1. Headline
  1. Headline
By
msnbc.com contributor
updated 3/24/2008 1:58:18 PM ET 2008-03-24T17:58:18
Commentary

Are we being sold a bill of goods about the number of patients waiting for transplants in the United States? There is reason to think so.

  1. More from TODAY.com
    1. Hoda, one of People's Most Beautiful, gets a congratulatory foot rub from KLG

      Lupita Nyong'o may have taken the title of People magazine's Most Beautiful Person of 2014, but Hoda Kotb made the list as...

    2. Prince William, Duchess Kate try their hand at the DJ decks
    3. 'Bachelorette' contestant Eric Hill dies after paragliding accident
    4. Embarrassing or excellent? Dad spoofs selfie taken by son
    5. 9 foods to 'spring clean' your diet 

The United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) is the Richmond, Va.-based organization that holds the federal contract for distributing organs to those awaiting transplants in the U.S. UNOS says there are about 98,000 people who need transplants. But, a recent story in the Washington Post shows that about one-third of those are actually not eligible for an organ transplant on any given day.

What is going on? If UNOS and the transplant community are inflating the numbers to make the shortfall in organs seem worse than it really is, they risk losing the trust of the American people. That trust is the ethical foundation for organ donation in this country.

If one checks the UNOS waiting list for people who are "inactive," or ineligible to receive an organ, some startling facts emerge. More than 7,000 patients with renal failure have been on the ineligible list for more than two years. So have hundreds of others with a failing heart, liver or pancreas. Although some patients awaiting transplants are going to bounce on and off the list because of other chronic health problems, the number who remain inactive for two years or more cries out for some sort of explanation.

Some of the reasons patients become inactive on the UNOS list make sense. Some patients take themselves off the list. Others cannot be found for one reason or another. Some need to lose weight in order to survive a procedure, while others are temporarily too sick.

But there are large numbers of people sitting inactive on the list because their medical work-up is not complete, or because of insurance or paperwork issues. These are not such good reasons.

Absolute honesty
How well do patients understand an inactive classification? If one transplant center thinks patients don't have enough money, or cannot complete their paperwork in a timely manner, do patients realize they can try to enroll in another one? Why is UNOS allowing people on the list to twist in the wind? If medical work-ups are not getting done, where does the problem lie?

The American people have every right to expect that the numbers given for those waiting for transplants are absolutely accurate. If non-medical reasons are making it hard to receive a transplant, they should be widely known so that something can be done about them.

Truth is, even if you take off a third of those on transplant lists, the need for organs still far outstrips the supply. However, those who are waiting need to know that they have the same shot at getting a transplant as anyone else, no matter where their transplant center is. The American people have a right to expect absolute honesty about the number of people waiting for a transplant at any time. These are problems that demand attention from those who
help pay the bill for transplants — you and me.

Arthur Caplan, Ph.D., is director of the Center for Bioethics at the University of Pennsylvania.

© 2013 msnbc.com.  Reprints

Discuss:

Discussion comments

,

Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments

More on TODAY.com

  1. Pool / Getty Images

    Prince William, Duchess Kate try their hand at the DJ decks

    4/23/2014 4:30:48 PM +00:00 2014-04-23T16:30:48
  1. 9 foods to 'spring clean' your diet 

    Want to wring out your system as part of the annual spring cleaning? Skip the weird (and often dangerous) detox diets or cleanses.

    4/23/2014 11:10:55 AM +00:00 2014-04-23T11:10:55
  1. Lupita Nyong’o is People magazine’s Most Beautiful person

    The Oscar winner with the perfect smile and the style to match beams from a cover that promises "her inspiring story.

    4/23/2014 11:54:41 AM +00:00 2014-04-23T11:54:41
  2. video Actress tells Savannah: Oscar win has opened doors

    video After a tremendous year for the actress, including winning an Oscar for her breakout role in “12 years a Slave,” and now being selected as People magazine’s Most Beautiful person, Lupita Nyong’o reflects on her rising fame in an exclusive interview with TODAY’s Savannah Guthrie.

    4/23/2014 12:35:32 PM +00:00 2014-04-23T12:35:32
  3. slideshow Her flawless looks: See Lupita’s colorful wardrobe

    slideshow Bright yellow, sky blue, rich red, shimmering gold — there's not a color that the fashionably adventurous Oscar-winning actress hasn't conquered.

    4/23/2014 1:40:41 PM +00:00 2014-04-23T13:40:41
  4. Reuters; AP
  1. Courtesy of Savannah Guthrie

    Savannah’s honeymoon dispatch: Letting it hang out on the best vacation ever

    4/23/2014 10:56:55 AM +00:00 2014-04-23T10:56:55