1. Headline
  1. Headline

Video: ‘Disney’s A Christmas Carol’

By Film critic
msnbc.com contributor
updated 11/3/2009 5:24:20 PM ET 2009-11-03T22:24:20

Could someone please keep Jim Carrey and director Robert Zemeckis away from cherished holiday classics? We’ve already had to endure Carrey mugging it up as the Grinch while Zemeckis turned “The Polar Express” into a bloated and freaky-looking theme park attraction, and now these two have gone and put the stink on Charles Dickens’ beloved “A Christmas Carol.”

While Zemeckis’ brand of ooh-cool-it’s-3-D filmmaking added zest to “Beowulf,” here it just gets in the way. Remember how completely superfluous that runaway-train segment was in “Polar Express”? Multiply that by numerous flying-over-London and scary-carriage-on-the-rampage sequences this time around.

Carrey, at least, doesn’t go over the top; whatever hamminess he brings to the role is at least appropriate for portraying Ebenezer Scrooge, a character who starts the piece at one extreme of human behavior and ends it on another. In this version, the first scene shows us a Scrooge so skinflint that he removes the pennies from the eyes of his dead partner, Jacob Marley (Gary Oldman); “Tuppence is tuppence,” he mutters as the undertaker gapes in horror.

Thanks to the motion-capture technology Zemeckis apparently loves so — again, it worked in “Beowulf,” but here and in “Polar Express,” everyone just looks rubbery and creepy — the lead actors get to play multiple roles. Carrey acts opposite himself as all three Spirits of Christmas (the Ghost of Christmas Past’s accent wobbles between Scottish and Liverpudlian) while Oldman pops up again as a gnomish Bob Cratchit and a Tiny Tim that’ll make your skin crawl.

Bob Hoskins looks just right as kind old Mr. Fezziwig, but that may be more of a testament to the actor’s physiognomy than to the motion-capture process, which makes most of the film’s cast look like they just sauntered out of Madame Tussauds.

Zemeckis’ screenplay is a rather odd patchwork — at times, he’s exceedingly faithful to the original text, down to the part where Ignorance and Want huddle beneath the robes of the Ghost of Christmas Present. But surely Dickens never intended to have a tiny Scrooge running through drainpipes while being pursued by a demonic coach-and-six, no matter how much the chase pops out of the screen.

“A Christmas Carol” has resonated with readers for more than a century because it so brilliantly captures the themes of redemption, generosity, family love and community that the Yuletide, at its best, summons in all of us. It can even be argued that the story’s impact can be felt in subsequent holiday favorites like “It’s a Wonderful Life” and “Home Alone” — both are about characters who, like Scrooge, are given a Christmastime glimpse of an alternate reality that makes them reevaluate their lives.

All of which is to say that, if you’re going to create yet another version of “A Christmas Carol” — IMDB lists 60 other film and television adaptations — you’ve got to bring something besides over-the-top special effects and unsettling animation to the table.

Follow msnbc.com Movie Critic Alonso Duralde at http://www.twitter.com/MSNBCalonso.

© 2013 msnbc.com.  Reprints


Discussion comments


Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments

More on TODAY.com

  1. Joan Lunden: 10 things I wish I knew before I was diagnosed with breast cancer

    From the moment you hear the words ‘You have breast cancer,’ it’s almost like you’re shot out of a cannon. Here are 10 things I wish I knew before I was diagnosed.

    10/1/2014 10:52:45 AM +00:00 2014-10-01T10:52:45
  2. Want to help? A guide to breast cancer charities

    In the United States an estimated 296,000 women and 2,240 men will be diagnosed with breast cancer this year and almost 40,000 women and 410 men will die of the disease. That's one death every 14 minutes, according to the National Breast Cancer Coalition.

    10/1/2014 10:45:11 AM +00:00 2014-10-01T10:45:11
  3. Samantha Okazaki / TODAY
  1. Nbc News

    9 things we learned from Brian Williams' Facebook chat

    10/2/2014 1:41:28 AM +00:00 2014-10-02T01:41:28
  1. Noel Vasquez / Getty Images Contributor

    Mila Kunis,  Ashton Kutcher welcome baby girl

    10/2/2014 1:24:09 AM +00:00 2014-10-02T01:24:09
  1. Kevin Lamarque / Reuters

    Secret Service director resigns amid scandal

    10/1/2014 7:30:52 PM +00:00 2014-10-01T19:30:52
  1. Texas Ebola patient had contact with kids

    Texas Gov. Rick Perry said in a press conference on Wednesday that “some school-age children” had been identified as having contact with the man diagnosed with the first case of Ebola in the United States. 

    10/1/2014 5:37:52 PM +00:00 2014-10-01T17:37:52