattinson's “Remember Me,” failed to connect with audiences.

  1. More Entertainment stories
    1. Autistic ballerina dances her way into hearts

      In a popular YouTube video, the beaming little ballerina dances an entire four-minute routine seemingly perfectly, matchin...

    2. Every on-screen drink in 'Mad Men' in 5 minutes
    3. See the 'Dancing' stars' most memorable moves
    4. Emmy's biggest snubs? Cranston, Hamm, more
    5. 'Toy Story' toys burn up in prank on mom
Story: See the Twin Towers rise again in movie clips

Independent filmmaker Brian Sloan can count himself among the handful of writer-directors to explicitly address the events of 9/11. His movie, the 2005 indie “WTC View,” about a New Yorker trying to rent out a room in his Twin Towers-adjacent apartment, is fictional but began with a true story. The New York-based director, who lives a short distance from what is now Ground Zero, placed an ad for a roommate on Sept. 10, 2001. His experiences talking to people who visited the apartment after the attacks, all of whom had stories to tell, eventually became a play and then a film. And the immediate nature of his experience felt like it needed to be told sooner rather than later.

Story: Twin towers erased from some films after 9/11

“What inspired me,” said Sloan, “was realizing that I was living in a remarkable period in history and I felt compelled to document that. There was the big story, of course. But there was also this story of how people in the city were living with this immense thing that happened and how they dealt with keeping their lives together afterward.”

Another early entry, Spike Lee’s “25th Hour,” wasn't about the attacks, but featured memorable related images. The drama opens with the image of the twin floodlights that recreated the towers and later features Ground Zero excavation work. Aaron Hillis, curator of Brooklyn’s reRun Gastropub Theater and journalist for The Village Voice, wasn't at first sure the images worked. “The film's evocation seemed timely but unjustifiably shoehorned for an adaptation of a novel published months before the towers fell," Hillis said. "And yet, over the years, those melancholic images have haunted me more than any other piece of post-9/11 cinema.”

Story: 10 years later, TV still has trouble capturing 9/11

Manohla Dargis, co-chief film critic for The New York Times, acknowledges that while there have been a limited number of mainstream Hollywood films that have dealt directly with the subject, it’s actually the aftermath of 9/11 that has been ever-present at the movies.

“You could look at the ‘Harry Potter’ series through the veil of 9/11,” Dargis explained. “It became very difficult not to, with the idea of Lord Voldemort as the evildoer of all evildoers who was going to try to take down [the world]. And the apocalyptic ending reaffirmed that for me.”

The images and memories of that day are still raw. Ten years isn’t a very long time. So when a mainstream multiplex-aimed film decides to take on the big moment and try to make sense of it, the results can wind up weighing too much. Audiences out on Saturday night at the movies are often in the mood to leave the ugly real world behind for vicarious thrills, not in-your-face catharsis. So indirect becomes the new direct.

  1. Related 9/11 content
    1. Iconic figures: Where are they now?
    2. Last woman rescued: ‘I can’t believe I’m here’
    3. Preserving stories, voices of 9/11 forever
    4. How 9/11 changed Pakistan
    5. Firefighter: Pride in his heart, dust in his lungs
    6. American Muslims come of age in post-9/11 era
    7. Inside the ‘bigger, better' World Trade Center 
    8. Remains of the day: Relatives honor dead with relics
    9. Twins born days after 9/11 reflect on dad's loss
    10. What the world looked like on Sept. 10, 2001
    11. How 9/11 changed msnbc.com readers' lives
    12. 9/11 aftermath: Covering the invasion of Afghanistan
    13. Muslim travelers still saddled with 9/11 baggage
    14. Photographers revist 9/11: ‘Horrific’

Not helping are failed movies such as “Remember Me” (which Dargis describes with words like “appalling” and “exploitation”) which uses 9/11 as a surprise action twist, in Sloan’s words, “a simple plot device.” The filmmaker’s not much of a “World Trade Center” fan himself, wondering aloud how it “add[ed] much to anyone’s understanding of that moment.”

War documentaries such as Michael Moore’s “Fahrenheit 9/11” and Charles Ferguson’s “No End In Sight” aggressively tackled United States foreign policy after the attacks. But it was a fictional war movie that never once mentioned the reasons for the current U.S. military involvement in the Middle East, “The Hurt Locker,” that won a best picture Oscar.

Video: TODAY remembers the sights and sounds of 9/11 (on this page)

Dargis said that "Hurt Locker" is “absolutely a 9/11 movie ... it’s indisputable. And I think that’s part of why it won the Oscar that year. It was a way of dealing with it at somewhat of a remove.”

And coming just in time for Christmas is “Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close,” starring Tom Hanks and Sandra Bullock. Based on the Jonathan Safran Foer book, the film is a domestic drama about a young boy who loses his father in the tower attacks.

That film will bring the tally of movies that directly address the attacks to little more than a handful. But considering the 70-year history of World War II movies, we’re not close to nearing the end of Hollywood’s attempts to grasp That Moment and its ongoing shockwaves.

“We can’t really deal with the central subject so we’re gnawing at the margins,” said Dargis. “This is not done. It’s not going to be done for a long time.”

Dave White is a critic for movies.com.

© 2013 NBCNews.com  Reprints

Video: TODAY remembers the sights and sounds of 9/11

Photos: September movies

loading photos...
  1. 'Apollo 18'

    Stars: Lloyd Owen, Warren Christie

    Director: Gonzalo López-Gallego

    Scheduled release date: Sept. 2

    Think there wasn't an "Apollo 18" lunar mission? Think again. Decades-old found footage from the supposed secret expedition reveals the reason the U.S. has never returned to the moon. Hint: Didja see "Alien"? (The Weinstein Company) Back to slideshow navigation
  2. 'The Debt'

    Stars: Helen Mirren, Sam Worthington and Tom Wilkinson

    Director: John Madden

    Scheduled release date: Sept. 2

    "The Debt" begins in 1997, as shocking news reaches retired Mossad secret agents Rachel (Mirren) and Stefan (Wilkinson) about their former colleague David. The group supposedly tracked down a Nazi war criminal in 1966 -- or did they? (Miramax Films) Back to slideshow navigation
  3. 'Shark Night 3D'

    Stars: Sara Paxton, Dustin Milligan and Alyssa Diaz

    Director: David R. Ellis

    Scheduled release date: Sept. 2

    The title, "Sharl Night 3D," says it all. But sharks in a freshwater lake? Hollywood will do anything to get the blood, bikinis and severed limbs flying in 3-D. (Relativity Media) Back to slideshow navigation
  4. 'A Good Old Fashioned Orgy'

    Stars: Jason Sudeikis, Leslie Bibb and Tyler Labine

    Directors: Alex Gregory, Peter Huyck

    Scheduled release date: Sept. 2

    In "A Good Old Fashioned Orgy," Jason Sudeikis and pals have partied for years at his dad's beach house. But when dad (Don Johnson) announces he's selling the place, his son decides it's time for the ultimate party. (Samuel Goldwyn Films) Back to slideshow navigation
  5. 'Contagion'

    Stars: Matt Damon, Kate Winslet and Jude Law

    Director: Steven Soderbergh

    Scheduled release date: Sept. 9

    Have your face masks ready -- you'll want one after seeing "Contagion." The action thriller follows people trying to survive a lethal virus. Big stars abound, and it sure looks like from promos that things don't go well for Gwyneth Paltrow. (Warner Bros) Back to slideshow navigation
  6. 'Bucky Larson: Born to Be a Star'

    Stars: Nick Swardson, Don Johnson and Christina Ricci

    Director: Tom Brady

    Scheduled release date: Sept. 9

    "Bucky Larson" is a kid from the Midwest who moves out to Hollywood in order to follow in his parents footsteps -- which for him, means becoming a porn star. (Columbia Pictures) Back to slideshow navigation
  7. 'Warrior'

    Stars: Tom Hardy, Nick Nolte and Joel Edgerton

    Director: Gavin O'Connor

    Scheduled release date: Sept. 9

    In "Warrior," two estranged brothers face the fight of a lifetime. Nick Nolte plays their alcoholic dad, who trains one to eventually land in the ring against the other in a mixed martial-arts tournament. (Chuck Zlotnick) Back to slideshow navigation
  8. 'Straw Dogs'

    Stars: James Marsden, Kate Bosworth and Alexander Skarsgard

    Director: Rod Lurie

    Scheduled release date: Sept. 16

    "Straw Dogs" is a remake of the 1971 Dustin Hoffman thriller, infamous for its controversial rape scene. L.A. screenwriter David Sumner relocates with his wife to her hometown in the deep South. There, while tensions build between them, a brewing conflict with locals becomes a threat to them both. (Screen Gems) Back to slideshow navigation
  9. 'I Don't Know How She Does It'

    Stars: Sarah Jessica Parker, Pierce Brosnan and Kelsey Grammer

    Director: Douglas McGrath

    Scheduled release date: Sept. 16

    "I Don't Know How She Does It" is a comedy centered on the life of Kate Reddy (Parker), a finance executive who is the breadwinner for her husband and two kids. Based on the best-selling novel. (The Weinstein Company) Back to slideshow navigation
  10. 'Drive'

    Stars: Ryan Gosling, Carey Mulligan and Bryan Cranston

    Director: Nicolas Winding Refn

    Scheduled release date: Sept. 16

    In "Drive," Gosling plays a Hollywood stunt performer who moonlights as a wheelman. After a heist goes wrong, he discovers that a contract has been put on his life. (Richard Foreman Jr Smpsp / FilmDistrict) Back to slideshow navigation
  11. 'Moneyball'

    Stars: Brad Pitt, Philip Seymour Hoffman, Robin Wright and Jonah Hill

    Director: Bennett Miller

    Scheduled release date: Sept. 23

    Brad Pitt stars as Oakland A's manager Billy Beane in "Moneyball," based on Michael Lewis' book. The focus is on Beane's attempt to create a competitive team despite Oakland's unfavorable financial situation. (Columbia Pictures) Back to slideshow navigation
  12. 'Abduction'

    Stars: Taylor Lautner, Lily Collins and Alfred Molina

    Director: John Singleton

    Scheduled release date: Sept. 23

    In "Abduction," Taylor Lautner plays a young man who sets out to uncover the truth about his life after finding his baby photo on a missing persons website. (Lionsgate) Back to slideshow navigation
  13. 'Dolphin Tale'

    Stars: Morgan Freeman, Ashley Judd and Harry Connick Jr.

    Director: Charles Martin Smith

    Scheduled release date: Sept. 23

    IThe 3-D film "Dolphin Tale" is is inspired by the true story of a bottlenose dolphin named Winter who lost her tail in a crab trap. Her human friends work frantically to create a prosthetic so she can still swim. (Warner Bros.) Back to slideshow navigation
  14. 'Dream House'

    Stars: Daniel Craig, Rachel Weisz and Naomi Watts

    Director: Jim Sheridan

    Scheduled release date: Sept. 30

    The beautiful home in "Dream House" is more of a nightmare. Soon after moving in, a family learns that a mother and her children were brutally murdered there. (Universal Pictures) Back to slideshow navigation
  15. '50/50'

    Stars: Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Seth Rogen and Anna Kendrick

    Director: Jonathan Levine

    Scheduled release date: Sept. 30

    "50/50" is a comedic account of a 27-year-old man's cancer diagnosis, and his subsequent struggle to beat the disease. (Summit Entertainment) Back to slideshow navigation
  16. 'Killer Elite'

    Stars: Jason Statham, Clive Owen and Robert De Niro

    Director: Gary McKendry

    Scheduled release date: Sept. 30

    Action film "Killer Elite" focuses on a retired member of Britain's Elite Special Air Service (Jason Statham) who is forced into action when his mentor (Robert De Niro) is taken hostage. His mission: kill three assassins dispatched by their cunning leader (Clive Owen). (Open Road Films) Back to slideshow navigation
  17. 'What's Your Number?'

    Stars: Anna Faris, Chris Pratt and Chris Evans

    Director: Mark Mylod

    Scheduled release date: Sept. 30

    "What's Your Number?" refers to the number of men a woman has slept with. Anna Faris plays Ally, a woman whose number is 20, as she looks back at those men wondering if any of them are her true love. (20th Century Fox) Back to slideshow navigation
  1. Editor's note:
    This image contains graphic content that some viewers may find disturbing.

    Click to view the image, or use the buttons above to navigate away.

  2. Editor's note:
    This image contains graphic content that some viewers may find disturbing.

    Click to view the image, or use the buttons above to navigate away.

  3. Editor's note:
    This image contains graphic content that some viewers may find disturbing.

    Click to view the image, or use the buttons above to navigate away.

  4. Editor's note:
    This image contains graphic content that some viewers may find disturbing.

    Click to view the image, or use the buttons above to navigate away.