Don't fear the riesling.
For all its versatility and charm, this noble grape continues to scare off many wine lovers. That goes double for German riesling, often the world’s best and almost assuredly its most intimidating.
Some of this anxiety comes from German wines' uneven legacy among U.S. drinkers, what you might call the Blue Nun problem. Many Americans' sole contact with these wines has involved hastily made wines of marginal quality, stuck in garish blue bottles and sold on the cheap. German Liebfraumilch of the 1970s and ‘80s, meant for quick drinking in export markets, was only partially riesling (and ho-hum stuff at that), blended with workhorse grapes like müller-thurgau and silvaner. It was to good riesling what “Must Love Dogs” is to “Casablanca.”
None of this has been helped by the thicket of exotic words and abbreviations found on typical German wine labels, which require the vinous equivalent of Cliff notes to parse. It’s a tall order to ask a wine drinker who’s finally straightened out zinfandel from merlot to comprehend the difference between kabinett and spätlese (two degrees of grape ripeness), or between QbA and QmP (two levels of wine quality).
Further complicating things are new simple-sounding terms approved by the German government. Words like “Classic” or “Selection” might have made sense to German consumers, but more than a few drinkers on these shores have been surprised to find that “Classic” riesling — which amounts to a kabinett riesling that's higher in alcohol and may have sugar added — is bone-dry, with none of that sweet edge that typifies most imported riesling.
The move was “exorbitantly stupid,” says Thomas Haehn of Rudi Wiest Selections, one of the top American importers of riesling. “They really just looked at it from a German perspective.”
Recent vintages are a puzzle, too. Riesling lovers are still speaking (in hushed tones, since there’s so little left on the market) of the amazing 2001 vintage, in which late-ripening grapes offered up wines in perfect balance. More recently, the blazing heat of Europe’s 2003 summer created fat wines with less acidity and more lushness: beautiful for lovers of an over-the-top style, though many wines ended up flabby, like fruit salad. In between are 2002 and 2004, more traditional years with lots of wines that balance sweet and tart.
Why bother, if it’s all so complex? For one, German riesling is a perfect food wine, low in alcohol (often under 10 percent), with acidity to cut through fatty dishes and sweetness to match spicy Asian cuisine and fish. Beyond that, you can easily indulge in some terrific wines for under $25 — if you pick carefully.
To help gauge how the latest batches from Germany stack up against their global competition, I enlisted the help of Bob Betz, a Master of Wine and formerly a vice president at Stimson Lane Vineyards (now known as Chateau Ste. Michelle) in Washington state. He invited Bob Bertheau, who as Ste. Michelle's head winemaker for white wines is in charge of the largest production of riesling in the world, including a collaboration with German riesling impresario Ernst Loosen on Washington's celebrated Eroica bottling. Both men can quote chapter and verse on this grape.
Some conclusions from our tasting, a global sampling of 20 rieslings not only from several regions of Germany but also New Zealand and even Colorado:
1. Frustratingly, when it comes to German riesling, money and value really do correlate. While we found a few standouts among basic QbA rieslings (the bottom tier for quality wines), the best wines under $25 are still found at the kabinett level and up. An upside of the ’03 vintage? Many kabinetts were made from riper grapes but not classified that way, so you can find great wines for less money.
More from TODAY.com
Social media tipsters hope to solve Philadelphia hate crime case
Social media sometimes gets a bad rap as the scourge of modern society, but in Philadelphia this week, police are hopeful ...
- Family lauds Miranda Lambert for concert gesture
- Why one dad hates homework as much as his kid does
- Mom's home! Toddler ignores military protocol, runs into soldier's arms
- For the win: TODAY fans pass along pics of their girls on the gridiron
- Social media tipsters hope to solve Philadelphia hate crime case
2. “Branded” rieslings — those with catchy names that have no official meaning — can be charming introductory wines, but many lack depth. At one point, they were described as “Dolly Parton wines,” with lots of flash upfront and nothing on the finish. Full apologies were quickly made to Ms. Parton.
3. The biggest shortfall with many of these wines came in a bitter or muted finish. Bertheau is one of the few winemakers who talks about tannins (those mouth-drying compounds) in white wine. Bertheau chalked up the finish problems to poor tannin handling.
4. That said, the German samplings still had more delicacy and structure than many American rieslings. (My conclusion, not theirs.)
5. It ain’t Germany, but Colorado makes some darn good riesling.
If your memories of German riesling are unpleasant, now is the time to give it another go. Despite a weak dollar, great values abound. It’s a wine that even drinkers who fear big, heavy red wines can love without feeling lowbrow.
In fact, it’s a grape that some of the world's most learned wine scholars choose as their personal favorite. Consider it the anti-chardonnay — misunderstood and underappreciated, yet as sublime as wine gets.
Just steer clear of those blue bottles.
We sought out good examples of riesling for under $25. In addition to our tasting with the two winemakers, we sampled more than a dozen other wines. These eight show a range of styles and tastes. Some are basic rieslings, others are from single vineyards. Three are good examples of “branded” wines. Oh, and those hints of “petrol” in some wines? Don't worry: It's a subtle, classic mineral aroma in good riesling, not an indicator your wine sat too long at the gas station.
St. Urbans-Hof 2004 Mosel-Saar-Ruwer (HB Wine Merchants, $10): Best deal of the bunch. Bracing and focused, with ripe mango, kiwi and citrus, and a clear-cut structure. The finish is long and clean, with all the right pieces in place. An entry-level bottling, which makes it all the more impressive.
Fritz-Haag 2004 kabinett Estate Mosel-Saar-Ruwer (Rudi Wiest Selections, $18): Crisp and clean, with just a hint of sweetness playing in the background. It’s all right angles and well-defined lines, lean and racy and made for a meal.
Loosen 2004 “Dr. L” Mosel-Saar-Ruwer (Valckenberg, $10): Ernst Loosen remains one of Germany's most charismatic and talented winemakers, and his entry-level riesling is a consistently good starting point. The most recent vintage shows off those classic citrus and mineral notes of the Mosel, with a pleasant tapered finish.
Dr. H. Thanisch 2004 kabinett Wehlener Sonnenuhr (Winesellers, Ltd., $17): Stoic and stony, with hints of tangerine peel, richness upfront and a mostly dry character. Finishes lush too, and yet it’s never heavy (at just 8.5 percent alcohol).
Zilliken 2004 “Butterfly” Mosel-Saar-Ruwer (Rudi Wiest, $14): Delicate and nectary, it’s medium-dry with a hint of spritz and light minerality to back up the melon and citrus scents. Finishes long. Refreshing and young, and yet still a serious wine. The rare combo: a riesling from a tiny estate with a long history (and reportedly the deepest cellar in the Saar region) that adopts an brand name but doesn’t pander to the obvious.
Mönchhof 2004 “Mosel Slate” spätlese Mosel-Saar-Ruwer (Rudi Wiest Selections, $18): This traditional Mosel estate has ventured into the practice of branding its wines, and here’s one that lives up to the name. The slate notes are unmistakable. It’s floral and lean, and a juicy acidity sears through some tropical notes. A classic dose of Mosel minerality.
S.A. Prum 2003 spätlese Gracher Himmelreich (Palm Bay Imports, $22): Big, shimmering petrol notes, with baking spice, peach nectar and ripe pear underneath. The minerality is razor-sharp, an austere center in the midst of all that rich fruit. Finishes long and crisp. Forget Dolly Parton; this is a Scarlett Johansson wine: Bold and lush upfront, with a no-nonsense complexity once you’re past the first blush.
Fitz-Ritter 2002 spätlese Ungsteiner Herrenberg (Winesellers Ltd., $20): This standout hails from the Pfalz, Germany’s warmest riesling region (warm being a relative term). Big classic petrol notes, with peach, lemon and a creamy texture wrapped around a stiff mineral backbone. That Pfalz richness stands out amid honey scents, and finishes with an aromatic punch. A wine in perfect balance.
© 2013 msnbc.com Reprints