1. Headline
  1. Headline

Video: She learned her longtime fiance was gay

  1. Closed captioning of: She learned her longtime fiance was gay

    >>> imagine how you would feel if the love of your life turned out to be gay. in a moment we'll talk to one woman who had that happen to her. first, natalie morales has more.

    >> good morning. experts say it is actually happening more and more often, leaving many women confused.

    >> i'm gay.

    >> reporter: from the big screen --

    >> i had what i guess you would call desires. i find that i'm attracted to men.

    >> reporter: to politics.

    >> i am a gay american. shamefully, i engaged in adult consensual affair with another man.

    >> reporter: a woman finding out the man she's in love with is gay is something we've seen played out before. it happened to kiri blakely, who thought she'd found the man she'd spend forever with.

    >> we enjoyed spending time together. everybody looked at us as the perfect couple.

    >> reporter: after ten years, kiri's faienciance said, we need to talk.

    >> i thought he was going to say i didn't clean out the cat litter box or something. he said, i'm confused about my sexuality. he said i'm having fantasies about men. it was the last thing i expected to hear.

    >> it's extremely difficult for a woman to reconcile this and come to terms with it. there aren't any striking red flags apart from catching him in the act.

    >> reporter: experts say at any given time, there are as many as 2 million mixed-orientation marriages. and a new cheating study from the university of texas shows only 22% of women say they could forgive their male partner's betrayal with another man. but if a woman cheats with another woman, over 50% of men say they would continue the relationship.

    >> women who cheat with other women, it's usually rooted more in an emotional relationship whereas men who cheat with men, it's almost purely based on something physical and sexual.

    >> reporter: kiri says having her fiance tell her he was gay was one thing, but finding out he cheated with another man was another.

    >> him having an affair hurt more than him deciding he was gay. emotionally, i still struggle with the idea that someone can lie to you and to themselves on a daily basis for so long.

    >> some mixed-orientation couples do stay together, but one study estimates that only 7% who try make it long-term. meredith?

    >> thank you, natalie. kiri blakely writes about her experience in "can't think straight." gail saltz is also here with us. you refer to your fiance as aaron. that's not his real name . we also offered him the opportunity to come on the show, give his side of the story. he declined. putting that out there. at the time of your relationship, you say you never had any idea that aaron was gay, but when you look back now in hindsight, can you see things that you didn't pick up then?

    >> there's a stereotype of how a gay man should look, act, and sound. and he fit none of that. none of that at all. so in that way, no.

    >> okay.

    >> he doesn't nit stereotype. the only thing is our sex life did dwindle over the course of the decade that we were together. it slowed down. but i saw that as a long-term relationship. i thought that was a normal thing that happens. i had other friends who were going through the same situation. so that was really the only clue, if you want to even call that a clue.

    >> yeah. gail , how often does this happen? apparently quite a bit. why would someone want to live a lie for that long?

    >> it often starts because they're lying to themselves. still today unfortunately, it's hard for people to come out. it's potentially a harder lifestyle. they feel people's disapproval. and it's internalized. they don't want to be gay. even though that's really what's going on. because there's really sort of a continuum, if you will, of sexuality, and you can have, you know, great attraction to a member of the same sex mostly but still somewhat be attracted to, you know, the opposite sex . it's not so black-and-white. it's not so defined. you can say to yourself, well, maybe this isn't so. i don't want it to be so, so i'm going to say it's not. people live secret lives of all kinds. this is one of them that usually leads to real depression, to betrayal, and a lot of hurt.

    >> do you think that you would have felt differently had he had an affair with a woman as opposed to a man?

    >> i tell everyone it's equal amount of devastation, but in different ways. so with a man or men, you don't get competitive like, oh, what does she have that i don't. you know what a man has that you don't. but in another way, i almost felt like i couldn't get as angry because i felt like i had to in some way support his choice or his decision even though he'd been cheating on me. so you almost are not able to be as angry as you would be if it was a woman. so that was kind of strange.

    >> maybe -- go ahead.

    >> i think women often in this situation feel very humiliated, you know? it's like why -- why did that happen? what does this mean about me? why did he pick me? and i think that leaves you very angry. you know, to be really shamed, leaves you very, very angry. and then what do you do with it? you can't fight for the guy to come back to you. so how do you, you know, how do you deal with that?

    >> you dealt with it by drinking a lot for a while?

    >> i sort of self-destructed for a while.

    >> sleeping with a lot of guys you write in your book.

    >> it depends on your definition of a lot. but, yeah, i went a little crazy because i think i had a psychotic break with reality. when the reality that you know for so long turns out to be not the reality that you thought, it's almost like you -- you just -- i just had a psychotic break . i didn't know how to be alone anymore. so for me to sit in my apartment for a couple of hours and watch tv was in possible. i would have to go out to a bar, you know? and just be around people and drink and -- yeah.

    >> and this isn't only about sexuality. this was about fidelity as well.

    >> correct.

    >> that's the issue. when he told his friends, a lot of people said, well, thank goodness you could come out. they weren't even angry that he cheated.

    >> this is not living a life of integrity. it's not being true to yourself. it's not being true to a commitment that you made. that's really the bigger issue. frankly, had he come to you -- it would have been painful, but had he said, i'm gay, we're not going to be able to stay together, i have to leave and then gotten into a relationship, it would have had a very different feeling. the betrayal is a big part of the problem.

    >> thank you for sharing your story.

    >> thanks for having me.

    >> gail , thanks. the book is called "can't think straight." we'll

By
TODAY books
updated 2/2/2011 4:46:58 PM ET 2011-02-02T21:46:58

Warning: This book excerpt involves some sexually explicit situations and is not suitable for all readers.

“Can’t Think Straight” is a brutally honest, self-deprecating, emotionally wrenching and somehow still laugh-out-loud funny memoir of betrayal — and one woman’s year of relearning to make out on public pool tables and maybe even love — whatever that means — again. Here’s an excerpt:

Chapter Eleven

I fly to Palm Beach to visit my grandfather, Bernardo.

Born into a noble Portuguese family, former diplomat, man about Georgetown, multilingual author whose first book was published at age twenty-four, and once so handsome he was under contract with a Hollywood studio because he resembled a more masculine Tyrone Power, Bernardo’s now ninety years old and preoccupied with his coming death. This, according to him, is set to happen any day now, despite his being in perfectly fine health, his mind as sharp as twenty-five-year-old’s, able to dredge up incidents, places, and people from decades ago with finely pointed fidelity.

  1. More in books
    1. Harlan Coben returns with ‘Six Years’
    2. ‘I Would Die 4 U’: How Prince became an icon
    3. ‘Until I Say Good-Bye’: Living for love in the face of ALS
    4. Letters from the life of George H.W. Bush
    5. Mom turns sleeping baby into fairy-tale star

Here’s a guy who’d always gone his own way: he’d had three wives (all gorgeous enough that they’d modeled professionally) and couldn’t stay faithful to any of them. His first wife, my paternal grandmother, had been the recipient of one of his most audacious displays of womanizing: three days into their Catskills honeymoon, he’d snuck off to cheat on her with another newlywed.

Of course, he’s an old man now, his Don Juan days behind him. He’s lonely, tottering around his tiny Palm Beach apartment. It would have been nice if he’d had a wife to keep him company. But they probably would have driven each other nuts. Besides, we all die alone.

My grandfather had heard about the breakup but not the reason for it. When I get to the “He’s GAY!” part, he does the standard-issue “What?!” Then, unlike anyone else I’d told, he starts laughing. “I thought it would be something more dramatic.”

“More dramatic than that? You set the bar pretty high.”

“Why would he want to be with a big hairy man when he could have you?”

“Actually, it’s big hairy men he prefers. How’d you know?”

At dinner, I ask my grandfather if any of his marriages had been “open.”

Submitted by Adeola Saul  /  UGC
“With Roxie,” he says, naming his third wife. “She liked women. She’d bring them home for a threesome. She loved to go down on me while the woman went down on her.”

Yep, this from my ninety-year-old paterfamilias. We’d never limited our conversations to grandfather-approved topics like heartburn and baseball.

“Did you ever get insecure because she liked women so much?”

“To a certain extent.”

But despite having a wife who brought women home for him, the marriage still fell apart. I never quite knew what had happened, except that Roxie once mentioned how she’d filed for divorce after Bernardo disappeared for four days over Christmas. I guess even if you give a man total sexual freedom, you still expect a modicum of reliability.

My grandfather and I are walking back from dinner when Aaron calls. He’s been staying at the apartment to watch the cats and updates me on them, then tells me he cleaned the bathroom. “You didn’t have to do that,” I say.

“It was disgusting.”

I tell him how my grandfather doesn’t get him at all. “He’s revolted by men,” I say. “He doesn’t understand how anyone could prefer a man over a woman.”

Aaron chuckles, hesitantly. I’m twisting the knife a little, making him feel like less of a man

  1. More from TODAY.com
    1. 'Sopranos' star James Gandolfini dies at 51

      According to HBO, the actor was vacationing in Rome and died of a possible heart attack.

    2. Blake's favorite 'Voice' moment? Meeting Cher
    3. Guinea pig fans go extreme: $22,000 outfit, 'pignics'
    4. Miley Cyrus talks alcohol vs. marijuana dangers
    5. Say it ain't so! Cap'N Crunch not really a captain?

“Well, baby, so far we’ve broken up so you could spend more time drinking at Last Exit. Are you doing any real work on yourself?”

“I’ve been to a couple of gay bars.”

Ask a stupid question.

“In Chelsea?” I gulp.

  1. Stories from
    1. James Gandolfini Dies at Age 51
    2. Blake Shelton Says Danielle Bradbery Is The Voice's Most Important Winner
    3. Mark-Paul Gosselaar: Maybe I'll Name My Baby Breckin (Or Not)
    4. Paula Deen: I Used the N-Word, but Don't Condone Racism
    5. Meet the Ecstatic Schoolgirl Who Photographed Princes William & Harry

“There are gay bars in Brooklyn.”

Ask another stupid question.

“How’s that going for you?”

“Not too good. I can just about say hello.”

I can picture it: Aaron, paralyzed with shyness. He was never good at the pickup.

Over dinner, my grandfather had told me that a great passion requires great suffering on both sides. He’d only felt it twice in his life, on neither occasion with his wives. The first time was when he was twenty-two, with an older woman whom he’d followed to America (I have her to thank for being American). Then there was a woman named Christina. He considered her the great love of his life. The relationship was fraught with jealousy, raging dramas, blistering arguments, and phenomenal sex. One night at a party, after seeing Bernardo dance a little too amorously with another woman, Christina had extinguished her cigarette on his hand (he still had the faint scar) and then tried to burn down his apartment.

Yet even this supposed great passion couldn’t stop him from straying. Christina had once walked in on him having sex with her best friend. I’d asked him why he couldn’t keep it in his pants — not even for his soul mate.

“Because,” he said, “I always wondered if I was a good husband, a good father, whether I would get a good job. One thing I knew I could do well was to get women into bed.”

We all have our strengths, I suppose.

From "Can't Think Straight: A Memoir of Mixed-Up Love" by Kiri Blakeley. Copyright © 2011. Reprinted by permission of Citadel Press .

© 2012 MSNBC Interactive

Discuss:

Discussion comments

,

Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments

More on TODAY.com

None
  1. Barry Wetcher / AP file

    'Sopranos' star James Gandolfini dies at 51

    6/20/2013 2:05:37 AM +00:00 2013-06-20T02:05:37
None
  1. Google: 'We're not in cahoots with the NSA'

    Google’s chief legal officer tries to reassure customers that their gmail and Internet browsing history are safe from government prying.

    6/19/2013 6:49:04 PM +00:00 2013-06-19T18:49:04
None
  1. Guinea pig fans go extreme: $22,000 outfit, 'pignics'

    6/19/2013 9:56:44 PM +00:00 2013-06-19T21:56:44
None
  1. Tyler Golden / NBC

    Blake's favorite 'Voice' moment? Meeting Cher

    6/19/2013 10:39:17 PM +00:00 2013-06-19T22:39:17
None
  1. What Duchess Kate’s ‘maternity leave’ means

    Officially, the Duchess of Cambridge is off the grid, trying to spend the final weeks of her pregnancy out of a limelight. Unofficially, she has gone on leave, one that may stretch through the rest of the year – and possibly longer.

    6/19/2013 3:52:49 PM +00:00 2013-06-19T15:52:49
  2. Kate to give birth in same hospital as Princess Diana
  3. slideshow Duchess Kate’s maternity style
  4. Getty Images