American Idol

'American Idol's' success on the charts: 11 winners, 230 No. 1s

Dec. 6, 2012 at 3:29 PM ET

Jordan Strauss / AP /
Country music singer-songwriter Carrie Underwood, who took top honors in "Idol's" fourth season, is among the chart-topping past winners.

The winners take it all: Season 11 winner Philip Phillips is the only "American Idol" sitting at No. 1 on the Billboard charts this week, as his album "The World from the Side of the Moon" spends a second week in pole position on the Top Rock Albums chart, while his single “Home” is No. 1 for the fifth week on Triple A Audience and for the fourth week on Triple A. All 11 of the series winners have collected No. 1s on the Billboard charts, but who has had the most chart-toppers, and who has spent the most weeks in first place?

Here’s an accounting of how many No. 1s each "Idol" winner has earned, counting all national, domestic charts compiled by Billboard:

Kelly Clarkson 79

Carrie Underwood 65

Fantasia 31

Ruben Studdard 16

Scotty McCreery 10

David Cook 8

Jordin Sparks 7

Phillip Phillips 6

Kris Allen 4

Taylor Hicks 3

Lee DeWyze 1

That’s a total of 230 No. 1s, out of the 370 chart-toppers scored by all "Idol" contestants.

The order of Idols is slightly different when you count up the total number of weeks each of these 11 winners have spent leading the various Billboard charts:

Kelly Clarkson 289

Carrie Underwood 246

Fantasia 114

Kris Allen 52

Ruben Studdard 49

David Cook 34

Phillip Phillips 17

Scotty McCreery 15

Taylor Hicks 11

Jordin Sparks 8

Lee DeWyze 1

That represents 836 weeks spent on top of the Billboard charts.

The biggest difference between the two lists is the rise of Kris Allen from ninth place among "Idols" with the most No. 1s to fourth place among "Idols" with the most weeks on top. His four No. 1s spent a total of 52 weeks in first place, mainly thanks to the 24-week reigns of “Live Like We’re Dying” on both the Christian Digital Songs and Christian/Gospel Digital Songs charts.

Kelly Clarkson is ahead of Carrie Underwood on both lists, but Underwood has the longest-running No. 1 of any Idol. Clarkson’s chart-topper with the lengthiest rule is “Breakaway,” her song from "The Princess Diaries 2" that held sway over the Adult Contemporary Audience chart for 28 weeks. Underwood’s first album, "Some Hearts," was No. 1 on Top Country Albums for 27 weeks and then set the all-time record by leading the Top Country Catalog Albums chart for 41 weeks.

PHOTOS: 7 Most Popular Christmas Songs From Radio

THE XMAS FACTOR: Every week that takes us closer to Christmas brings more holiday songs to the Billboard charts, and the Idols continue to occupy a great number of slots on the various tallies. Scotty McCreery’s "Christmas With Scotty McCreery" rebounds 21-12 with a bullet on The Billboard 200, is up 6-4 on Top Country Albums, holds at No. 5 on Top Holiday Albums and re-enters Top Internet Albums at No. 20. Jordin Sparks’ single “Do You Hear What I Hear” blasts into the top 10 of the Adult Contemporary chart with a 15-8 leap and is up 4-3 on the Adult Contemporary Audience list. Jason Castro’s "Gloria (Hark! The Herald Angels Sing/Angels We Have Heard On High)" debuts at No. 35 on the Christian Songs chart, where Mandisa’s “It’s Christmas” rockets 42-23 with a bullet.

BITS AND PIECES: Carrie Underwood’s “Two Black Cadillacs” hasn’t debuted on The Billboard Hot 100 yet, but it’s driving in the right direction, entering the Bubbling Under the Hot 100 chart at No. 19… Frenchie Davis’ “Love’s Got a Hold on Me” breaks into the top 20 of the Hot Dance Club Play chart with a hike of 24-19 (with a bullet)… Australian Idol Guy Sebastian holds at No. 5 on the singles chart from down under with his new release, “Get Along.” It’s the follow-up to his collaboration with Lupe Fiasco on “Battle Scars,” which is down 17-23 in its 16th week on the chart. The new single helps lift the parent album, "Armageddon," 4-1 in its seventh week on the Australian album chart. There’s also an American Idol on the Australian album chart, as Kelly Clarkson’s "Greatest Hits – Chapter One" debuts at No. 20.

Are you surprised by how well the "Idol" winners have done on the charts? Tell us on our Facebook page.

Related content:

More in The Clicker:

TOP