1. Headline
  1. Headline

Video: Doctor analyzes ‘Girl Who Cries Blood’

TODAY contributor
updated 9/11/2009 11:00:51 AM ET 2009-09-11T15:00:51

The pictures are striking. Streams of blood seem to flow from a 14-year-old girl’s eyes and spring spontaneously from her scalp and feet.

Some say it’s a miracle. Some say it’s a mystery. Still others call it witchcraft or sorcery. And a doctor who examined her said it more likely is a manifestation of a mental illness called Munchausen syndrome.

Whatever it is, Dr. George Buchanan, who traveled to India to examine the girl called Twinkle for a special on National Geographic Channel, says it’s unlike anything he’s seen before in a long career as a pediatrician.

“This is really a first for me,” Buchanan told TODAY’s Al Roker Friday in New York. “I can’t tell — I don’t know where [the blood] comes from.”

  1. More from TODAY.com
    1. Purple Heart sent to 'Slender Man' victim: When a gift needs no thanks

      After an anonymous military veteran sent his Purple Heart medal to the survivor of the Slender Man stabbing in Wisconsin, ...

    2. The 5 best exercises for tank top-worthy arms
    3. Michigan jail trades trendy 'Orange' inmate uniforms for timeless sailor stripes
    4. See for your selfie: 'The Rock' pumps up fans with hard work on Instagram
    5. Millionaires really are different; they don't want to retire!

Elaborate hoax?
What Buchanan does know after observing two of Twinkle’s bleeding episodes is that neither he nor anyone else except her mother has ever seen the bleeding begin — only the results of it. And he wasn’t able to find any wounds or lesions in her scalp when the bleeding has occurred there. Pictures of the girl show streams of blood under her eyes — but not necessarily originating there.

The doctor said more tests are needed, but his surmise is that it may all be an elaborate hoax engineered by the girl or by the girl and her mother.

“I think this is something that has been purposely brought on,” Buchanan told Roker.

There’s a medical term for what Buchanan suspects: Munchausen syndrome, named after Baron Karl Munchausen, a German nobleman who became famous in the 18th century for the fabulous tales he told about himself, including riding a cannonball and flying to the moon.

People with the syndrome imagine symptoms and may physically cause them. Alternatively, Buchanan said, Twinkle’s mother may be the one with the syndrome and could be transferring the symptoms to her daughter. Such transference is called Munchausen syndrome by proxy.

“I don’t know where the blood comes from. I can’t tell how. It seems to be her blood, but where it’s coming from, I’m not sure,” Buchanan said.

When Roker asked if the girl’s mother could be involved in the mysterious bleeding, Buchanan said, “There’s good reason to think she probably is.”

No wounds
Buchanan is a pediatrician at the University of Texas Southwestern and Children’s Medical Center in Dallas, and has more than 30 years of experience. When he was asked by National Geographic to go to India to examine Twinkle, he said he was dubious.

Twinkle’s scalp has been observed to shed blood as well as her eyes.
“When I heard her story even before I left, it sounded very suspicious to me. I had not seen bleeding conditions like this before. The doctors in India suspected that as well,” he told Roker.

Beyond that is simple medical fact: “When one looks at her, there’s no obvious cuts or scrapes or scratches or wounds; this seems to come right through the skin and the eyes, and medical science just has no good explanation for that. There’s no mechanism by which blood can spontaneously come through the skin and from the eyes as medical science understands it.

“This really does raise the question: Is this being faked in some way, or is the blood being placed there or put there by Twinkle?”

Since no one other than Twinkle’s mother — and perhaps her co-conspirator — has seen the bleeding begin, that remains the big question.

Pediatrician Dr. George Buchanan said that he cannot determine for certain where the blood that Twinkle sheds comes from.

There are discrepancies in the accounts Twinkle’s mother gave of her daughter’s history, Buchanan said. The mother said she had to take the girl out of school when she began bleeding 2½ years ago — but, the doctor learned, Twinkle was removed from school before the bleeding episodes began.

Also, the mother described her daughter as being weak and sickly, but Buchanan saw her as a normal teenager — talkative, generally happy and interacting with others.

Buchanan said that Twinkle describes mild pain at times, but does not seem to suffer significant discomfort. But her life is clearly being disrupted.

“I feel bad for her. This has affected her life in significant ways,” he concluded. “I really think this is a psychiatric problem.”

“The Girl Who Cries Blood” premieres Sunday, Sept. 13, at 9 p.m. ET on National Geographic Channel.

© 2013 NBCNews.com  Reprints


Discussion comments


More on TODAY.com

  1. Courtesy Aldrich Family

    ‘Extraordinary’ 8-year-old boy finishes triathlon with his disabled brother

    7/22/2014 4:35:28 PM +00:00 2014-07-22T16:35:28
  1. Feds ban airlines from flying to Tel Aviv airport

    Federal aviation officials issued an order to airlines prohibiting them from flying to and from Tel Aviv’s Ben Gurion International Airport for 24 hours after a rocket struck near the airport earlier Tuesday.

    7/22/2014 5:43:01 PM +00:00 2014-07-22T17:43:01
  2. Dutch collect DNA to match with MH17 victims
  1. Pool / Reuters

    Prince George's birthday: The royal tot's 10 cutest moments

    7/22/2014 1:11:51 PM +00:00 2014-07-22T13:11:51
  1. Khakimullin Aleksandr / Shutterstock / Khakimullin Aleks

    The 5 best exercises for tank top-worthy arms

    7/22/2014 8:56:50 PM +00:00 2014-07-22T20:56:50
  1. Coke is a stain remover? 6 surprising cleaners in your home

    From those annoying white deodorant stains on your little black dress to rust stains in the commode, some stains just won't go away — until now. With help from some savvy experts, we put together surprising tips to banish these stains once and for all.

    7/22/2014 4:48:22 PM +00:00 2014-07-22T16:48:22
  1. Robyn Beck / AFP - Getty Images

    Chris Pratt wows us — and his wife — on 'Guardians' red carpet

    7/22/2014 7:16:22 PM +00:00 2014-07-22T19:16:22